https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh You will participate in a collaborative discussion question using "Padlet". We will read the chapters together. You will then respond to both of the discussion questions on the PADLET. Make sure you also comment on someone else's answer using ACCOUNTABLE TALK. PLEASE MAKE SURE YOU INCLUDE YOUR NAME IN YOUR RESPONSE. We will be responding to you as well as a way to engage in rich conversation. Please answer the following questions. You can include pictures and quotes as well. Question 1: Do you think Jack deserves his punishment? What would you do if you were him? Question 2: Why did August agree to become Jack Will's friend again? Use EVIDENCE from the text in order to support your answer. Today's chapters: "Detention" "Season's Greetings" "Letters, Emails, Facebook, Texts" "Back From Winter Break" en-us 2021-05-07 10:16:38 UTC 2023-11-30 18:06:27 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet-uploads.storage.googleapis.com/583448734/fce4eb4f633298054bfc68633e359b1e/choosekind.jpeg kgeoghan2 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517781868 2021-05-12 14:55:43 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517781868 patcruz24 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796021 1. I think Jack Will deserve the punishment becuase he punched a kid and he's bleeding without a tooth. That is very serious in school so Jack Will deserves his punishment. If I was Jack Will I would just  accept the punishment and write the letters for Mr.Tushman and Julian. In addition, "Julian's mouth was bleeding, Jack," said Mr. Tushman. "You knocked out a tooth, did
you know that?" He shouldn't have used his hands to solve the problem becuase violence shouldn't ever be a resort.
2. August agreed to be Jack Wills friend becuase he defended him from Julian  and he apolagized to August many, many times. In addition,"I changed my mind at the last minute. Did u really punch Julian? " and "Yeah i punched him knocked out a tooth in the back. A baby tooth.
whyd u punch him????????
I dunno
liar. I bet he said something about me right? "
So August accepts his friend request becuase of what happened with Jack will and Julian.]]> 2021-05-12 14:58:48 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796021 nazhoque26 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796254 2. I think Jacks punishment is fair because he did punch someone and it did hurt and it resulted in blood. I also think Julian should have been punished to. If I was in this situation I would just ask Julian to stop talking to me and I would say sorry to Auggie.
1. August became friends with Jack because he forgave him and understood him. For example, " 1 New Text Message From: AUGUST Dec 31 5:10PM lol yes dude we'r frenz agen." Auggie understands that he didnt mean any of the things Jack said.  
   ]]> 2021-05-12 14:58:51 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796254 tymassaro23 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796387 1. I think Jack Will deserved it because he punched Julian for a random reason.

2.Auggie becomes friends with Jack Will again because he forgives Jack Will of what happened and he didn't know that Auggie was in the Bob Fett costume.]]> 2021-05-12 14:58:53 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796387 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796403 Do you think he deserves detention? What would you do if you were him?

yes and no because he could've resolved it in other ways but he was caught in the moment and it wasn't just then Julian had annoyed him and he had been rude often. "We could have been partners. You don't have to be friends with that freak if you don't want to be, you know..." 

Knowing who i am i'd probably Get mad and insult/threaten but never phisically hurting anyone i find myself get extremely aggrivated when others treat each other differently for things they cant help let alone people i support.]]> 2021-05-12 14:58:53 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796403 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796421 I think JackWill deserved his punishment, but I also think that Julian should have been punished too. I think this because it was wrong for Jack to punch Julian, but Julian shouldn’t have been talking about Auggie like that. I would have just told Julian to not talk about Auggie that way and to leave me alone. 

August became JackWill’s friend again because he said sorry, and then Jack started making jokes about Julian with Auggie.]]> 2021-05-12 14:58:54 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796421 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796510 1 I think jack deserved it because he talked bad about Auggie and now he punched Julian in the mouth. Auiggie is friends with jack because he punched julian in the face.]]> 2021-05-12 14:58:55 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796510 zpierre24 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796563 Q1. I think that Jacks punishments is fair because punching someone in the mouth isn't good. Even though Jack punched Julian because he was offending Auggie and he had enough of Julian's rudeness, he could at least have found another way to react to what Julian did and said. I also think that his punishment is fair because Jack could have got suspended, even though he did, it wasn't as harsh, for the reason that Jack is a good kid. I think that Julian should been punished too. 

Q2. Auggie becomes friends with Jack again because Auggie realized why Jack said that and realized that Jack actually didn't really mean what he said. Auggie also realized that Jack punched Julian in the mouth because of what he said. Jack did apoligize, after all. ]]> 2021-05-12 14:58:55 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796563 dbechan24 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796624 I think Jack deserved a harder punishment because he punched a kid.  Also Julian lost a tooth and was bleeding. What I would do is that send sorry cards.]]> 2021-05-12 14:58:55 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796624 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796762 i think jack should not be in detetion because he was just sticking up for his friend even if it was not that the right way. jack will and Auggie became friends because jack will knew why auggie was mad at him and said he was sorry and august said they were friend again.]]> 2021-05-12 14:58:57 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796762 chloethieu24 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796766 1. I think that Jack does deserve his punishment because he injured Julian by punching him in the face. Julian was being really mean to August, but Jack should've handled the situation differently, instead of violence. I also think that Julian should get a punishment too since he was talking bad about August.

2. August became friends with Jack again because Jack gave an apology to him since he was talking bad about him before. To elaborate, "he's a jerk. but I was a jerk too. really really really sorry for wat I said dude, Ok? can
we b frenz agen? lol yes dude we'r frenz agen." This proves that August forgives Jack and that they became friends again.

]]> 2021-05-12 14:58:57 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517796766 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517797880 I think Jacks Punishment is fair. I think this because he is a good kid, and Mr. Tushman was nice enough to only suspend him throughout spring break to think about what he did. Jack does deserve detention, because he punched Julian, and knocked out his tooth. If I was Jack, I would just tell Mr. Tushman why he did what he did.]]> 2021-05-12 14:59:12 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517797880 zushuaib23 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517798034 Yes I think should get his punishment because he physically touched someone and hurt them. If I was him I would be very sorry!!!]]> 2021-05-12 14:59:13 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517798034 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517798125 Question 1:I think that Jack’s punishment is fair because he didn’t get that much in trouble and he has time to give his reasons so I think ti was fair.If I were him I wouldn’t say anything and I would ask for time to think and to calm down.

Question 2: Auggie said yes to Jack Will when he ask do you want to be friends again because Jack Will was kind to Auggie. Jack will also meant his sorry becuase he thought auggie is a cool dude.Jack Will said“Like, if all the guys in the fifth grade were lined up against a wall and I got to choose anyone I wanted to hang out with, I would choose August.He wants to hang out with August now instead of him being forced.]]> 2021-05-12 14:59:14 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517798125 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517798299 Q1:I think Jack deserved his punishment but I also think Julian deserved a punishment to Jack was caught in the moment and he acted out of anger so I understand why he punched him but it was also the wrong thing to do but Julian shouldn't have been talking so badly about Auggie it isn't the right thing to do.
Q2:Auggie became friends with Jack again because he had realized that he didn't mean what he said about him and he said sorry and he also stood up for Auggie by punching Julian when he was saying bad things about him.]]> 2021-05-12 14:59:17 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517798299 julmichel24 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517798638 I think Jack was wrong .I think he was wrong because even if Julian was bad mouthing Auggie people do that everyday behind Jack and Auggies back. I would tell Julian he was not cool for bullying Auggie and that if he didn't want to be my friends since I liked Auggie then so be it.]]> 2021-05-12 14:59:21 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517798638 1bryfrank1 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517799285 I think Jack Will's punishment is fair because he punched Julian in the mouth and his tooth fell off while bleeding. I think Jack will deserves a worse punishment.

]]> 2021-05-12 14:59:30 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517799285 joyou26 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517800335 1. i think jack deserved his punishment because he knocked Julian's tooth out it was very worg ]]> 2021-05-12 14:59:44 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517800335 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517801571 I think he deserves his punishment because even if he was right he still punched someone which was wrong.]]> 2021-05-12 14:59:59 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517801571 afalauso24 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517802789 Yes because after what he said about Agust I would never forgive him because that would mean that he is a fack friend.

]]> 2021-05-12 15:00:16 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517802789 abramirez24 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517803357 1. Jacks Punishment is fair because even thought the reason he did it was good the way he did it was bad he shouldn't have punched Julian in the face. If I was jack I would explain why I punched. I also think that Julian was the one who deserved the suspension because what he said about auggie was really wrong and he shouldn't have said that jack did it because he was really mad about what he said he shouldn't have punched Julian thought.
2.Auggie agreed to be jack wills friend again because he saw that jack will punched Julian and risked losing his friend ship with the popular kids

]]> 2021-05-12 15:00:24 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517803357 rhcrawford24 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517805731 Yes, Jack deserved it, even if Julian is mean, he knocked out his tooth, for that, I think Jack was pitied.]]> 2021-05-12 15:00:53 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517805731 sgreen243 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517810949 Yes I think Jack's punishment is fair because even though jack is a good kid and he was trying to do something good after he knew what happened with him and August. ]]> 2021-05-12 15:02:03 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517810949 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517815453 I think jack desraved that puishment becayse he punched jack really hard and now he lost a tooth.]]> 2021-05-12 15:03:01 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517815453 dbechan24 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517863489 He became friends with him again because he punched Julian and he said he would kill himself if he was Julian.]]> 2021-05-12 15:13:06 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517863489 sgreen243 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517863586 August agreed to be Jack's friend because jack came clean and was very sorry. Jack also covered up the tension by making a joke.]]> 2021-05-12 15:13:07 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517863586 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517863827 2021-05-12 15:13:10 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517863827 afalauso24 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517864200 2021-05-12 15:13:15 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517864200 1bryfrank1 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517866600 2021-05-12 15:13:43 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517866600 afalauso24 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517867399 Because he would know that he didnt mean it and is trying to be cool with juilian ]]> 2021-05-12 15:13:54 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517867399 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517868452 August agree to become Jack Will's friend again because Jack apologized, and was honest with Auggie. The text states, " 1 New Text Message From: AUGUST Dec 31 5:06PM but tell me the truth, ok? wud u really wan to kill urself if u wer me??? 1 New Text Message From: JACKWILL Dec 31 5:08PM no!!!!! I swear on my life but dude- I would want 2 kill myself if I were Julian ;)" Jack was honest with Auggie. " lol yes dude we'r frenz agen."]]> 2021-05-12 15:14:07 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517868452 julmichel24 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517868733 August became Jack's friends again because he knew that Jack was a real friend since he punched Julian for Auggie's sake. Jack showed that he was very sincere about the things  he said towards Auggie. For Example "  1 New Text Message From: JACKWILL Dec 31 5:02PM he's a jerk. but I was a jerk too. really really really sorry for wat I said dude, Ok? can we b frenz agen?   1 New Text Message From: AUGUST Dec 31 5:03PM ok  "This demonstartes that Jack realized his mistake and apoligized and Auggie knows that he was sorry so he accepts to be Jacks friend again.  ]]> 2021-05-12 15:14:11 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517868733 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517868743 August and jack became freinds again because jack had defended auggie and had showed his appreciation for allowing him to be freinds again]]> 2021-05-12 15:14:11 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517868743 zushuaib23 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517869072 August agree to become Jack Will's friend again because Jack apologized, and was honest with Auggie. The text states, " 1 New Text Message From: AUGUST Dec 31 5:06PM but tell me the truth, ok?]]> 2021-05-12 15:14:16 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517869072 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517902654 Yes I think Jack Will deserves his punishment because he punched someone in the mouth, and even knocked out a tooth. Even though he was trying to defend Auggie, it still wasn’t right to do it ]]> 2021-05-12 15:21:42 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517902654 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517913829 August became Jacks friend again because Jack punched Julian in the face, Jack Will also apologized and said that he didn’t mean those mean stuff. I think Jack Will deserved detention because he made Julian bleed for teasing August, he knocked one of his baby teeth out. If I was Jack Will I would ask Julian to stop, cause even though he’s teasing August it’s still bad to punch people in the face, as it can cause big problems.]]> 2021-05-12 15:24:09 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517913829 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517972066 Auggie became friends with Jack Will again because he apologized to him, and was honest with him.]]> 2021-05-12 15:36:41 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1517972066 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1518497537 i think that jack did the right thing to punch julian in the mouth becouse julian was beinga bully a jerk and he was bragging about how rich he is so i think that julian deserved that punch]]> 2021-05-12 17:32:12 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1518497537 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1519217618 i think jack deserved his punishment because he knocked Julian's tooth out it was very wrong.]]> 2021-05-12 21:06:18 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1519217618 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1519225601 No I don’t think Jack deserves his punishment because he was standing up for Auggie.Auggie do you greed to become friends with the jack again because Jack still up for him]]> 2021-05-12 21:09:59 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1519225601 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1519387107 I think jack deserved his punishment and doesn't deserves his punishment. I think he deserved his punishment because even though someone annoys and gets you very angry that doesn't mean you punch them. I think he didn't deserve his punishment if Julian didn't get a punishment because it was Juilan fault for what Jack did. But, he mostly deserved his punishment.]]> 2021-05-12 22:39:05 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1519387107 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1519464625 I think jack deserved it because he said mean things about Auggie behind his back ]]> 2021-05-12 23:27:31 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1519464625 rhcrawford24 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1519493493 August agreed to be his friend again because he admitted he was being a jerk and August learned he punched him and knocked out a baby tooth. I know this because the text states "Julian? 1 New Text Message From: JACKWILL Dec 31 4:54PM Yeah i punchd him knocked out a tooth in the back. A baby tooth. 1 New Text Message From: AUGUST Dec 31 4:55PM whyd u punch him???????? 1 New Text Message From: JACKWILL Dec 31 4:56PM I dunno 1 New Text Message From: AUGUST Dec 31 4:58PM liar. I bet he said something about me right?"]]> 2021-05-12 23:44:36 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1519493493 https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1529394957
in my opinion I think he got what he deserved beceuse he bad . he also said really bad things to poor august . And he knocked julian's tooth out was a very bad thing to do. ]]> 2021-05-17 01:08:46 UTC https://padlet.com/kgeoghan2/ecezif6lvpbu39dh/wish/1529394957