Sadao and Hana demand respect as they valued humanity more than trivial principles of patriotism. Whom do you rate superior than the other? by Teacher_AME MeenaA https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij en-us 2021-08-02 16:50:28 UTC 2025-12-07 06:24:18 UTC hello@padlet.com Druva https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668560578 Sadao has better morals as he was subject to racial prejudice during his time in the US. He still didn't hesitate to help the wounded soldier. Hana was just shown as afraid and obedient to her husband's orders. Even though she did show compassion for the wounded soldier.]]> 2021-08-04 05:13:05 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668560578 Joshua - Sadao https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668562275 Both Sadao and Hana helped out the soldier, but throughout the lesson, we see Hana be more focused towards her own belongings and welfare. this is very well seen in the carpet incident. ]]> 2021-08-04 05:15:11 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668562275 Sashank https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668562929 Both of them were correct in their own perspective. Sadao is a doctor and his job is to save the lives. Whereas Hana in the other hand was worried and not okay with keeping an American Soldier in their house especially in the time of war.
If i had to pick up one side , i would go with Sadao as he did what is necessary at the time. ]]> 2021-08-04 05:16:02 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668562929 Jitesh https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668562953 Sadao, Hana was selfish but the doctor Sadao helped the american soldier even after he was a subject to racial prejudice in US.]]> 2021-08-04 05:16:02 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668562953 Eshwar https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668563239 Sadao is superior than Hana with respect to humanity as he treated the wounded enemy because he was a doctor all he saw there was a wounded human. Sadao also helped the white solider escape. Meanwhile , Hana didn't like to be in the same room as the white man but, she also showed some humanity.]]> 2021-08-04 05:16:23 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668563239 Hana is more superior ~ Harikeshavan https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668563266 Hana is more superior than as, Sadoa only saw the soldier as a patient and only treated him as he was wounded, but Hana on the other hand showed compassion towards the soldier and even when the soldier told her his name Hana showed no anger towards him. Hana was also the one to see the soldiers scars and think of the cruelty he had been thought of the further torture he would be enduring if he was turned over, but on the other hand Sadao only wanted to get the soldier out of his home.]]> 2021-08-04 05:16:25 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668563266 my preference goes to sadao .he was opposed by every one including his wife intially ,but he stood by humanity though he knew and feared the consequences if he saved the american's life . on the other hand he confessed to the president about his actions that shows his loyalty to the country,similarly when the asassins arrival delayed he helped the american to escape despite of his hatred towards america that shows supremacy of humanity over the wrongly understood patriotism (in this case) https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668563501 sheshadri

]]> 2021-08-04 05:16:42 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668563501 Sundar https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668563730 Sado, as he valued the american soldier as a human and his patient and helped him, but his wife didn't want to help him herself]]> 2021-08-04 05:16:59 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668563730 S Aditya https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668563750 HANA IS SUPERIOR
|hana although pressured by servants and annoyed by her irritated husband , continued to take care of him to the level of washing and cleaning him .]]> 2021-08-04 05:17:00 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668563750 https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668563849 Kapilesh

The fact that Sadao saw the American soldier as a human before an enemy American and treated his wounds goes to show how Sadao valued humanity over patriotism and why it is clearly superior. Before we're Americans or Japanese we are humans and it is a fact that we tend to ignore in these times and that value for human life is very much better than anything else]]> 2021-08-04 05:17:07 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668563849 Sindhoora https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668564764 personally i would choose Sadao, he is indeed a patriot he served for his country for years, however as it was mentioned in the story he was never taught to not save a patient when the patient is injured or sick, doesnt matter where s/he belong to. I do respect Hana point of view too. However Sadao actions proved humanity 

]]> 2021-08-04 05:18:16 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668564764 Sadao can be ranked first because at the start when they caught the site of the war prisoner laid wounded, Sadao was less reluctant compared to Hana to treat him keeping aside the fact that he was an American. https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668564781   Harshita]]> 2021-08-04 05:18:18 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668564781 Yugaan - Sadao has greater values because he faced racial persecution in the United States. Despite this, he did not hesitate to assist the injured soldier. https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668565170 2021-08-04 05:18:47 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668565170 Valaroli Sadao was better set on his values of humanity than Hana. This can be seen when Hana worries about how the servants of their house were going to take the issue of having an American in their house while Sadao was willing to help him without concerning himself with consequences of his act as the soldier's life was in danger. Hence he values humanity more than patriotism. https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668565398 Valaroli]]> 2021-08-04 05:19:05 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668565398 Vignesh https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668566749 Sadao is more superior than the other because he is a doctor and he want to save that soldier and also he had taken oath to save lives. But Hana worries about the consequences of helping an american soldier.]]> 2021-08-04 05:20:33 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668566749 Dheepaswarupan https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668566751 Hana has better morals .Because she has an opportunity to say this out but she didn't .but sadao was waiting for the assasins to kill the solider. Unfortunately they didn't arrive so he let the solider escape due to pressure .  ]]> 2021-08-04 05:20:33 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668566751 Aniruddhan https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668567317 Sadao, as he treated the american soldier as his own patient even though he faced racism when he lived in america

]]> 2021-08-04 05:21:21 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668567317 yashwant https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668567909 sadao is a doctor who saved the lives which is a duty as a  he doctor to save ilves dint deny his duty as a doctor and save the lives of the american soldier and helped him so but  hana dint like take care the american solider but still sadao performed his duty as a doctor due to his kindness sadao is superior than hana

]]> 2021-08-04 05:22:06 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668567909 Aadhiyaa Manian https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668568549 Both Hana and Sadao have equal humanity in their own ways. Hana also did her part in helping the enemy and obeying her husband. But since Sadao was a doctor specialised in healing wound he managed to do well ]]> 2021-08-04 05:22:55 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668568549 Sanjuktha https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668569072 Sadao was a doctor who was taught to save a life no matter the circumstances and he did the exact same thing when he saw the wounded American soldier even during the time of war, on the other hand, Hana was a patriotic women who is anxious, she worries what others like her servants might think of her and her husband's actions yet she helped in the recovery of the soldier, doing things which she wouldn't do else, like cleaning him before the treatment. In my opinion, I think both Sadao and Hana showed humanity and compassion to the level both of them can.

]]> 2021-08-04 05:23:39 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668569072 Tharaka https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668570030 I would rank Sadao over Hana as when the prisoner was brought into the house, Hana was more worried about the blood and the dirt staining the white silk quilt, a materialistic possession, rather than the man surviving. If there had been a Japanese soldier in the same position, her first instinct probably might've been to save the man's life and not the qulilt. This shows that Sadao was compassionate and valued humanity more than Hana.]]> 2021-08-04 05:24:53 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668570030 Maanasa https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668571370 Humanity definitely holds a higher value in terms of comparison with patriotism. The very intent of patriotism is to bring unity within countrymen. But mistaking it results in showing brutality and inhuman practises towards other countries. Sadao and Hana were thoughtful and had understood the true meaning in the qualities of patriotism and humanity. They knew that helping the American Soldier would mean that they are going aganist their country , but by not tending to cure him, they would be going against their own-self. ]]> 2021-08-04 05:26:34 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668571370 Sadao is more Superior https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668572141 I would personally say that Sadao was superior because as a doctor he knows the value of life so he took care of prisoner as well  didn't leave the general take away the prisoners' life illegally . Being Patriotic is a relative term one may be patriotic to his nation whereas he might be criminal for an opposing nation. - Rohin]]> 2021-08-04 05:27:41 UTC https://padlet.com/teacher_ame/ead2wab5km5rkaij/wish/1668572141