https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo Made with a lightning strike of genius en-us 2021-05-11 19:53:37 UTC 2023-05-23 03:07:37 UTC hello@padlet.com tara_divittorio https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/1515089083 Submit your your response to the following question: Do you think there is any justification for Bruno denying his friendship with Shmuel? & respond to at least one classmate. Please remember that your feedback must be kind and thoughtful as well as constructive. This means I’m looking for more than “This is Great!” Some sentence starters might be: I was impressed by.... OR Did you notice that....... OR What did you mean when you wrote.....]]> 2021-05-11 19:53:37 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/1515089083 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/1775684934 I think Bruno is a spoiled and clueless brat, but he also doesn't want to get into trouble. I probably would've lied about it too.]]> 2021-09-28 18:54:41 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/1775684934 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/1876167133 I think that Bruno was justified in denying his friendship with Shmuel. He wanted to protect himself and his friend, so he denied that they were friends.]]> 2021-11-08 19:36:09 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/1876167133 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/1916653329 I think it's clear that Bruno lied to protect himself whether or not he was trying to protect Shmuel in the process. I think he had good reasoning and it could've ended way worse than his sister thinking he's weird.]]> 2021-11-28 21:57:58 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/1916653329 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/1918671575 I think his lie was and wasn't justified. On one hand he told the lie because he didn't want to share Shmuel with his sister. Even though he started thinking she was just as lonely as he was. However, on the other hand  by telling her the lie he was able to protect Shmuel, even though he probably knew she would tease him for it.]]> 2021-11-29 18:27:24 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/1918671575 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/1919055229 Amaya M]]> 2021-11-29 21:59:31 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/1919055229 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/1919096810 Bruno lied to protect them both, but Bruno lied mostly to protect himself. ]]> 2021-11-29 22:35:56 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/1919096810 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2127611426 bruno lie was to protect himself and his friendship with shmuel but mostly himself ]]> 2022-04-03 23:42:21 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2127611426 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2131586347 I really think that it was a good idea. I think that without it he would never see his friend again and then never be allowed outside.]]> 2022-04-05 23:21:14 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2131586347 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2152380268 I think it was a good idea for Bruno to not tell Gretel the truth. If Bruno had said the truth it would've gotten him in trouble and possibly make him not allowed to leave the house. But just imagine what Shmuel would've gone through if Father found out. 
~Brynlee E]]> 2022-04-21 16:59:25 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2152380268 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2157524931 It's clear that Bruno finds some type of companionship within his relationship with Shmuel, especially considering his circumstances. Bruno lied because he couldn't take any chances with someone knowing about his and Shmuel's relationship and potentially ending it. I believe Bruno had every right to lie out of fear he'd lose his one friend in "Out-With". 
-Dejah-Jade R.]]> 2022-04-26 00:24:12 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2157524931 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2191748157 I think it is smart to not tell Gretel about Shmuel, not because Bruno wants him all to himself but because it could backfire, and Gretel could tell someone else like mother or father on accident. Jonathan D.]]> 2022-05-19 17:41:06 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2191748157 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2336542389 I think that it is understandable because from the way he put it; it seems that he is sneaking out when his mom is sleeping to go see Shmuel and if they found out they might stop him from talking to his new friend. -Talon R.]]> 2022-10-12 06:59:28 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2336542389 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2387306114 I think he did it because he doesn't want to get in trouble or get shmuel in trouble. Christian T]]> 2022-11-16 20:58:32 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2387306114 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2390603453 I think it was very justifiable. By doing this he is probably saving the life of Shmuel, and maybe even others. I don't think what he did was selfish at all.]]> 2022-11-19 01:22:38 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2390603453 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2392951253 I think that Bruno is justified in denying his friendship with Shmuel. Bruno thinks that if anyone in his family finds out about Shmuel then they will not let him go visit him anymore. By him keeping it a secret it is probably saving Shmuel's life. Sam A]]> 2022-11-21 17:24:48 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2392951253 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2411905036 i think so. Bruno who lost his 3 best friends for life doesn't want to take any chances on losing any more friends.]]> 2022-12-07 09:21:29 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2411905036 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2438266318 I think he did because if he had said anything Grettel might have snitch and then they would be forced to no longer be friends.]]> 2023-01-09 18:39:54 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2438266318 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2443181354 I think his justification to denying his relationship is due to him just loosing a bunch of friends, as well as him scared of what Gretel might do if she found out.]]> 2023-01-13 05:30:30 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2443181354 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2446039982 I think there is a little bit of justification for Bruno lying. He is young and lost his 3 best friends, he doesn't want to loose anymore. ]]> 2023-01-16 20:41:37 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2446039982 hydetyler7 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2546025804 I think there is justification because Bruno does not know what will happen to Shmuel if his family finds out that they are friends. Bruno already had to move away from three of his friends, he doesn't want to lose another one. ]]> 2023-04-06 07:47:52 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2546025804 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2555266934 I think their is justification because Shmuel could get really hurt if Bruno speaks out about him.]]> 2023-04-15 11:52:15 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2555266934 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2574177256 There is complete justification for Bruno keeping Shmuel a secret. Bruno's father is a Nazi soldier and if he learned that Bruno was communicating with a Jew, Shmuel would be in terrible danger. Not to mention Bruno would definitely not be able to see Shmuel anymore. ]]> 2023-05-01 20:06:59 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2574177256 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2574525195 I think its justified because in Shmuel is Bruno's only friend in the Out - With, and after losing his other friends he wants something for himself. As he says he doesn't want to "Share him." Another reason this is justified is because of his father position as a Nazi solider, would cause Bruno's friend to get hurt, as well as completely losing his friendship with him. If Bruno doesn't keep his friendship secret, he could accidently cause Shmuel's death. ]]> 2023-05-02 03:03:59 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2574525195 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2575661172 I think there is much justification for Bruno denying his friendship with Shmuel. Bruno does not want to get him or Shmuel in trouble for being friends. This shows that Bruno really does care about Shmuel. ]]> 2023-05-02 19:03:14 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2575661172 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2575827685 It was justified because Bruno's father is a nazi and Shmuel could be hurt or killed if caught talking to Bruno.]]> 2023-05-02 22:37:08 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2575827685 https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2600961390 Bruno was justified in denying his friendship because he did not want to get in trouble for going where his parents told him not to. Bruno doesn't really understand the trouble he could cause Shmuel, but the reality is coming slowly]]> 2023-05-23 03:02:14 UTC https://padlet.com/tara_divittorio/h6ulpbugfwg39bqo/wish/2600961390