https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p Post your case analysis here en-us 2016-10-05 16:24:07 UTC 2025-12-03 11:57:59 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409594872 Transfer of presidency from Adams and Jefferson

Adams tries to pack the court with Federalists
 -Senate approves of this

William Marbury is a Federalist judge and wants the Secretary of State (James Madison) to give him the job. 

John Marshall (a Federalist) is the current Chief Justice...

If Marshall rules in favor of Marbury, the ruling will be ignored and the Supreme Court will seem weak.]]> 2019-11-11 17:58:54 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409594872 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409596355 Should Marshall give Marbury his job?]]> 2019-11-11 18:01:55 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409596355 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409596563 Judiciary Act of 1789 is decided to be unconstitutional. It allowed the Supreme Court original jurisdiction in cases when it shouldn't have 
under the Constitution.]]> 2019-11-11 18:02:21 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409596563 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409599441 This gives the Supreme Court the power of judicial review - the power to determine the Constitutionality of laws.]]> 2019-11-11 18:07:59 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409599441 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409600476 Does any state have the constitutional right to tax an agency of the United States Government?]]> 2019-11-11 18:09:43 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409600476 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409600506 James McCulloch won the case]]> 2019-11-11 18:09:47 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409600506 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409600560 Confirmed the right of congress to use the implied powers clause which is anything “necessary and proper”]]> 2019-11-11 18:09:53 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409600560 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409600907 They ruled that Georgias voiding of the 1795 grant was invalid since it violated the contract clause of the constitution ]]> 2019-11-11 18:10:35 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409600907 johnteng https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409600980 In 1795, Georgia Legislature granted the sale of cheap land to private corporations. This was repealed in 1796, however, due to fraud. In 1800, John Peck bought some land that was part of the original 1795 plan, and in 1803 he sold some of it to Robert Fletcher. Fletcher eventually realized that the 1796 ruling made his purchase from Peck void, and he sued for damages. A federal circuit court ruled in favor of Peck, and Fletcher subsequently appealed to the US Supreme Court.]]> 2019-11-11 18:10:45 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409600980 sanjanachadive https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409601340 Should the New Hampshire Legislature change Dartmouth, a privately funded institution, into a state univeristy (private --> public)?

]]> 2019-11-11 18:11:25 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409601340 anishsuresh https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409602015 Could the contract between Fletcher and Peck be invalidated by an act of the Georgia legislature?]]> 2019-11-11 18:12:41 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409602015 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409603008 Are the Georgia statutes relating to the Cherokee nation in violation of the Constitution of the United States?]]> 2019-11-11 18:14:25 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409603008 sanjanachadive https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409603594 In 1769, Dartmouth College received a charter from King George III; the charter gave 12 trustees full power to oversee the college and its administration. It stated that the college corporation should always continue under the 12 trustees. However, in 1816, the New Hampshire legislature passed an act declaring that Dartmouth would continue as a state-run university]]> 2019-11-11 18:15:28 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409603594 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409603913 For a short time, the Cherokee were recognized as a sovereign nation, and only Congress was permitted to set laws regarding them (not the states). The ruling favored the federal government over the state government. Though, Andrew Jackson hardly enforced this law. Not long afterward, the Cherokee were forced westward on the Trail of Tears.]]> 2019-11-11 18:16:03 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409603913 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409605964 The Cherokee were recognized as a sovereign foreign nation.]]> 2019-11-11 18:19:44 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409605964 jacobsosinsky https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409606178 A state legislature cannot invalidate a contract. The ruling also gave more protection to property rights; earliest Supreme Court case that invalidated a state's ruling. ]]> 2019-11-11 18:20:07 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409606178 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409606245

Odgen was given the right to operate vessels in bays and rivers between NJ and NYC, passed down by John Livingston

Gibbons had ships in those waters

Ogden took case to New York Legislature and he won the case.

Gibbons then took it to Supreme Court 

]]> 2019-11-11 18:20:13 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409606245 allisonarnold https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409606456

Charter of Second National Bank~ April 1816 

Maryland imposed “stamp tax” on the paper that banks used in printing bank notes 

• Aimed at Second National bank 

James McCulloch 

• Cashier of Baltimore branch 
• Refused to pay the tax 

State of Maryland sued McCulloch

]]> 2019-11-11 18:20:37 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409606456 naomiconsiglio https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409606992 8-1 decision that the state violated Article 1, protecting the contract made by the college. ]]> 2019-11-11 18:21:31 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409606992 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409607062 Are the laws to regulate interstate commerce passed by the New York legislature unconstitutional? ]]> 2019-11-11 18:21:39 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409607062 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409607198

After Marshall’s statement, the Court broadened the definition of commerce so it now included regulation of transportation

Court could keep individual states from interfering in the conduct of trade by those living in other states, so court decided federal laws trumped state laws 

]]> 2019-11-11 18:21:52 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409607198 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409607342

“Commerce” was expanded to mean both the exchange of goods and services and the transportation of those goods

Gave congress the ability to regulate commerce across state boundaries

Avoided threatening the south by not taking away all state's power in regulating commerce

Opened door to the expansion of nations economy→ States could not interfere with the building of roads, canals, ect

]]> 2019-11-11 18:22:05 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409607342 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409607411 Around 1832, the American government was encroaching on Native American Rights--especially in the Southeast where there was plentiful farm land. Georgia's state government, along with President Jackson, supported the decision to remove the Native Americans from the Southeast to the West. The Southeast Native Americans, mainly the Cherokee Nation, responded to the governments attempts of removal of Natives with calling the decision unconstitutional.]]> 2019-11-11 18:22:11 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409607411 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409607730 State governments cannot invalidate private contracts. 

]]> 2019-11-11 18:22:40 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/bxzm5txidp7p/wish/409607730