Debate Feedback by Catherine Sotil Brown https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm What did you learn? what did you like? what would you change? en-us 2022-09-23 15:08:49 UTC 2026-01-22 22:27:42 UTC hello@padlet.com Kamilah Romero https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310697901 I learned how a moderated debate works, I've never been able to participate in one and I discovered that it's hard not to intervene when you know something that can refute what they say. As I said, I liked that there was a moderator, although I would change the time to coordinate. Being such a large group it was difficult to come to an agreement in just one minute. It was a little bit messy but for being the first time, it was really good .]]> 2022-09-23 15:31:06 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310697901 Belén Mogrovejo a005305 https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310701443 I learned new information about Machu Picchu, I think my perspective changed a lot. I never thought that tourism could do environmental damage, I was surprised. I liked how the girls prepared themselves, they were good, besides that they were respectful and they all had time to talk, the moderator did a great job. Even so, I would have liked that the subject had been investigated more.]]> 2022-09-23 15:33:37 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310701443 Camila Cieza https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310704407 This activity helped me to improve my investigation skills since I had to investigate deeply in the advantages and disadvantages of turism in Maccu Pichu. I really enjoyed being able to express my opinion. Although, I think the structure of the debate was a bit confusing and due to that we couldn´t get to a conclusion, but we will make it better the next time.]]> 2022-09-23 15:35:41 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310704407 Ana Vega https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310704942 This debate was so interesting. I liked the idea of sharing different perspectives about the tourism in Machu Picchu. I learned many aspects about this theme, but also about me and what I must improve. 
I think that I have to explore and get deeper on the theme, to know more and answer quickly. Besides, I liked the idea that everyone could participate in the debate and share their opinion. However, it was so difficult to stay in silence when the other group was talking and I wanted to intervene. At the beginning I was confused, but then I understood and it became interesting from both perspectives. I would like to repeat it. ]]> 2022-09-23 15:36:04 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310704942 Fátima Cano https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310705716 I liked this activity since I was able to learn more about the positive things in Machu Picchu, I was able to share ideas with my group and look for information that I did not know before. I hope we can repeat this activity.]]> 2022-09-23 15:36:40 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310705716 Sarah Barrera https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310707044 In this debate I really liked that everyone was passionate and concentrated about doing this wich it help for the dainamic. I leard for this activity I should really investigate a lot and have backup, also I saw how a debate works and what you should do or not and personally I actually wouldn´t change a thing because this showed how are we are as a class and how we interact with each other even if it was a little messy.   ]]> 2022-09-23 15:37:36 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310707044 Alejandra Livia https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310709487 Personally I really enjoy participating on debates, however I have never experienced on a moderated debate before, and I found it really interesting. I like it so much, because I could explain my arguments detailed, but I think that I could have handled the time better, for example I normally embellish my answers a lot, but in this case I couldn´t do it, so I had to go straight to the point most of the times. In terms of the topic and the information, I think I have never researched about Machu Picchu so much like I did this time, and that is because I wanted to be really prepared for this debate. And I would love to do another debate soon.]]> 2022-09-23 15:39:13 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310709487 Flavia Herrera https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310709912 I learned how to make strong arguments in less time and with a lot of pressure. Also how to investigate and organize our information. What I like the most, was investigate about machu pichu and how turism pollute our country. My perspective has not changed , I still thinking that the tourism isn´t bad, however we need to improve things to not contaminate machu pichu and neither any other touris atraction. The thing that i would change is the order, I think if any of the members, would like to include something that we didn´t agree, they need to ask the group if she could say something, since the time was very short and everybody need to talk and if is always the same person that talks the others participants can´t not include more information. ]]> 2022-09-23 15:39:31 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310709912 Miss Cat misscatherinesotil https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310709915 As I see it, it was a very productive time, from the preparation stage to the actual debate, I could see different shades of you all and got to realize that we need to work on our patience and assertiveness as well. I liked the fact you were passionate about the topic being discussed but would like to see you more into working as teams next time, since some of you hardly participated. Remember the success of each member is the success of the whole group, so coming to agreements before hand is important as well as learning to disassociate yourself from the actual comments being shared. Good job class! I truly enjoy working with you and watching you grow as time goes by.]]> 2022-09-23 15:39:31 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310709915 Daniela Carrión daniela_carrion https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310710563 I learned that the important to work in groups is organization and the comunication. In addition i would like to say that the people that are talking have to moderate their emotions. I saw that everyone investigated, but we need to coordinate better the time to say every argument.]]> 2022-09-23 15:39:54 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310710563 Camila Arias https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310710980 At the beginning I had a neutral position on the topic of tourism in Machupicchu ,but I had to defend the negative part and thanks to this I could see a reality that I didn´t know when researching more. At the same time I found it amusing to share different arguments ,I think that with each one I learned something new . These kinds of activities help me to communicate more in the language and at the same time you have to read a lot to have knowledge of the subject and that is very important.]]> 2022-09-23 15:40:10 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310710980 Micaela Koperdraad a005305 https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310710997 I learned a lot about how to organize a debate and about tourism. It really changed my perspective, and I am glad that I ended up in the negative group, otherwise I wouldnt have realize how many negative consequences there where for tourism. At first I thought It would be really dificult to find arguments, but when we started to research about it, it was actually not that difficult. I liked it a lot, but there are some things I would change, like next time I would preffer it to be with less people so that it is easier for everyone to participate, and I would also try to be more organized, because since we were a lot of people it was difficult to quickly decide who was going to talk. ]]> 2022-09-23 15:40:11 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310710997 Natalia https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310711543 I like that we have tried to work with a debate, but I feel that we did not have enough time to research and coordinate in class before the debate, also I feel that it would have been more realistic if we could have said "objection" to say exactly what we want to refute the point, instead of saying something general . 
An advice would be that next time we have rules that must be complied with, for example, that when the time comes to conclude, the other group cannot give another argument.
Overall, I think it was a good experience for our first time doing this, but I hope next time it will be a bit more organized.]]> 2022-09-23 15:40:34 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310711543 María Paz Garcia a005317 https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310716473 i had the oportunity to learn more about Machu Picchu and how is a debate, also i didn´t know that someone was counting the time. I like the fact that i could hear new perspectives and increase my knowledge about the theme. I realize that team work es very important and in the team should be a lot of organization. I would change the time, i think that my group had a lot of information and we couldn´t say it all. ]]> 2022-09-23 15:43:51 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310716473 Sol Gonzalez https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310716606 I learned to politely respond to a point of view different from my own. I also learned that for this type of exercise, you and the group have to be fully informed of what you are going to talk about, since you don't know what the other group is going to say or ask. Also, I think my perspective on tourism changed a lot when I listened to the ideas of the other group. I liked that each one spoke about an essential part for the debate. Each one had a voice and all perspectives were respected. I would feel more comfortable with this exercise if while I was presenting my ideas, the other group didntt speak or modify their ideas. They knew they had more time later but still they did. That sucked a little, but overall i liked the debate. ]]> 2022-09-23 15:43:57 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310716606 Camila Lama https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310718511 I learned that we have to respect everyone's opinion. We have to hear and understand their point of view, because it can enforce our ideas. I also made a research about our culture and historical places that made me realize how damaged it is and how we have to preserve our identity. 
It is surprising how disrespectful are some tourists and the fact that there is no solution that doesn't risk our economy is devastating. I liked the debate because it gave me the opportunity to improve my English and saw how capable I am to explain myself in other than my natal language.
I would make the debate last longer because my Group had more arguments that because of the time, we couldn't get to expose. 

]]> 2022-09-23 15:45:19 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310718511 Lucrecia Rozas a005377 https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310718729 I learned how a debate works and how to organize ourselves as a group for this type of work. It was my first time doing a debate so I had no prior experience. I also learned about the good and bad aspects of tourism in Machu Picchu, which I had no idea about before.
I liked that each one gave a point in favor of their team and the other contradicted it. The fact that we always try to defend our group made it very interesting. I had a lot of fun because sometimes we would get nervous not knowing what the other team was going to answer. I think I would change to a better group organization next time. For example, if a person wants to say something, discuss it with the group before saying it. Also, distribute the information in a more equitable way, so that the other participants in the group can also speak.


]]> 2022-09-23 15:45:28 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310718729 Miranda Morón https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310722251 Personally, I found it an interesting experience. Although, I had searched for information about Machu Picchu, and the positive side of having tourists in this wonder of the world, and for that reason i was sad bcs I had to work on the negative side. At the beginning I was discouraged, I really wanted to work on the positive side, but after the investigation I began to feel comfortable with my group and what I had received. I would like to have another debate, the atmosphere was very tense while we debated, I even think I got very red from adrenaline
But it was fun. And also, I worked with girls that I don't usually work with. Was INTERESTING.]]> 2022-09-23 15:47:36 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310722251 Karime Cornejo https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310726004 I learned that sometimes is good that there is a moderator that helps to control the disorder that always can appear in this type of debate which are formals. Also is good hearing the opposite side because they can mention points that maybe we had been cosiderated, so that is important. On another hand I think that it shoud improve the attitude of people to share ideas more respectfully and calmly. In addition, we shouldn't take the things so seriusly and personally. Equally I feel that if we had spoken a little bit more general, just environment and tourism, and not only had focused on Peru it could have found more arguments. But, in general I liked the activity, I would like repeat it but with other topics. ]]> 2022-09-23 15:50:06 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310726004 Mariví Olivares https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310728630 In my opinion this debate was a beneficial activity for us, because it help us to express our different opinions and respect each other. Also we touch on a very important theme for our country that was about Cusco.
However I think there was a lack of organization because the time to talk was limited. In addition the debate wasn't a competition of who gave the best arguments, but a way to learn about different perspectives, but even so there was a bit of tension.]]> 2022-09-23 15:52:01 UTC https://padlet.com/misscatherinesotil/fj0hqi7jo3uvgtcm/wish/2310728630