SIG2 meeting 14-10-2021 by https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z en-us 2020-02-29 10:31:43 UTC 2026-01-28 00:37:32 UTC hello@padlet.com Do you miss information? j_e_vandepol https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813072284 2021-10-13 06:35:50 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813072284 Is there anything that should be more concrete? j_e_vandepol https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813072602 2021-10-13 06:36:02 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813072602 Is it ok to not mention the key variables from this study, namely cue-utilization, cue-value perception accuracy, and cue-validity awareness in the summary? (it may get too complicated and too long to explain) j_e_vandepol https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813072948 2021-10-13 06:36:15 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813072948 Should I also describe why this is timely (and why is it timely???) j_e_vandepol https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813073387 2021-10-13 06:36:28 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813073387 Is the importance/urgency of this project clear? j_e_vandepol https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813073738 2021-10-13 06:36:38 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813073738 Is the proposal understandable? I use quite some terms/jargon and I’m afraid that it is very hard to follow now. Is this the case and what could help to make it easier to understand? j_e_vandepol https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813074488 2021-10-13 06:37:07 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813074488 The part where I discuss the actual studies is quite long. Is this understandable? Reviewers won’t spend a long time on reading the proposal so I’m afraid it is too long and hard to get an overview of the studies easily. Is this the case? And what could help? j_e_vandepol https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813074732 2021-10-13 06:37:17 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813074732 For the vidi, one has to show that it is aimed at building a new research line; is this clear or does it look too much as if I’m just continuing what I’m doing? If it looks like I’m just continuing what I’m doing, at what points did you get this idea and what could I do to prevent this? j_e_vandepol https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813075117 2021-10-13 06:37:30 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813075117 Title l_f_henrichs https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813649929 You might translate 'Towards' in the NL summary vertalen as 'Op naar..' ?]]> 2021-10-13 11:51:23 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1813649929 primary or secondary education? j_e_vandepol https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816207621 I'm still not sure whether to go for primary or secondary education. in primary education, students' levels differ and teachers differentiate more so this topic might be more relevant for primary education. Yet, the profiles that I use (struggling/strong students) from Seidel come from secondary education (no research on that in primary education) and Tina Seidel indicated that she would be worried that students' self-concept in primary education is less differentiated (all quite high). Also, a practical reason for me would be to go for secondary education because I have a much larger network of teachers in secondary education....

]]> 2021-10-14 06:40:50 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816207621 other child characteristics l_f_henrichs https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816284153 We wonder whether you should mention somewhere that also factors like ses and etnicity influence teachers' expectations - but that you will not focus on this for now (and why) - this might also matter when you design your vignetes: will the appearance of children or the way they talk play a role?]]> 2021-10-14 07:21:24 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816284153 https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816285616 Het voorstelgoed opgebouwd en je hebt een prettige schrijfstijl]]> 2021-10-14 07:22:14 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816285616 Equitable Educational opportunities l_f_henrichs https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816296912 This is a hot topic, and we think your proposal fits right in. You might be able to write about this a bit, what will you bring to teachers to become more objective -> provide equal opportunities]]> 2021-10-14 07:28:36 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816296912 https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816306103 It would be useful to have some more information about the possible subjects this judgement accuracy is most relevant for. For example presentations/essays or spelling/grammar tests. It could be helpful to include these examples]]> 2021-10-14 07:33:01 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816306103 Jargon, but well explained l_f_henrichs https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816317043 We think the way you consequently briefly explain jargon by using () works very well]]> 2021-10-14 07:38:50 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816317043 Paradigms e_e_vandijk https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816320546 We (M, E and I) were a bit confused by the term 'paradigm': this has a very fundamental connotation and made us think of more research paradigms ("interpretative"). What do you mean by this? And would there by other words that could describe this? Perspective maybe?]]> 2021-10-14 07:40:47 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816320546 Figure l_f_henrichs https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816321624 It is a bit confusing that the words in the figure are the same, it may need a bit more inormation ]]> 2021-10-14 07:41:27 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816321624 Well structured and clear proposal! l_f_henrichs https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816323388 2021-10-14 07:42:22 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816323388 Make your own role more clear l_f_henrichs https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816328012 The focus on the phd work and the post doc work is clear, but you might show more what your unique role and tasks (that justifies the work time you ask for) are]]> 2021-10-14 07:44:56 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816328012 Review unexpected l_f_henrichs https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816329251 You mention the need for a review relatively late, maybe show this earlier in the text.]]> 2021-10-14 07:45:36 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816329251 e_e_vandijk https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816340238 Tijdens het lesgeven zijn er naast inschatting van de performance ook nog heel veel andere overwegingen waarop docenten hun acties baseren (motivatie van leerlingen, persoonlijke vorming van leerlingen). Jouw studie zou aan die overwegingen iets toe kunnen voegen, namelijk wat wel/niet relevant is voor het inschatten van de prestaties van leerlingen. Een "perfect" accuraat oordeel is daarin misschien niet realistisch (we zijn immers geen robots), maar het zou oordelen van docenten wellicht aanzienlijk kunnen verbeteren. Soms kregen we een beetje het idee dat docentschap en wat docenten in de praktijk kunnen realiseren wat nuance misten, dus dit is een beetje een samenvatting voor hoe je dat zou kunnen aanvliegen. ]]> 2021-10-14 07:51:25 UTC https://padlet.com/j_e_vandepol/cavbyybd866z/wish/1816340238