Queer Worldings by Lila Miran https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . en-us 2021-02-18 16:34:58 UTC 2025-12-17 05:53:40 UTC hello@padlet.com alilnarim https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik/wish/1216000173 2021-02-18 16:42:28 UTC https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik/wish/1216000173 Questions alilnarim https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik/wish/1216017155 1. What is your general impression about the text?
- The text itself was messy, in-deep discussion is missing
- Too judgy
Reproduces stereotypes global north / south
- What is actually "messy"? Negative judging?

2. What do you think about the definition / use of the term queer in the given article?
- too negative in the article 
- too broad definition

3 How do you understand / what do you think about the worlding concept? 

- concept not 100 % clear to us
- power through diversity


4.Can you think of other examples, where the concept of worlding could be applied?

5.Chaotic queer spaces in the Global South vs. shiny organization in the Global North: what is your opinion about this contrasting juxtaposition?

- western point of view?
-  constructed
indifferntiated
- When Jakarta was "messy" it was critisised by the west... lost its culture? dio

]]> 2021-02-18 16:45:58 UTC https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik/wish/1216017155 Questions alilnarim https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik/wish/1216018110 1. What is your general impression about the text?

2. What do you think about the definition / use of the term queer in the given article?

3 How do you understand / what do you think about the worlding concept? 

4.Can you think of other examples, where the concept of worlding could be applied?

5.Chaotic queer spaces in the Global South vs. shiny organization in the Global North: what is your opinion about this contrasting juxtaposition?]]> 2021-02-18 16:46:08 UTC https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik/wish/1216018110 1. What is your general impression about the text? musermal https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik/wish/1218764533 - PERSPECTIVE: Another perspective on queer lives. Moves away from neoliberal perspectives and compares different types of queer. Looking at outcast people of the society / working class queer.

- ETHNOGRAPHY / STUDY DESIGN: Research Ethics: This is not how research should be. Derogative terms are used and are putting an opinion on people. Judging nature of the text was not appreciated. Structure of the text is difficult to follow.

- MESSY / mess: Can have a negative connotation. Can remind us of dirt.

- MESSY: Reclaiming the term "messy". Comparison to being normative. Their life stories are not in structured ways, but they have to go through more than others.

- Domesticity / feminine cleaning-up. Mess = masculine mess?

- Order ≠ Disorder / Capture the disruptive order of being queer]]> 2021-02-19 13:28:47 UTC https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik/wish/1218764533 2. What do you think about the definition / use of the term queer in the given article? musermal https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik/wish/1218768107 MARGINALISATION: Queer are being put on the edge of the society.

POSITIONALITY: What is the position of the author? Does he really intend for queer to reclaim the term "messy" or is he using it in a judging way?

DEFINITION: There is not the one queer person. But this is not discussed in this article.

QUEER = Mess does not have to be cleaned up. Speaking against this claim by others.

-different definitions of queer in text? "These two impossible subjects are not the “good Gay Index citizens” who “creatively” consumes and enable new modes of urban affluence."]]> 2021-02-19 13:30:01 UTC https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik/wish/1218768107 3. How do you understand / what do you think about the worlding concept? musermal https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik/wish/1218768608 PERSPECTIVE: New / alternative world order constructed.

MESSY: How do both concepts related to each other? They can oppose each other.]]> 2021-02-19 13:30:12 UTC https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik/wish/1218768608 4. Can you think of other examples, where the concept of worlding could be applied? musermal https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik/wish/1218769144 INVITATION to study queer in a different format without domestication and rendering them "normal". Complex reality, not systematic, no cause and logics about why things happen.

DECOLONISATION of colonial research ethics. Take a more ethnographic, and less normative approach on researching.]]> 2021-02-19 13:30:22 UTC https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik/wish/1218769144 5.Chaotic queer spaces in the Global South vs. shiny organization in the Global North: what is your opinion about this contrasting juxtaposition? musermal https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik/wish/1218770328 BIAS: Worlding idea of clean, rigid northern city and messy southern cities strengthens North-South biases. Worlding = non-strict/non-clean/non-structured spaces.]]> 2021-02-19 13:30:47 UTC https://padlet.com/alilnarim/c3rf1t226ho1skik/wish/1218770328