The Giver Quote and Analysis Chapters 6-10 by Jeannie Gianni https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71 Put your name at the top and copy/paste what you wrote in the "Putting it all Together" part of the quote analysis en-us 2021-02-26 17:28:48 UTC 2025-10-19 01:10:30 UTC hello@padlet.com Chance Amirian chancamiri3207 https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260907956 When Jonas was reading the rules of his receiver job, the last rule said “You may lie.” In other words, Jonas was given permission to fib to others
The author is trying to make us see that Jonas is going to change with the new rules he has.

The story had a significant impact on my thinking about freedom of speech and human rights in the real world because the single quote saying “You may lie.” gives the key to freedom of speech, making this quote important in the real world.

]]> 2021-03-02 21:43:16 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260907956 Daniel Torres https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260921285 Jonas was reading the rules he received for his selection. Jonas was shocked about this rule because his whole life he had been taught never to lie. If you need to keep something secret you may lie to anyone that includes your parents.
The significance of the quote is that it shows that anyone could have been lying to him and he would not know if something said to him is true.
It is important because it is a major event in the story and a new conflict for Jonas. In the real world anyone anyone can be lying to you and you may never know if they are telling the truth or not. This passage had a significant impact only thinking about what is true and what is not. This relates to me because I am having to grow up a lot this year. I am having to make new habits for myself to prepare in my own way to train for adulthood. 
]]> 2021-03-02 21:47:32 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260921285 Roman Bitar https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260922880 Jonas is reading the description of being the receiver of memory and sees something saying he can lie.

Jonas is given a special privilege to lie.
Jonas is one of the only people who can lie showing that his job and him are very important.

It is important because jonas is very important now he is in a position that is like our govern ment and is now going to play an important role in his society.]]> 2021-03-02 21:48:02 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260922880 Devin Bacon https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260923682 Jonas was reading his rules of his assignment that would shape his future life until the final rule shocked Jonas, “you may lie.” Lying was never allowed in the community, this caused Jonas to question many things, like if others had the ability to lie whenever they felt like. In other words, “You are allowed to not tell the truth wherever you feel like.” The author is trying to make us see how big of a deal breaking rules of the community are, with not being allowed to lie seeming to be just a given to people of the community, being able to lie is groundbreaking for Jonas. This quote is so important because it shows how Jonas’s assignment is so important it can even break the most emphasized rule. A real world connection is someone's job requiring them to commit crime that they know shouldn’t be allowed.]]> 2021-03-02 21:48:18 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260923682 Priscilla Alcantar https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260926415 On pg. 87 of the giver Jonas is reading a list of things he can and can't do as a elder. When he gets to the last one saying "You may lie." he freaks out, and later even the reciever of memory elder tells him that too. In other words the quote is telling him he can lie to others such as parents or friends. The qauother is trying to make us see how toxic and controlling the elders are. The quote is important because it shows the true nature of the elders. The connects to how the government lies to us to keep us listening to them and safe.  This story had a significant impact on my thinking about how the world lies.]]> 2021-03-02 21:49:13 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260926415 Marlee Thomas & Charlotte Sandoval https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260937671  Nobody said this, it was a rule made for Jonas. It was a rule for Jonas because he became the keeper of memories and was one of the things he was allowed to do.
Jonas had received his job at the time and there were specific rules he had to follow. So then he read them and found out about the 8 rules he has to follow.
The quote “you may lie” means that he can sometimes lie and slide a bit. It reveals that he can lie sometimes and it'll be okay but then questions if everybody else gout that rule. To me I think the quote means that lying isn’t allowed in their community. It makes me think about the reasons for having such strict rules in place. As Jonas is reading through the instructional folder listing his job requirements he is shocked to see that on the last instruction it reads “8. You may lie.” 68. In other words it means he is in denial that he now has the ability to break an important rule. Since he has never wanted to lie before he is confused about why he would need to lie. The author is trying to make us see that to the community lying is a punishable offense based on how Jonas reacts to reading in his folder. This passage had a significant impact on my thinking about lying as a whole and the motivations behind it. In the story, it benefits the adults and the elders for people to obey the rules and to never lie.


]]> 2021-03-02 21:52:58 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260937671 Xyje Martinez xyjemarti3608 https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260938601 When Jonas is reading the rules for being the receiver of memory, the instructions say that he may lie. This is important because this makes Jonas the only person who can lie in the whole community. This is also important since he had been told to always follow the rules and he no can break one rule.]]> 2021-03-02 21:53:18 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260938601 Joy Osovski joyosovs4709 https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260941733 When jonas gets home he read the 8th rule he happened in shock that it said he can lie. In other words, jonas is able to lie as it leaves him curious . The author is trying to make us see that jonas is getting older with more rules to take in and realize. This quote is important because jonas is having a big step in life of becoming receiver of memory. The meaning of the quote put in the real world is breaking a rule and being sent to jail or getting a ticket.  This story has a significant impact on my thinking about what would happen if you lied when you weren't 12? 

]]> 2021-03-02 21:54:26 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260941733 Ronen Kalev https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260949252 When Jonas is given some rules for his new job, he comes across one that shocks him that says, “You may lie.” In other words, this means Jonas is allowed to lie when he needs to. The author is trying to make us see that Jonas has the permission to lie when necessary. ]]> 2021-03-02 21:57:07 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260949252 Ani Butler https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260954554 The envelope that was for Jonas had 8 rules on being the next receiver of memories and the last rule said “You may lie”
In other words if Jonas were to need to lie to someone to keep a community secret the law of no lying will not apply to him, therefore he will not be punished in any sort of way when he lies. 
The author is trying to make us see that the law to not lie in the community is a very strict law and Jonas was taught to follow that strict law or else there would be consequences so when he is told he may lie his natural instinct is to be uncomfortable or afraid of that reality. 
 This story had a significant impact on my thinking about how others lie in our world and no one makes a big deal out of it, however in the community in the giver if you were to lie there would be great consequences coming your way. I just found that this community is very strict with their rules and what their rules are.  ]]> 2021-03-02 21:58:53 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260954554 Charlotte Sandoval https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260954579 2021-03-02 21:58:54 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260954579 Gabby Nemil gabrinemil6208 https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260959452 When Jonas is given the assignment as Receiver of Memory he proceeds to open a folder and the last guideline listed was “8. You may lie” 
In other words, Jonas can lie about certain things and break a rule while other people can’t
The author is trying to make us see that it might be crucial for Jonas to lie at some point in the story and that Jonas can break some rules to be Receiver of Memory.
This quote had a significant impact on my thinking about how Jonas is going to fulfill his assignment. I also think that this quote gives us some context on how Jonas feels when bringing up this specific topic.
]]> 2021-03-02 22:00:35 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260959452 Charlotte Sandoval & Marlee Thomas https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260959518
As Jonas is reading through the instructional folder listing his job requirements he is shocked to see that on the last instruction it reads “8. You may lie.” (Pg.68).
In other words it means he is in denial that he now has the ability to break an important rule. Since he has never wanted to lie before he is confused about why he would need to lie.
The author is trying to make us see that to the community lying is a punishable offense based on how Jonas reacts to reading in his folder.

This passage had a significant impact on my thinking about lying as a whole and motivations behind it. In the story, it benefits the adults and the elders for people to obey the rules and to never lie.]]> 2021-03-02 22:00:37 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260959518 Ronen Kalev https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260972526 When Jonas is given some rules for his new job, he comes across one that shocks him that says, “You may lie.” In other words, this means Jonas is allowed to lie when he needs to. The author is trying to make us see that Jonas has the permission to lie when necessary. This quote is important because it shows since Jonas is the Receiver of Memory, he can lie even though it’s not promoted to lie in the community. A real-life connection that can be drawn is when you go to another friend’s house and tell the other friend you're busy. This story/passage had a significant impact on my thinking about how I should tell the truth unless I need to tell a lie for the better.




]]> 2021-03-02 22:05:24 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260972526 https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260981953 When Jonas gets home from the ceremony of twelves he reads all the instructions for his new assignment and the last rule says “you may lie.” In other words the quote means Jonas has a decision to make will he lie to people? Or will he choose do the right thing and not lie?  The author is trying to make us see that one of the rules of a receiver is that they can lie to others.This passage had me thinking about how people can lie when it can damage friendships.

Jackie Sampson]]> 2021-03-02 22:08:36 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260981953 Rebecca Dahlsten & Noah Giblin https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260993419 Jonas is reading the instructions he is given at the  ceremony. “8. You may lie. Jonas was stunned.”
Jonas is now given the ability to freely lie. The author is trying to show us how much of an important quote this is by saying that Jonas was stunned and scared by this rule. This rule is an outrageous one considering that the community has never been able to lie. This quote is very significant because lying is prohibited in Jonas’ community. The idea that all people could potentially also be lying to Jonas is also something that unnerves him, and there is no true way of knowing the answer.


]]> 2021-03-02 22:12:32 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1260993419 Mary Hatch https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1261004365 “8. You may lie” In other words, you are able to not tell the truth to whoever you want, whenever you want. The author is trying to make us see that in the interesting job that Jonas got could be slightly suspicious and different then thought of before. This quote is important because it is different then thought of, and compared to the rest of the community supposedly can’t lie. This passage has a significant impact on my thinking about some connections are maybe like how you are hopefully told to not lie, but if you do it enough, then others might actually believe them enough to believe your lies more often. ]]> 2021-03-02 22:16:32 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1261004365 Aden Daneshnia https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1265554319 The quote is from is a book in the rules of the receiver of memory. It is said to Jonas After Jonas was chosen as the receiver of memory. In other words this means that Jonas is allowed to lie as the receiver of memory. This quote means that Jonas is allowed to lie and it causes conflict because Jonas was always told to never ever lie. This connects to real because it is illegal in the real world to lie about a crime. Another way this connects to the real world is because it is bad to lie about something to your parents.


]]> 2021-03-03 19:04:59 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1265554319 Tanner Klein https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1266321269 When Jonas is opening his folder sent to him by The Elders to see what he has to do as his role of Receiver of Memory, the folder says, “You may lie.” In other words, he is allowed to lie and be dishonest in order to receive memories from people. I see this in the main world as not a problem at all because we live in a  society where we have democracy and this utopia is a very strict utopia. This Quote is important Lying is not a good thing and humans are so good at lying and we need to remove lying from our lives.]]> 2021-03-03 22:30:34 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1266321269 Joshua Mahler https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1266325808 When Jonas is opening his folder sent to him by The Elders to see what he has to do as his role is it says that he can lie. This quote is important because jonas has never lied so he is having trouble now that he can lie. ]]> 2021-03-03 22:32:31 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1266325808 James Giacopuzzi https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1266880291 When Jonas becomes a twelve, he receives a slim set of instructions about his new position as receiver. The eighth and final item on the list is "You may lie," which really rattles Jonas more than any of the other instructions.

]]> 2021-03-04 02:13:13 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1266880291 Cameron Kelly https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1270214034 This quote in the giver shows that nobody but Jonas gets to lie in the community. This makes Jonas scared because he has never been able to lie. This quote made me think that I really shouldn't lie unless it is to be nice. Finally I can connect this to real life because my parents tell me to only lie when its doing the right thing which is the same with Jonas.]]> 2021-03-04 17:19:51 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1270214034 This quote is important because it shows that if you get caught lying you might get punished. This story has a significant impact on telling the truth and not lying and following the rules.Jacob C https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1271892801 2021-03-05 00:53:10 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1271892801 " You may lie bricechuc7907 https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1275260132 The woman who told the jobs, she said to Jonas after she told him his job. It was on purpose so that he would know what he can do from now on because you can’t lie while you’re a citizen. It is a mature job a responsible one that has to keep you from telling the truth in some ways,Many people are shocked and proud about what Jonas got for his job, The woman says it when they are talking about his job. He is told the quote when he gets his job chosen, they are telling the quote means that if Jonas finds out somethings and the citizens know he may lie to them he can lie about anything he does. It reveals that many of the elders and the people who work for the place know many things and lies to the citizens to keep them protected. It also reveals that there is a conflict involving the place because why would they need to lie to the citizens.hat he can do and what not.I think the quote means to me is like secrets and that can hide unknown subjects. I think that the quote means so much that many people from This world are lying to us to keep us protected or just not wanting to know about subjects that can make citizens argue and bring conflict.When Jonas job was being chosen, The woman who assigned his job says,” You may lie”In other words, saying that if he gets into a problem about something he can lie so he can start to understand his job.The author is making us see that the community has some secrets they haven’t told the citizens because why do you need to lie if the place is organized and safe.This passage had a significant impact on my thinking about the book and the secrets it is keeping and about reality because if you think about it many people could be lying to you to keep you safe or to keep you away from important information.

]]> 2021-03-05 19:27:10 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1275260132 Sebastians Padlet https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1276049696 The note that Jonas was given said this. It had the purpose to inform.
Jonas is becoming the new receiver of memory.
The quote means he can lie and it reveals how lying is something that is usually not allowed in the community. It also shows the conflict about how Jonas now has to deal with this fact as the new receiver.
This quote means a tiny bit to me because in our society people lie all the time and it really shows the contrasts and how the book society and ours are different.

This was read by Jonas in a note when the higher ups gave Jonas the notification that he was going to be the receiver of memory.

In other words this was a letter to Jonas.
The tone was frightening and surprising. It was significant because he was getting permission to break a law in their society.
This quote is important because it shows how there is going to be change in the story and how Jonas will now be allowed to break a law for his special job, the receiver of memory. This will change relationships with his friends and family in the story because he will now have to lie about stuff when he has never lied before. This will have a significant impact to Jonas and the story because of these reasons.

]]> 2021-03-06 02:10:59 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1276049696 "You May Lie" - Brody B. brodybejar1708 https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1346640362 When Jonas came back from the Ceremony of Twelves he read the paper that the Elders gave him and one of the guidelines said he may lie.
In other words, Jonas can lie without getting punished like the others that do without permission. 
The author is trying to make us see that there might be a time where Jonas needs to because Jonas can not speak of certain things where that can get him in trouble.
This story/passage had a significant impact on my thinking about how this can impact his training and his job as The Receiver of Memories. Besides the story lying is taken seriously and is taken as a bad thing because others use lying in an inappropriate way.]]> 2021-03-24 07:22:54 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/1346640362 Math https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/3013557791 2024-05-30 22:09:17 UTC https://padlet.com/lvusd/ffxj2wqkjxdpsw71/wish/3013557791