Debt in a Changing World by https://padlet.com/elisedermineur/d5sdi98achzomfes What is the central theme or message of the book? Are there any key arguments or claims presented in the reading? Which ones? How convincing or well-supported are they? What evidence/source material does the author provide to support their arguments? Are there any counterarguments or alternative perspectives worth considering? How does the reading relate to other texts or theories we have discussed in the seminars/lectures thus far? Are there any conflicting or complementary ideas? en-us 2023-06-21 10:54:47 UTC 2025-12-25 16:49:50 UTC hello@padlet.com Group 2 https://padlet.com/elisedermineur/d5sdi98achzomfes/wish/2629112988 1.) The central theme is to investigate the connection between debt and ambitions among low-income people and households in South Africa. Also to extend the existing literature about the indebted South African society for the time period year 1990 and onwards. 

2.) Considering the key arguments presented is that even if you are over your head about borrowing there are still opportunities. Our intuition is that the arguments are convincing. 

3.) In terms of source material, for example analyses by economists, interviews, novels, observations and surveys, are being used. To exemplify this, look at the first chapter where it is referred to "black diamonds" - indebted people are not only buying based on greed, but also e.g. because of obligation and care.

4.) The author relies on ethnographic research conducted in Johannesburg, utilizing qualitative methods such as participant observations, interviews and focus groups to gain firsthand insights into the experience and perspectives of individuals and households. ]]> 2023-06-21 11:20:24 UTC https://padlet.com/elisedermineur/d5sdi98achzomfes/wish/2629112988 Group 3 https://padlet.com/elisedermineur/d5sdi98achzomfes/wish/2629119021 1 & 2
- Aspiration for an increase in quality of life causes increased indebtedness 
- Informational asymmetries, neoliberalism, power and gender relations, culture & social demands exacerbates the problem
- Credit-apartheid (due to 'white' dominans in the financing system, instead of in the government)

3. 
- Anthropological & multifaceted view, interview material, social focus
- Less generalisability but increased understanding 

4. 
- Similarities with the American dream in South Africa (Trumbull and James)
- Social and historical similarities with Graeber, with peer to peer lending and social demands for lending 

Other 
- Savings clubs are interestingly more in-stable as they're dependent on individual deposits and dependent on trust
- Stokvel networks similar to Graebers lending network? In their instability and chain reactions


]]> 2023-06-21 11:30:56 UTC https://padlet.com/elisedermineur/d5sdi98achzomfes/wish/2629119021 Group 1 https://padlet.com/elisedermineur/d5sdi98achzomfes/wish/2629125902 What is the central theme or message of the book?  
The emergence of debt in South Africa and the ambivalence surrounding debt as both a way to agency but also as a kind of bondage. Trying the describe the complex interaction between the history of colonialism, liberal market economics and apartheid. 
]]> 2023-06-21 11:43:58 UTC https://padlet.com/elisedermineur/d5sdi98achzomfes/wish/2629125902