1. From the movie scenes you have watched , what makes a great defense lawyer ? What makes a good and fair judge ? Give short examples from the scenes 2. Read your classmates' notes and leave a comment ( do you agree ? Why or Why not ? ) by MrsBouzgaou

alice sohane margot oceane

2023-02-02 09:13:51 UTC

- a judge or a lawyer should not let his emotions take over him .
- you should wear fancy outfits in the court .
- have a good eloquence .
- be respectful and impartial/ neutral .
- listen to each others arguments .

Henri/Nyhaja What makes a great defense lawyer

2023-02-02 09:16:07 UTC

A defense lawyer needs to be:
-Smart
-Have a good general culture
-a great orator
Exmeple:
When the defense lawyer trap the witness Chutney aboitut. the perm

What make a good judge:
A judge needs to be:
-impartial
-neutral
-great orator

Amélie

2023-02-02 09:17:50 UTC

For me a great defense lawyer is a good observer and a logical person

Mario Maxence Noémie Kinan

2023-02-02 09:21:50 UTC

A defense Lawyer needs to be persistent, clever, because he has to find the incoherences in speeches.

A good judge needs to be impartial and neutral, while being authoritary to keep the court in place

Laeticia, Calaivani, Camille, Sarah

2023-02-02 09:22:59 UTC

A defense lawyer should have repartee, be eloquent, be convincing, use space to show his confidence.
A judge should be objective, respect both parties, use logical reasoning to make a decision.

Sanaâ, Chloé, Maya, Soraia

2023-02-02 09:23:23 UTC

Great defense lawyer:
-has to be convincing, self assured, eloquent, logical, have an impact on the public as well as the judge, needs to have sharp thoughts, have solid arguments, can't be too empathic, needs to be respectful.

Good judge:
Objective, attentive, neutral, doesn't have to show how he feels about the event

What makes a great defense lawyer / Judge - Clément, Alexandre, Sacha, Hector

2023-02-02 09:23:47 UTC

- (Lawyer) He needs to find the contradiction like in Legally Blonde where the defense lawyer finds out that the witness could not have taken a shower or in My Cousin Vinny where V. Gambini finds out that he can't cook his grits in 5min

- (Judge) He must be completely impartial, he needs to not let his emotions take over him. Like Randolph in A few good mens

They both need to know people's rights

2023-02-02 09:23:47 UTC

an impartial judge
a convincing lawyer

Tom

2023-02-02 09:23:49 UTC

In my modest opinion, a good judge is a person who is equal for everybody.

Maeva

2023-02-02 09:23:50 UTC

To be a good judge, you have to be impartial

To têt the truths thé lawyer is often forced to lead him in battle, we can see it in the scene if Elle Woods where she uses this process and get thé truth

2023-02-02 09:23:56 UTC

Sara Jabbari

Cass, Eunice

2023-02-02 09:24:08 UTC

A great defense lawyer is able to be neutral and convincing.
He has a good eloquence. He is smart.

A great judge is able to have good decisions. He is neutral too.

They must have good arguments.

Cass, Eunice

2023-02-02 09:24:18 UTC

A great defense lawyer is able to be neutral and convincing.
He has a good eloquence. He is smart.

A great judge is able to have good decisions. He is neutral too.

They must have good arguments.

Corentin / Ilyes

2023-02-02 09:24:19 UTC

- a great defense lawyer needs to defend the acusated but in an objective way
- a great judge essentially care about the facts and is not subjective

Example : a few good men

Phylie Gasmi—Sedilot

2023-02-02 09:24:54 UTC

In my opinion, a good defants should convencing the jury, the people in the court and him-self.

Maeva

2023-02-02 09:24:59 UTC

To be a good lawyer you must have the ability to conduct research

Ornella, Jules, aurelien, gayathri

2023-02-02 09:26:10 UTC

I would say that a good defense lawyer should be confident, quick witted and observant
And he should be able to connect the dots with few informations

A good judge should be serious, fair-minded, open minded and most importantly impartial