https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300 Research Topic: God is a Woman en-us 2021-02-22 17:55:35 UTC 2024-02-07 22:11:24 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet.net/icons/png/1f469-1f4bb.png zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227846403 2021-02-22 17:55:35 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227846403 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227846431 2021-02-22 17:55:35 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227846431 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227846433 2021-02-22 17:55:35 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227846433 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227846436 2021-02-22 17:55:35 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227846436 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227846440 2021-02-22 17:55:35 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227846440 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227846444 2021-02-22 17:55:35 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227846444 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227846458 2021-02-22 17:55:35 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227846458 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227852271 -Your relationship to the topic: your thoughts, feelings, potential bias
- all are familiar with the song and video
-Source format/type: genre, intended audience
-audience is the general public, it is a newspaper article
-Source publisher: purpose, mission
- purpose is to inform
-The Guardian
- Left-centered bias
- Mixed credibility based on mediabiasfactcheck.com
-Source author: credentials, relationship to topic
- Author is Arwa Mahdawi
-columnist for guardian, has a "this week in patriarchy" column
-Sources referenced: citations, links to other sources
-some links to other content showing god as a woman
-Source content: language, tone, images
-not super formal language
-some images included of other depictions of god as a woman]]> 2021-02-22 17:56:38 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227852271 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227954472 2021-02-22 18:14:37 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227954472 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227960142 2021-02-22 18:15:35 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227960142 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227978101 1.What contribution does this source make to the ongoing conversation about the topic?
-This source provides insight on  other people referring to god as a woman, including multiple sources that came before this song. Despite this becoming a hot topic of discussion due to Grande's platform, this is not the first time that someone has considered God to be a woman. This source shows us that although it is a controversial subject now, there was a time where people referred to god as a woman and a man.
2. How would you use this source in a paper?  
I would use this source to show that Ariana Grande is not the first artist to depict god as a woman. I would look into the quotes the author used from religious leaders to show historical context.
3. Anything interesting or unique about this source?
-  The author, Arwa Mahdai, included multiple pop culture references to other non-male depictions of God that have been used in the past, as well as opens up the discussion to the history behind the male  
4. Does this source meet the assignment’s source requirements? Yes- we need at lease 2 outside sources, one of which must be a scholarly article.]]> 2021-02-22 18:18:46 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227978101 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227985425 -Your relationship to the topic:  we are all women studies majors thus we have a pro-feminist stance on the topic
-Source format/type:  feminist Magazine
-Source publisher:  talk about the pro-feminist aspects of ariana's song god is a women
-Source author:  Carmiya Baskin , editorial intern and third-year Feminist studies major at UCSB
-Sources referenced: none
-Source content: semi formal]]> 2021-02-22 18:20:04 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227985425 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227986164 -Your relationship to the topic:  
we are pro feminism and this article is definitely not
-Source format/type:
biased, Catholics
-Source publisher:
anti-feminist, against Ariana Grande's expression of sensualism/sexuality
-Source author: 
Katie Yoder, conservative, writer
-Sources referenced:
includes links to interviews with Grande, includes links to lyrics, also links to other articles by the same author
-Source content:
passive aggressive, semi formal]]> 2021-02-22 18:20:11 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227986164 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227988453 -Your relationship to the topic: your thoughts, feelings, potential bias
-Source format/type: genre, intended audience
-Source publisher: purpose, mission
-Source author: credentials, relationship to topic
-Sources referenced: citations, links to other sources
-Source content: language, tone, images]]> 2021-02-22 18:20:35 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227988453 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227989208 -Your relationship to the topic:
Dependent on individual backgrounds and beliefs (ex: Christian, non-religious, etc.)
-Source format/type:
Scholarly peer reviewed, religious studies journal
-Source publisher:
Cambridge University - undercut the main motivations for traditionalism
-Source author:
Cambridge University Press author, analytic philosopher
-Sources referenced: yes
-Source content:
Scholarly tone, posing an argument]]> 2021-02-22 18:20:43 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1227989208 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1228004003 1.What contribution does this source make to the ongoing conversation about the topic?
Making a pop culture reference in and connecting it to feminism theory
2. How would you use this source in a paper? 
In a paper, we believe this source can be a secondary source that could support an argument for pro-female sexuality
3. Anything interesting or unique about this source?
It is a feminist runned magazine so it gives their stance on the video based on feminist theory. it gives specific references of based on what was shown in the music video and compares
4. Does this source meet the assignment’s source requirements?
No, because it does not list any references]]> 2021-02-22 18:23:15 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1228004003 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1228013953 1.What contribution does this source make to the ongoing conversation about the topic?
gives a religious perspective on why some may disagree w/Ariana's lyrics
This source is attacking Ariana Grande, anti-feminist

2. How would you use this source in a paper?  

Use as an example of negative reactions to the video and song

3. Anything interesting or unique about this source?

Against the idea of God being a woman

4. Does this source meet the assignment’s source requirements?

Technically]]> 2021-02-22 18:24:59 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1228013953 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1228015183 1.What contribution does this source make to the ongoing conversation about the topic?
Contributes Ariana Grande fans' reactions to her new song off her unreleased album. Perspective of social media is different.
2. How would you use this source in a paper?  
Would not normally use this source in a paper since it is not very informative, could be used in reference to her popularity among her fans. It would have to be used along with scholarly sources and could be used as a brief reference point if anything.
3. Anything interesting or unique about this source?
Interesting and unique to use all Twitter social media responses, 
4. Does this source meet the assignment’s source requirements?
Her music video and the song "god is a woman" could definitely relate to the pop culture aspect of feminist analysis in the media and possibly work as a cultural artifact. It is not scholarly or professional as a source, and is biased so would not  work for the assignment's source requirements.

]]> 2021-02-22 18:25:11 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1228015183 zohrajs3 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1228016730 1.What contribution does this source make to the ongoing conversation about the topic?
-yes, it could work with ariana grande "god is a woman", it is plausible to be either
2. How would you use this source in a paper?  
-cite, our use their research to back up theory
3. Anything interesting or unique about this source?
-yes, the author says that it is just as crazy to assume that god is a man
4. Does this source meet the assignment’s source requirements?
-yes]]> 2021-02-22 18:25:27 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1228016730 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1234190532 Relationship to the topic:
•the thoughts about the video from her fans was mainly positive
•the video god is a woman could offend some people (possibly religious people) (parents)
•the article has bias because the comments are mainly coming from her fans, but we as a group don’t have a bias
Source format/type:
•audience would be her fans
Source publisher:
•the purpose of this article would be to see how her fans are
reacting to the video
Source Author:
•the article comes from billboard
•the credentials of the article normally shouldn’t be used for research
Source References:
•there weren’t any links on the article
• however, there were the tweets from fans which could take a reader to twitter
Source Content:
•the language of the article from the fans was positive
•the tone and images were praising Ariana for her video 

]]> 2021-02-24 00:12:16 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1234190532 https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1234192894 1.The source makes a biased opinion on the topic as it comes from a catholic/conservative perspective that does not see the possibility of a woman being god.
I would use the source as 2.According to Katie Yoder from catholicvote.org in july of 2019 ... or direct quote. 
3. the source is called catholicvote- they have a specific audience.]]> 2021-02-24 00:13:29 UTC https://padlet.com/zohrajs3/wmst300/wish/1234192894