Chapter 4- Best Example of Reasoning by Megan Callari https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70 After revising based on teacher comments, read over your Chapter 4 response. Choose the best example of elaborated reasoning utilizing one of the 2 strategies taught in class. Include the claim, one piece of evidence, and the reasoning. en-us 2020-09-22 18:37:11 UTC 2025-10-11 17:37:55 UTC hello@padlet.com Chloe https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772661885 Edward is intelligent because...
 
"Edward sees us talk all the time so he learns words like perhaps”.

That piece of evidence proves that Edward is learning because he asked a question to Albert and he got the answer and that's learned because his brain grew.






]]> 2020-09-23 15:51:27 UTC https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772661885 Claim: Edward is a Jokester smillman2 https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772663312 Text:“Are you asleep, Edward?” I whispered. “Yes, I am,” said Edward, making me laugh.

Reasoning:  This shows Edward being cute and funny. Edward's response to Jake's question which was “Are you asleep Edward?” Edward's response is “Yes I am,” He started to make Jake laugh. Instead of saying Yes I am, He could have said No, not yet or just ignore it if Edward was asleep. Instead he said yes I am which tells Everyone that he is not asleep because he is talking.

]]> 2020-09-23 15:51:45 UTC https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772663312 Claim: One trait that I can explain how Edward acts is, he is curious. jogarcia8 https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772664129
Evidence: Edward always asked Albert personal questions.” He asked him anything and all things.”

Reasoning: When Edward asked Albert personal questions, that shows that Edward is curious because it is weird and not usual to ask people personal questions.]]> 2020-09-23 15:51:57 UTC https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772664129 Hunter hsheikowitz https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772664796 claim: Jake is studious
evidence: “You read that last year,” said Will, digging through the box. 
“I'll read it again,” I said. “I'll read it next year, too.” 
“I know,” said Will, smiling.
reasoning: This quote proves my thought because Jake already read that book and he is going to read it again and try to study it more so he can learn more about the adventure in the book.
]]> 2020-09-23 15:52:06 UTC https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772664796 Abby https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772665894 Claim:Maeve is a cheerful.
Evidence: "cakes that were Maeve’s trademark.She was not a good cook,Maeve made tea cakes with chocolate and marshmallow and almond cream icing topped with candied decorations.” Chapter 4
Reasoning:This quote supports my thought because even though Jake told the reader that Maeve was not a good cook, Jake also said cakes were Maeve’s trademark which must mean that she makes them every year. All of her children are happy to see their mother happy. Maeve still tries to get better because it makes her happy and she enjoys it.


]]> 2020-09-23 15:52:22 UTC https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772665894 Gavin gfranklin2 https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772671955 Claim: Will is a bookworm
 Evidence: Will loves books and always wants to read a good book. Will even says that “Will found two more books at the bottom of the box. “This is better than Christmas,” he said. p.g. 26
Reasoning: This quote supports my claim because Will loves books so much he thinks they are better than Christmas. You get presents and your family comes on Christmas and it’s a very happy day. So if Will likes books better than Christmas he must REALLY enjoy books.


]]> 2020-09-23 15:53:43 UTC https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772671955 Aradh https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772676115 Claim: Albert Is a good friend.

Evidence “Albert always told Edward the truth.”

Reasoning  This quote supports my claim because.. the text shows that Albert is a good friend because he never lied to Edward. Also a good and true friend never lies. 
 

]]> 2020-09-23 15:54:38 UTC https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772676115 Claim: Jake is Mature hgreen48 https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772677376 “Don’t you want to play?” asked Albert. “I like to watch,” I said. 

This quote proves my thought because Jake has matured to not want to slide in mud and even be enthusiastic about baseball that much. In this part of the text Jake is having a talk with Albert Groom, his neighbor, who enjoys spending time with the kids. Jake probably wants to watch to know what is going on. Jake probably, in his head, is thinking of baseball rules and what is happening, not yelling and screaming when his favorite player strikes out. Jake has matured to be the kid who thinks but does not act when not necessary. Most kids do scream and shout, Jake does not because Jake is mature. ]]> 2020-09-23 15:54:56 UTC https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772677376 Aleena ashaik2 https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772680333 Claim: Edward is Kind

Evidence: “Oh, I thought I'd walk with you, Edward,”  she said.
 Edward shook his head, making Jack smile.
 “You're busy, he said to Maeve, not unkindly. 

Reasoning: This proves my thinking because Edward realized that Maeve is too busy and is telling her that she can stay at home, and that she could stay home. This stands out to me because Edward is only 5 years old, but he's already being very kind. 

]]> 2020-09-23 15:55:37 UTC https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772680333 Surina ssingh157 https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772689554 Claim: Will is a curious character who has a thirst for knowledge.  

Text: “ ‘Books,’ Will whispered. He grinned.” 

Reasoning: This proves that Will is a curious character who has a thirst for knowledge because when he saw the book he probably felt really happy, I think this because after he whispered he grinned and that could be because he likes books and enjoys reading them.
]]> 2020-09-23 15:57:45 UTC https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772689554 Katie Kwei https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772702200 Edward is affectionate.

“‘Have you ever been in love?’ Edward asked Albert.”

This quote proves that Edward is affectionate, because he’s asking a Albert a private question...even if that may seem nosy, I know already that Edward likes Albert, therefore this just proves more that Edward shows an affection for Albert.]]> 2020-09-23 16:00:36 UTC https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772702200 edward jlarose3 https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772713290 Claim: Edward is curious.


Evidence #1:”Have you ever been in love? Edward asked Albert. “Edward, that’s private,” said Maeve.



Reasoning for Evidence #1: “This quote proves/supports my thought because …”“This part of the text proves/supports my thought because …”He keeps asking a lot of questions and people who ask a lot of questions are considered curious.


Evidence #2:“The knuckleball,” he said softly, so softly that everyone looked at him. “One of life's mysteries…….. and a small flip of the fingers and wrist, a round ball is thrown with zero spin.” He looked up suddenly. “A mystery.” “A mystery,” repeated Edward, staring at Albert.




Reasoning for Evidence #2: “This quote proves/supports my thought because …”“This part of the text proves/supports my thought because …”  Edward is curious because he wants to know why.

Evidence #3: “How old are you? asked Edward. Edward always asked Albert personal questions.”


Reasoning for Evidence #3: “This quote proves/supports my thought because …”“This part of the text proves/supports my thought because …” People who ask personal questions want to know about the person and they are considered curious.





]]> 2020-09-23 16:02:52 UTC https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772713290 katrin Claim: Edward is curious.Evidence #1: “Have you ever been in love?” Edward asked Albert.” (Chapter 4)Reasoning for Evidence #1: “This quote provesmy thought because you don’t usually ask people if they are in love.Edward wants to know more about Albert Groom because he thinks he is cool.Evidence #2: “Edward always asked Albert personal questions.” (Chapter 3-Page 19)Reasoning for Evidence #2: “This quote supports my thought because you don’t usually ask people personal questions. Edward is curious about Albert Groom because they are friends.Evidence #3: Edward asked Albert Groom “Did you live by the sea when you were little?” (Chapter 3-Page 19)Reasoning for Evidence #3: This part of the text supports my thought because Edward is curious to know about Albert Groom’s house during his childhood. Edward wants to know more about Albert because they are friends. https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772780422 2020-09-23 16:16:46 UTC https://padlet.com/mcallari1/c0pale4f32x9iy70/wish/772780422