Historical Truth by https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts Which work best captures "historical truth?" What made you come to this conclusion? Respond to the question in a box under the respective work. en-us 2018-09-05 16:51:56 UTC 2021-01-22 15:32:24 UTC hello@padlet.com Different Trains https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278185606 I think that Different Trains is a more impactful version of music compared to the others since recordings of peoples voices are being used from the actual time period, rather than singers voices in a choir and such.]]> 2018-09-05 20:14:07 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278185606 Different Trains https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278185617 I believe Different Trains comes closest to achieving “historical truth” because it incorporates the voices of the actual Holocaust survivors rather than using the voices of others to retell a story. ]]> 2018-09-05 20:14:09 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278185617 In Different Trains, the stories weren't adapted or summarized by a secondary source, but they were edited and selected by a secondary source. It isn't fully objective, but it comes closest to being historical truth. https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278185734 2018-09-05 20:14:29 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278185734 Trains, Different https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186068 I believe this one is most accurate because it accounts for multiple survivors and not just one (Anne). The lyrics are straight from the survivors and show the reality of the holocaust. ]]> 2018-09-05 20:15:30 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186068 https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186128 I believe Different Trains is closest to achieving "historical truth" because Reich uses first hand testimonies from survivors and incorporates his actual experiences rather than with the others they used pieces of Anne's journal instead of the entire thing and had their own interpretation of it. 

]]> 2018-09-05 20:15:40 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186128 Anne Frank: A Living Voice https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186399 I feel that Anne Frank: A Living Voice was the most accurate because Anne's diary was changed slightly, but it was not changed as much as the testimonies in Different Trains. ]]> 2018-09-05 20:16:32 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186399 Different Trains https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186454 In my opinion, Different Trains is the closest to achieving "historical truth". Reich doesn't just focus on one perspective but focuses on multiple characters and also talks about before, during, and after the war. 

]]> 2018-09-05 20:16:44 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186454 Anne Frank: A Living Voice https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186502 The musical was more impactful and emotionally connected to the diary ]]> 2018-09-05 20:16:55 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186502 I think different trains is more accurate because it includes the broad overview of the war and not just one persons experience. https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186536 2018-09-05 20:16:58 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186536 Anne Frank: A Living Voice https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186547 I feel that A Living Voice is the most accurate because it does not create create a new story, but takes the original words of Anne Franks Diary, and shapes it to music. I believe that this was done to keep the same mood and story as the original Dairy, and because of this A Living voice is the most historical accurate because it doesn't change and rewrite the original work, but takes the all ready created pieces to shape the new median, witch in this case is a musical piece.]]> 2018-09-05 20:17:00 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186547 Annelies https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186696 In my opinion, Annelies is the most historically accurate because it is based on the diary of Anne Frank, a girl that died in the Holocaust while at a Death Camp. It is the most accurate because it is a first-person account and gives insight to what happened to the Frank family and the Van Pels family while they were in hiding in the Achterhuis, the three hidden rooms behind the bookcase. ]]> 2018-09-05 20:17:28 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186696 https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186796 Different Trains was the most emotionally stimulating and understand out of the three works, in my opinion. Hearing th voices of actual victims and not just their accounts made it more real, and easier to connect with.]]> 2018-09-05 20:17:47 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186796 Different Trains https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186959 In my opinion, Different Trains comes closest to historical accuracy when compared to Annelies and Anne Frank: A Living Voice because it includes first hand accounts on their experiences with the Holocaust rather than being a complete adaptation. There are parts that are adapted but it is the most realistic. ]]> 2018-09-05 20:18:23 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278186959 Annelies https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278187125 I believe that Annelies is the closest comparison to the opinions and voices of the Holocaust. This is because it reflects Anne Frank in her diary while in Different Trains the author Steve Reicher changed the claims of the people. ]]> 2018-09-05 20:18:49 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278187125 https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278187588 I believe Different Trains stands out in historical context because it actually took the voices and stories of actual survivors and transformed them into a beautiful musical masterpiece without changing the stories or altering the way they were supposed to be perceived. Different Trains is very authentic and original and I think for me at least, that had the most impact in a historical sense. 
 
]]> 2018-09-05 20:19:28 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278187588 different trains https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278187640 the use of firsthand accounts from both holocaust victims and american jews of the time period showed the vast differences in lifestyles. the phrases as part of the main melody felt more organic as opposed to the more theatrical performances of anne frank: a living voice and annelies]]> 2018-09-05 20:19:38 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278187640 Different Trains https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278188073 I think they all are altered in some way, whether it be picking and choosing what to use or leaving specifics out, but I like different Trains because it has the survivors voices and that makes it more real to me. ]]> 2018-09-05 20:19:57 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278188073 Anne Frank: A Living Voice https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278188108 All three pieces have their downfalls but I feel that Anne Frank: A Living Voice sticks closest to it's source material. By using excerpts from the diary a more realistic and accurate portrayal is obtained. ]]> 2018-09-05 20:20:00 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278188108 A Living Voice https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278189240 A Living voice uses Anne's actual words and because it is done in a musical fashion it adds emotion to her words. Although Different Trains uses actual recordings, it is more objective does not offer the emotion that A Living Voice does. ]]> 2018-09-05 20:21:40 UTC https://padlet.com/dana_gorzelany/d84jv9axexts/wish/278189240