https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8 You are an American Soldier coming back from World War I. Would you rather be dealing with the physical loss of a body part or limb or would you rather deal with the psychological impact of PTSD? en-us 2023-02-15 01:17:30 UTC 2025-10-19 15:14:58 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet-uploads.storage.googleapis.com/1058117395/f065d918b0826eaecb27be048fcb2c2b/war.jpg https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483531086 I say this because I could always get a prosthetic but PTSD is something that lives with you for the rest of your life, in fact as someones who has it, it isn't fun and its hard to do most thing without being reminded of your trauma. Also I could just learn how to do normal everyday tasks without said limb but with having a psychological trauma such as PTSD, anything could trigger it and you could start having a panic attack whenever.]]> 2023-02-15 14:20:45 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483531086 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483532814 I would rather have PTSD because i would not want to lose a limb and feel pain. The reason why i say PTSD is because that will make me feel worse and remember every second of the war.]]> 2023-02-15 14:21:56 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483532814 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483534056 2023-02-15 14:22:48 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483534056 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483534841 i would rather lose a boddy part then having phsychological impacts because for example if i come back from the war i dont want my family to see me having ptsd impacts but if i lose a body part i could always just get a prosthetic. ]]> 2023-02-15 14:23:21 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483534841 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483535253 I would rather lose a limb instead of coming back with PTSD. If I were to lose a limb I could get a wooden leg and I could still be able to function in my daily life with some difficulty. PTSD or shell-shock would leave me being unable to function as most soldiers with PTSD cant handle being around loud noises and having to live with the mental toll of what happened in the war.]]> 2023-02-15 14:23:37 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483535253 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483536504 I would rather lose a body part because even though I may be left crippled at least I would be able to have a stable mental state because if I had PTSD then simple sounds such as car horns could make me go crazy and I feel like it would make it difficult for me and anyone around me to live with that. Also, a loss of a limb could have me sent home for I will be useless in the war and then I will have at last be at peace away from the violence, however, having PTSD will make the war much worse for any sound I hear will trigger a devastating memory and make me go mad(crazy).]]> 2023-02-15 14:24:18 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483536504 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483536675 I would rather choose the psychological impacts of war because if i lost a body part i would lose a lot of blood. I would rather deal with my psychological problems then lose a body part]]> 2023-02-15 14:24:25 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483536675 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483536724 l rather loss a body part because if l get shot or blow up on my leg l rather tell the doctor to cut it off instand ]]> 2023-02-15 14:24:27 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483536724 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483536940 I would rather have PTSD instead of losing a body part because losing a body part could be challenging you wont be able to do many things and you'll probably struggle and also losing a body part can cause a lot of pain.]]> 2023-02-15 14:24:35 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483536940 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483537810 2023-02-15 14:25:06 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483537810 winnyn https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483538295 I would rather lose a body part than deal with PTSD is because i feel like losing a body part would be easy to get used to, even though it will be a struggle to do somethings in life. I could also have a metal arm or a wooden arm. ]]> 2023-02-15 14:25:25 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483538295 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483538340 I would rather lose a body part because instead of being scared of loud sounds i can just get a wooden leg like one of the soldiers from the German side even if i can die like Kemmerich.]]> 2023-02-15 14:25:27 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483538340 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483538793 I would rather lose a body part because any psychological impacts of PTSD  u can't get  rid of On the other hand if you lose a body part u can get  prosthetic.]]> 2023-02-15 14:25:45 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483538793 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483542062 I would rather suffer from PTSD Because even though I'll have my trauma with me everywhere I go I will still have all my body parts. And losing a body part can start to make simple task even more difficult. ]]> 2023-02-15 14:27:49 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483542062 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483542163 I'd rather lose a body part because you could always get a wooden or metal body part. I wouldn't want to deal with any mental issues during that time because of the way they were treated. In the book, they told us that any soldiers with shell shock would be thrown into no mans land.]]> 2023-02-15 14:27:53 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483542163 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483542509 I rather lose a body part because i could always get a wooden leg or an iron leg or even be put on a wheel chair and i rather not have a Psychological effect because i will always remember my trauma and there no way of escaping it ]]> 2023-02-15 14:28:06 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483542509 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483543019 I would rather lose a part of my body than having PTSD because whenever you hear something loud you it would cause you to hear all the cries and explosions from the war and it is hard to get rid of since you hear a lot of noises and always be on edge like how Paul went back to his home town and when Paul was hearing all the loud noises he was on edge. ]]> 2023-02-15 14:28:25 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483543019 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483544044 i would rather lose my mind  because i don't want to lose a body part because you can die in the surgery.]]> 2023-02-15 14:29:05 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483544044 https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483544991 I prefer get one of my leg cut off and not PTSD because people will treat me differently ]]> 2023-02-15 14:29:39 UTC https://padlet.com/plafaille3/ctnajljjh1xrkft8/wish/2483544991