LA6020-502 Phase IV Review by Duarte Santo https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review LA6020-502 Phase IV Presentations 11 May 2020 en-us 2020-05-11 13:24:54 UTC 2020-05-11 21:16:56 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565057782 it seems like you have spent a lot of time creating your design in plan view and representing that in an attractive way. although it has worked, because you don't have other views (sections, perspectives, sketches, etc.) your design idea doesn't come through. even simple drawings would be helpful]]> 2020-05-11 14:41:18 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565057782 https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565096680 your plan is amazing - well done rendering it and realizing the pencil drawing you started with]]> 2020-05-11 14:53:34 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565096680 https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565178335 love your ideas and the way you represented them. massive improvements. that said, I felt like your presentation was almost cut short and you had more drawings to do in order to fully communicate your design ideas. ]]> 2020-05-11 15:19:46 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565178335 Edge Conditions https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565207885 Expressed in the analysis about "sensorial shifts" and how the ice reacts to the edge and body of water creating push/pulling. However, the plan/ sections do not show this being considered. The layout focuses more on the positioning of the farmer's market and the parking lot, creating a very formal layout. Would like to see more of an exploration of the edges and reaction with ice and during other seasons. Do the cut ins actually respond more to runoff rather than water level fluctuations? 

]]> 2020-05-11 15:29:18 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565207885 Wilderness Gradient https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565217334 How much more can incorporate a natural vegetation edge. Think about the possible uses of allowing canoe launch or making a pond where people can have more fun public engagement with shallow body of water to convince maintaining as a feature. ]]> 2020-05-11 15:32:27 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565217334 programming https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565224626 What in the proposal can generate more interactions with varying groups. Also variation with leisure, sports fields, for example. ]]> 2020-05-11 15:34:48 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565224626 https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565230384  What was blue and what was red in terms of the experience? Appreciate the section enlargements. Having more near the boat dock would be beneficial. It would be helpful more than the perspectives along with tying back into the sensorial diagram. The project appears a little reductive. The intervention doesn't seem to actually mitigate flooding. One thing that happens here is the catchment of sediment and you can start thinking about incorporating it into the design. The experiential is the real key here so try and tie back to that. ]]> 2020-05-11 15:36:41 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565230384 https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565230744 kind of hard to locate where the sections are on the plan. Appreciating the hierarchy of movement. More sections and more enlargements would help. The topo can interact with each other in certain ways with the flow of water. Analysis logic flowed well. Also, exploring the type of materials of the paths and how it connects to the surrounding area
Appreciate the stakeholder comments. A couple of things to consider: thinking about the connection of the building to the landscape can be helpful. A little concerned about a farmers market overflow space because it questions the design of the new building. Also, the building footprint seems similar to the existing, explores how going bigger might look. The second iteration that shows connects to the water are things to really look into. i.e. other programs as well, weddings, proms, kayak berthing. Ramping down features and docking can be more located in the next iteration. Still some questions about parking especially the people that are mobility impaired. 
]]> 2020-05-11 15:36:48 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565230744 https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565231386 The focus on water is intriguing due to the length of the season here. The design is still very diagrammatic and raises questions about the actual design. Can dredge be incorporated to raise the elevation of the island? Flood elevations and sections and what birds are tied to the landscape would be helpful. The idea of the dock part submerged should be explored more particularly with the material being used. Explore the drawings through big sections would help a lot. what's not helping is the portrait layout. Make drawings landscape orientation. 

]]> 2020-05-11 15:36:59 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565231386 https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565231927 What are the drivers of the plan that establish this design? That would be helpful to explain and diagram before coming into the plan. Enlarging certain parts to let us know exactly what's going on. The method seems to be in align with the concept but the reading from the work is hard to understand. The idea of the interface and experimental site is intriguing but in the plan, it seems wet/dry. Not clear how all edges are being considered. Run some scenarios i.e. greenhouses flooding or are the in upland areas? 

]]> 2020-05-11 15:37:11 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565231927 https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565232543  How was the diagram flow pattern arrived at (slide 13). Somewhat confused with the sequence from programming to the flowy diagram. Currently not reading the plan as a stitched fabric. Ask how you can be inspired by this piet appraoch, perhaps using hatches? Never got a comprehensive analysis of the site being worked on right now. How do the interventions resolve some of the issues. No way of knowing of what the design is doing address issues. When the abstract drawing gets translated, it seems to plan focused, think about topo weaving as well. Also the idea of weaving in time, since the water is dynamic.  ]]> 2020-05-11 15:37:23 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565232543 https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565233330 Right now the sensory pods are somewhat missing. The ecotone diagram, how can it be more applied to the site? Consider seasonal gardens? Think about reconsidering the material of the paths as well that are being presented. Think about the character of the paths. Are these arches presented as portals for specific conditions? Understand them as conditional changes along the path.Think about how these forms can be connected. 

]]> 2020-05-11 15:37:38 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565233330 https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565240845 I think you could be more editorial with the drawings you show in order to communicate your process and reasoning for your design decisions. also, I think being more clear on why you designed the site like you did. Was it just to create a natural edge, or is it serving a purpose?]]> 2020-05-11 15:39:58 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565240845 https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565255171 keep a small plan for reference while showing your detailed sections, for context. 
number of sections is very helpful though]]> 2020-05-11 15:44:25 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565255171 Sourcing https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565264551 Show data of where water level comes from ]]> 2020-05-11 15:47:18 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565264551 Storm water runoff https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565266507 Where does the runoff go from the parking lots. Are your ponds addressing that? Can help make argument for design]]> 2020-05-11 15:47:52 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565266507 https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565280514 express dynamics through diagrams and collages. Right now a lot of things are being discussed over a plan.]]> 2020-05-11 15:52:00 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565280514 https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565323690 integration of 6-ft grid and vertical and horizontal topography was well done. it doesn't look like two separate ideas - it looks like one. but id like to see more perspectives or section elevations to understand the design better. ]]> 2020-05-11 16:05:44 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565323690 Smell https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565330089 Introduce prevailing winds in relationship to point source of smells]]> 2020-05-11 16:07:47 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565330089 drawing styles https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565337014 can you use drawing styles or same color palette across drawings to help connect them visually?]]> 2020-05-11 16:09:56 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565337014 informing decisions https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565375171 Use past work to help inform addressing issues in the landscape]]> 2020-05-11 16:22:08 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565375171 process https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565386540 clearly thought about how design of certain forms can create topo changes over time. 
sediment axon and perspectives are great - nice style. 
as critics said, need to link design to analysis in a more clear way

]]> 2020-05-11 16:25:43 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565386540 Connecting to Education Center https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565403405 Ithaca Youth program and linking to the sensorial. ]]> 2020-05-11 16:31:24 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565403405 expand the exploration of the 6 areas duartesanto https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565758867 zoom in and present each one of the areas as one slide including plan, sections, views axos and diagrams]]> 2020-05-11 18:41:27 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565758867 Tie your design back to the analysis (close the design process loop) duartesanto https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565761980 use your design proposal to question and identify the holes in your (presentation of the) analysis. 
i.e incorporate diagrams, data, charts from official sources when talking about water or vegetations or about birds or about cars or ..... everything that you address in your design proposal need to be identified in your research/analysis or diagnosis.

]]> 2020-05-11 18:42:46 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/565761980 underrepresented materiality duartesanto https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/566081886 explore the materiality of your projects by showing it through the plans, sections, models, etc]]> 2020-05-11 21:14:01 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/566081886 represent the experience of that landscape duartesanto https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/566084171 develop mixmedia outputs ]]> 2020-05-11 21:15:24 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/566084171 bring the sensorial back to your designs!!! duartesanto https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/566085688 underrepresented]]> 2020-05-11 21:16:22 UTC https://padlet.com/duartesanto/LA6020_Phase4_Review/wish/566085688