UNSDG Year 5 by Tunas Muda Meruya https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb Conflict en-us 2021-11-07 11:40:46 UTC 2026-01-25 19:24:54 UTC hello@padlet.com Write down your answer individually tmpypmeruya https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1872588780 Question: Should Indonesia handle the Afganisthan Refugee?

]]> 2021-11-07 11:44:47 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1872588780 Natalie https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876971861 Yes, they should try to build a shelter and provide some food and supplies. They can also try to offer to work to get some money.]]> 2021-11-09 02:31:20 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876971861 Carmell winonacarmellie https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876980912 Yes and no because Afghanistan isn't really safe but Indonesia is 14th on the covid rank.]]> 2021-11-09 02:34:49 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876980912 Reeve benedictdharmawan https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876981341 I think we should let them into Indonesia because they can't go back and maybe the people of Indonesia will donate to them so they can have a nice living in Indonesia. ]]> 2021-11-09 02:34:59 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876981341 Cherri cherrilouise https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876982384 I think yes, because we are showing lots of hospitality to the people. Maybe they should make a limit, because there might be a overpopulation. For the food and water?
Maybe they should ask other countries, to help? They could work themselves a house, and their own food and drinks?
Afghanistan is not really safe so I think yes.]]> 2021-11-09 02:35:22 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876982384 Kyran kyranleonarwo https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876984504 I think yes because they cant go back to Afghanistan and if Indonesian people donate to him, he can live nicely in Indonesia.]]> 2021-11-09 02:36:11 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876984504 Clarissa clarissamae https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876984751 They should only take a few thousand refugees at once give them what they need then let them go back and repeat that process over and over again. But in return the refugees have to work.
So, my answer is yes]]> 2021-11-09 02:36:16 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876984751 Jayden jaydentandiary https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876984871 I think we should just let them in for a while let The Indonesian people help them and if they have to let Indonesia be their home]]> 2021-11-09 02:36:19 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876984871 Marco marcofrederick https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876986406 We really need should provide them with some food and donate to them so they can have a nice living in Indonesia
and have a nice house]]> 2021-11-09 02:36:55 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876986406 Nicole https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876989997 Yes because they came to Indonesia and they can't go back, they don't have good food to eat and they have to stay inside a tent, so we should provide some shelter and good food for them.]]> 2021-11-09 02:38:16 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876989997 Aldrich aldrichathaya https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876990295 I think yes Indonesia should handle the Afghanisthan Refugee because, they can't really go back home because it's quite far and we can also donate to them so that they can afford to buy food and clean water. We can also donate to them so that they can buy/build a house. But we can also let them in just for a while.]]> 2021-11-09 02:38:23 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876990295 Axel https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876995612 Yes because they came to Indonesia and they can't go back so we can just donate some stuff too them. ]]> 2021-11-09 02:40:31 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1876995612 Godeliva godelivawidjaya https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877000992 I think yes because they already come here in Indonesia and They cannot go back. In my opinion we should let them stay in Indonesia and donate a little bit of money so they can buy enough foods and drink, and maybe when they are ready they can go back.]]> 2021-11-09 02:42:38 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877000992 Heidi heidinatio https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877002194 Yes because the Afghanistan is not safe and they can't go back, so we can provide health, food, and shelter.]]> 2021-11-09 02:43:05 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877002194 zoe https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877243420 i think we should accept them because they are still people and they need a home and we should take part in helping them if i were the government i would give them a free stay at a homeless shelter]]> 2021-11-09 04:44:47 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877243420 mikka gabrielmikka https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877243593 yes because we need to help them so we need to donate them to buy shelter, food, and others]]> 2021-11-09 04:44:53 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877243593 Josh joshdavid https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877244841 I think we should not let them in because maybe they are bad people or they can come from a country that is full of robbing and maybe when we let them in they can rob or steal us.

So, my answer is a very big NO

Except if there poor and homeless but not stealers.]]> 2021-11-09 04:45:34 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877244841 Gisella 5M gisellaclairicia https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877245449 My opinion is No. 
My reason is because Indonesia itself still suffer with a lot of poor people who still need helps from another country.
They still struggle how to get food and drink each day.
Even though I think Indonesia is a rich country but most of the people are not.]]> 2021-11-09 04:45:56 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877245449 Shawn shawntan2 https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877245898 I think yes, because they can't go back to Afganisthan so Indonesian people can donate to them so they can live happily]]> 2021-11-09 04:46:11 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877245898 Ryan :0 ryanrusman https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877245911 Yes, we should help them because they are poor, they don't have shelter, food, and comfort. The condition is getting worse because winter is approaching and most of the people don't have proper clothes and food for this weather. If we are willing to help we must move fast because soon no access to this country for medicine and food since the road will be blocked by snow.

Reference:

Afghanistan facing desperate food crisis, UN warns - BBC News]]> 2021-11-09 04:46:12 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877245911 Nathan https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877246721 Yes because we can accept them and they need help even though there might be problems we must help them. Link: https://www.nationalreview.com/2021/09/why-we-can-accept-afghan-refugees-and-should/]]> 2021-11-09 04:46:37 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877246721 Nicole Y https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877247408 Yes, we should help them because their are homeless and poor , they don't have house food and comfort stuff ]]> 2021-11-09 04:46:59 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877247408 Aldrich 5M https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877247815 I think yes because they have no where else to go.]]> 2021-11-09 04:47:13 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877247815 Aldo sebastianaldo https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877248795 Yes, I think it is the best that Indonesia handles to Afghanistan refugee. They have came to Indonesia in a long way because they are thriving to live. We should donate so they can afford and have longer lives. We can also help them provide food, water, and shelter. ]]> 2021-11-09 04:47:45 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877248795 Trisha trishaangelene https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877249278 Yes because we need to help them, we need to provide food and donate so they can hapily live in Indonesia and have a place to live.
Refugees come from all walks of life – they are farmers, factory workers, shopkeepers, mechanics, electricians, doctors, lawyers, politicians. What sets them apart from others is their need for international protection because of war, persecution due to their beliefs, and violations of their human rights.
Refugees cannot be protected by their own country as they were forced to flee from it. Therefore, their protection and assistance then becomes a matter of the responsibility of the international community.

https://www.unhcr.org/id/en/refugees
]]> 2021-11-09 04:48:01 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877249278 Kenny kennypratama https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877251023 yes because i think they don't have money or i think they think their country is dangerous so indonesia can donate money even more so my answer is YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES
(btw can the donation open so we can donate plz thx)]]> 2021-11-09 04:48:42 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877251023 Joseph https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877251339 Yes because Afghanistan stuck in Indonesian and maybe we need to help them by giving them food, big house or anything.]]> 2021-11-09 04:48:52 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877251339 Audrey audreychriselle https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877252140 I think yes because they can’t really go back to Afghanistan and don’t really have a house to live in, we can help them by donating to them, providing them food, shelter, and water.

In late 2016 the President of the Republic of Indonesia signed the Presidential Regulation on the Handling of Refugees, which contains key definitions and sets out processes for the detection, shelter and safeguarding of refugees and asylum-seekers.
Reference: https://www.unhcr.org/id/en/unhcr-in-indonesia
]]> 2021-11-09 04:49:21 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877252140 Yes i think they don't have money and they have no where else to go. chloemitchell5 https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877255294 2021-11-09 04:51:08 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877255294 Aislyn aislynsherrie https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877255898 Yes I really think that Indonesia should handle the Afghanistan refugees because Afghanistan is not that safe , there is kids and families who are in need of money, give them shelter, food, clothes, etc and maybe we could donate what they need  ]]> 2021-11-09 04:51:27 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877255898 Rafael rafaelbagaskara https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877257507 yes because Afghanistan isn't that safe and in Indonesia we should donate to them so they can eat and drink. so they can have a shelter]]> 2021-11-09 04:52:25 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877257507 Not Gavyn (yes this is a paragraph) maximiliangavyn https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877268133 We should accept them because Afghanistan  is a very poor country. The food there isn't really like food, and 97% of Afghanistan's population may sink below the poverty line. They have also come all the way from Afghanistan and Afghanistan is already far away, (6639 km away) so if we don't accept them, they have traveled 6639 km for nothing.

References:
https://www.livemint.com/news/world/97-of-afghan-population-could-plunge-into-poverty-by-mid-2022-undp-11631235190491.html

https://distancem.com/countries/from-afghanistan-to-indonesia]]> 2021-11-09 04:58:41 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877268133 Dennis 5M dennisgregory https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877277013 Yes (If I am a government) I would build a school that refugees go to so that they can get a good education and a big shelter for the refugees to live in.]]> 2021-11-09 05:04:15 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877277013 Hilda hildalaetitia https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877568674 Yes, but not for a long time because we also have to take care of our health too. But we can help them by giving them food, shelter, clean water and clothes.]]> 2021-11-09 07:59:22 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877568674 Charlize charlizenatalie https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877575772 Yes, they can stay in Indonesia. They’ve just got to hope that someone is kind enough to give them the resources in order for them to survive. But Indonesia isn’t really the safest country in the whole world, they need to protect theirselves from danger.]]> 2021-11-09 08:03:14 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877575772 Angel angelinabeatrice https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877746152 Yes, I think they need to handle the Afganisthan Refugee because the situation is kinda bad right now, and to make a better community. So its better to handle the Aganisthan Refugee by getting what they need to survive.]]> 2021-11-09 09:35:48 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877746152 Aldrich 5M aldrichjethro https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877747635 I think we should accept the refugees because they have travelled very far to get to Indonesia. Also I'm making another post because I can't edit my old one.]]> 2021-11-09 09:36:32 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877747635 Dennis 5M https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877888849 yes because Many of Afghanistan’s close neighbors have refused to provide havens. Instead, they have fortified border walls. Iran has set up camps along the border, although aid and assistance remain inadequate. Now is the time for Indonesia, with the largest Muslim population in the world, to address the more urgent crisis at hand.



]]> 2021-11-09 10:53:48 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877888849 Naomi omiomi1237 https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877952841 I think so because they have no home, no food, and less money. And god will always bless the ones who help others😊]]> 2021-11-09 11:31:32 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1877952841 Victoria victoriasusanto https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1878132492 Yes, I think Indonesia should handle the Afganisthan refugee. Give them food,clothes,shelter.]]> 2021-11-09 12:59:57 UTC https://padlet.com/tmpypmeruya/g46ofcxhe6vno9wb/wish/1878132492