Chp 4 The Giver 9D by Lise İngilizce Anabilim https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j Discussion en-us 2021-03-31 06:43:38 UTC 2021-04-01 05:45:39 UTC hello@padlet.com liseingilizce https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370810779 Larissa told Jonas about the celebration of Roberto’s release that morning. Then she went on to tell about Edna’s release. Larissa said, “Well, they tried to make her life sound meaningful. And of course, all lives are meaningful, I don’t mean they aren’t. But Edna. My goodness. She was a Birthmother, and then she worked in Food Production for years, until she came here. She never even had a family unit.” 

In contrast, when she spoke about Roberto, she said, “But Roberto’s life was wonderful. He had been an Instructor of Elevens – you know how important that is – and he’d been on the Planning Committee. And – goodness, I don’t know how he found the time – he also raised two very successful children, and he was also the one who did the landscaping design for the Central Plaza…” 

 

What do Larissa’s words tell you about how the people in the community view others and place value on them? (Hint: Think about the roles to which people are assigned.)

]]> 2021-03-31 06:43:38 UTC https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370810779 Zeynep Savaş zeynepsavas_ https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370813061 People value each other by the jobs they have. First, Larissa talk about, Edna's life before she got released. Edha is a birthmother and in this community birthmother is not a valuable job. She also worked in food production. But nobody support her. And they don't think her life is impressive. I think Their respect for you depends on your profession. If your position is high, you will be respected.]]> 2021-03-31 06:44:45 UTC https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370813061 Deniz https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370813154 People value each other by the things that they have done before they get released. 
 When we compared being a birthmother to being in a job which is in a higher statute it doesnt seem as valuable as that kind of job. Because of that they are triying to make Edna's life sound meaningful because they dont think it is impressive enough. 
But I think they are breaking the rules of utopia by judging peoples and deciding their value by their jobs]]> 2021-03-31 06:44:47 UTC https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370813154 Arhan ER arhanera https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370813201 They see you as your position. They will respect your position not you. If your position is in a high place you will be respected. If you are a birthmother you can't even have a family and you will be forced to hard labour.]]> 2021-03-31 06:44:48 UTC https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370813201 ekin ekinarikkan https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370813240 The roles that are given to the people in the community shows their values. They judge the people by their jobs. If you have an important job you get respected more than the other people. Edna as a birthmother didn't even have a family unit.]]> 2021-03-31 06:44:50 UTC https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370813240 Zeynep Danışmaz zeynepdanismaz https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370813252 People value each other according to their assignments that they get. So basically they don’t respect you in person they respect you because of your job. They don’t care about your skills or your life it is just your job that matters for them. For example if you are a birthmother like Edna, your life wouldn’t be that easy. Because people are underestimating those people who have no respectability in the community at all.

]]> 2021-03-31 06:44:50 UTC https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370813252 ayse aysenaztnyr https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370813372 They value each other by the things that they did . For example when Larissa was talking about Edna's release the only thing that she have done was being a birthmother and working in food production, this means these things are not valuable. 
But when Larissa was talking about Roberto's life; he was an instructor of the elevens, he had been in the planning committee and he also raised two children. And wee see these things have a value.]]> 2021-03-31 06:44:54 UTC https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370813372 nikol https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370813379 In this community people classify you by your proffesion. For example ıf you are a birthmother you probably get the wost  treatment. As we read in redna's life story, just because her proffesion she couldn't even had a family unit.]]> 2021-03-31 06:44:54 UTC https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370813379 Defne Eryurt https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370813430 they value each other by the things they did. if the thing you do is important you get more respect but if you are a birthmother like Edna you can't even have a family unit.]]> 2021-03-31 06:44:56 UTC https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370813430 Mustafa senmustafa790 https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370814026 People treat you by your job like larissa said. İf you have a good job people can treat you better. Roberto was the instructor of elevens so people respected him. Edna was a birthmother and she couldnt even have a family.]]> 2021-03-31 06:45:13 UTC https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370814026 Kuzey https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370814694 Larissa's words show us that some roles in the community are more valuable from the others, and they value the people based on their work.]]> 2021-03-31 06:45:31 UTC https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370814694 Arda ardahacioglu5 https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370818182 People in this community compares by their jobs that they have done before they get released. In a short way Larrisa wants to show how important to being a great job in their life in community because they treated acording to their jobs.]]> 2021-03-31 06:47:18 UTC https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370818182 defne su defnesu https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370824573
It seems that people value achievements, skills, experiences and occupations more than the person themselves. They look down on people who have been assigned jobs that they deemed unworthy, and praise others who have been assigned respectable jobs according to themselves. In the end your occupation decides if people will be respecting you or not. ]]> 2021-03-31 06:50:15 UTC https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1370824573 Alisa alisaozdemir https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1371182213 They value each other by the life they lived before they get released. And the life that you live depends on your profession so they are judging people by their jobs.]]> 2021-03-31 09:42:41 UTC https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1371182213 Melek https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1373439723 Everyone in the community is valued  according to their assignments that they get so thats mean citizens occupation is more important than the person themselves. ]]> 2021-03-31 21:09:26 UTC https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1373439723 Ahmet Emre Ersoy ahmetemreersoy https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1374362774 People treat everyone according to their jobs. If you are a birthmother you will not have even a family unit. But if you have another job people would treat you better.]]> 2021-04-01 05:34:34 UTC https://padlet.com/liseingilizce/d1qulzomrzpm2k2j/wish/1374362774