Should we help these people? by Elissa Julian https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8 en-us 2023-10-18 23:23:01 UTC 2023-10-20 01:00:06 UTC hello@padlet.com Ms Julian ejulian1 https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753564221 I believe we could help in ensuring the wider world does not take advantages of their resources. However, we should not 'help' in terms of trying to reeducate or colonise them. ]]> 2023-10-19 00:27:31 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753564221 Alfie keeping https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753570247 I do not think we should help these people as we don’t know what they can do and can maybe take over the world as they will take Over one country and then the world so I disagree we should be friends they should stay home. I think it will be hard to colonise them as they dont ware clothes and want speak our language and will be very hard to learn. I dont think they are human so that is why i dont think we should be friends in the future. I think if they come in to country’s that live on te English way they will ruin it. They could maybe live in normal if but it will be bad if they cant speak but it will be good if they learn to wear the right clothes and drink water and eat our type of food. This is my opinion]]> 2023-10-19 00:31:12 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753570247 Alex klingberg https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753571279 I believe we should leave them alone because this culture has probably survived for many years and tampering with the traditions is not something that would bring peace.]]> 2023-10-19 00:31:52 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753571279 Thomas https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753571336 I disagree because if you do try to colonise we might bring some a virus which there body can’t handle.]]> 2023-10-19 00:31:55 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753571336 Kiran’s opinion https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753571764 Remember what happened last time we attempted colonisation to “help the world”?]]> 2023-10-19 00:32:10 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753571764 Felix wiseman https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753571877 I do not think we should help these people for 1 reason they simply just don't need help they are a thriving tribe if we went in and helped it could affect the whole tribe .]]> 2023-10-19 00:32:14 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753571877 Charlie on top https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753572297 I think we should not help them bc they r human]]> 2023-10-19 00:32:33 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753572297 Christian Foster https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753573010 We should not help these people because they have lived there for a long time and they do not need us]]> 2023-10-19 00:32:58 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753573010 Rhys https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753573120 Rhys 
These people are fine without us ,while we’re killing each other and destroying stuff there painting themselves without doing anything wrong .THEY ARE FINE LEAVE THEM ALONE]]> 2023-10-19 00:33:02 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753573120 Jack Rogan https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753573404 I believe we should not help these people because through the images we can tell that is a self sufficient society and does not need our help but, we should protect and conserve their area.]]> 2023-10-19 00:33:15 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753573404 Angus Brownrigg https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753573536 I think that we should not help them because if we help them they can take advantage of the resources they’re given and they could possibly harm us humans as they don’t understand us and the world. ]]> 2023-10-19 00:33:20 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753573536 Rishav Aryal https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753575057 I do not think we should engage with any of these tribes or people because we should respect their culture and leave them be.]]> 2023-10-19 00:34:22 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753575057 Ted Forsey https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753575090 I disagree with this argument, because they are a thriving civilisation and are not in need of help. They don’t need are help and if we stepped that could mean they go into panic mode and they into a panic and could mean a lot of casualties. These tribes are helping the land instead of destroying them because we have not been able to keep care, so when you think about it they are saving us in a way.


Another  response to this argument is that they don’t need are help and if we got in the way they would not know what to do. In their response they will probably will get scared and will not lesson. We also don’t know there language so we will have no communication with them so that means some stuff could go over wrong and get translated in a way you didn’t mean it or a way they could deem disrespectful.

————————————————————————————-

Organizations like Survival International work to protect uncontacted tribes from threats like deforestation, colonization and the spread of disease. According to Survival International, uncontacted tribes are a barrier to deforestation and climate change, especially in the Amazon rainforest (got this from the internet for the cons of colonisation).]]> 2023-10-19 00:34:24 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753575090 https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753575365 I DONT THINK WE SHOULD COLONISE THEEY WILL END THE WORLD.]]> 2023-10-19 00:34:33 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753575365 Iverson Yeo https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753575603 I think we should not help them as in educate them about (maths and english etc) because they might feel like they’re being treated like animals and attack us and i don’t think they’ll be happy to learn something they have no interest about.]]> 2023-10-19 00:34:42 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753575603 https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753576130 Don’t help them i dont know why though ]]> 2023-10-19 00:35:03 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753576130 Konrad https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753577281 I believe that we should not interfere with this tribes history and make sure that they can live as they have for Hundreds of years. One day they will evolve with more technology.]]> 2023-10-19 00:35:43 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753577281 Charlie https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753577313 2023-10-19 00:35:45 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753577313 Christian Simmonds https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753577397 I believe that we should leave these tribes alone, because they have not communicated for help and have lived there for an extremely long time and seem to be doing fine. We should respect their culture.

]]> 2023-10-19 00:35:47 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753577397 James https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753577458 I think we can help them by making sure that they don’t get interfered by modern humans ]]> 2023-10-19 00:35:50 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753577458 Markus Blanchard :) https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753577511 I believe we shouldn’t help them in case of the risk of getting captured and hurt. On the other hand we should help them from losing a whole new colony and learning from the past.
These are my reasons to why I am on the fence.]]> 2023-10-19 00:35:52 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753577511 Seb KK ejulian1 https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753578005 I belive that we need to keep there colony for as long as possible because this is are only tribe left. this will allow us to take a deep look into what are life was like. by this I mean we need leave them be. in addition we need to preserve the amazon to insure this tribe can live as long as possible. A question that I would like to know/learn is what their language is like. ]]> 2023-10-19 00:36:09 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753578005 Rhys https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753578262 People like us are screwing up and generally making a mess of everything like the ENVIRONMENT AND THE WASTE they’re doing just fine ]]> 2023-10-19 00:36:18 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753578262 Jordan Herrera-Hu https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753578815 I think that we shouldn’t help the tribe.

According the the United Nations Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention, 1989 (No. 169) it is clearly stated in article No.4 that:

Special measures shall be adopted as appropriate for safeguarding the persons, institutions, property, labour, cultures and environment of the peoples concerned.

Doing otherwise would be a breach of the UN’s convention. 
]]> 2023-10-19 00:36:38 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753578815 Aaron https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753581044 I disagree to help these people because they have survived all this time without contact with the outside world.]]> 2023-10-19 00:38:08 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753581044 Rhys https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753582875 They are self sufficient and we should learn from them ]]> 2023-10-19 00:39:16 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753582875 Rhys https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753585227 Colonisation is a bad idea my peoples 

]]> 2023-10-19 00:40:44 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753585227 Henry https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753585433 I believe that we should not invade or colonise this part of the the world as it could impact their mental wellbeing as they won’t be able to catch up to our modernised culture. This will destroy this culture and belief's and the environment at the same time. ]]> 2023-10-19 00:40:52 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753585433 https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753588645 They should live in nice places as they are human and are no difference as us other than them not wearing clothes ]]> 2023-10-19 00:42:54 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753588645 Christian Foster https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753590826 Tribes and mobs don’t need our useless help because they’ve lived here and survived for a long time (or at least of what we assume…we don’t actually how long they’ve been there) . It will do nothing to help the tribe so I VOTE NO TO THE COLONISATION OF THIS UNKNOWN TRIBE. We’re already destroying our own country, causing world wars, wars, devastating, problems that will cause us death. We do not need to affect them as we have to ourselves. There are hundreds of ways that we have had with wars, we do NOT need to cause them these problems; let alone they probably wouldn’t understand us. According to google, it takes  2 years to learn a new language. Back then, in the 1700s, 1800, colonisations have happened to so many countries, including us Australians. We can’t help them, we won’t change them so that equals to…. Nothing ventured, nothing gained. Plus they might have special traditions that they might share. What is a positive that WE will all gain from taking over?…. Think about it, form your own opinion, but for me, I say NO to helping them. So after this, I believe as an individual, that we, as a country should leave them alone, don’t get in contact with them and let them live their lives.]]> 2023-10-19 00:44:23 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753590826 Rhys https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753591428 So stop it like honestly it’s just dumb like really terrible 
,So it’s like just stop mate what are you doing just go away you stupid idiot they aren’t destroying the world are they that is US 
not them so yeah]]> 2023-10-19 00:44:50 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753591428 https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753596452 L people who agree]]> 2023-10-19 00:48:09 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2753596452 Wbfugweugweygyy https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2755399895 Uhfuwgbfiuyugsryfhgsiyuhhfisuy]]> 2023-10-20 01:00:06 UTC https://padlet.com/ejulian1/bzrv3jbrerodauf8/wish/2755399895