Socratic Seminar-Outer Circle by Seif Tahayneh

mst98 — 2019-02-12 08:07:46 UTC

You can rate other people's critiques and comments by a star system that ranges from 1-5 stars.

mst98 — 2019-02-12 08:08:50 UTC

You can also comment on someones post if you have a different opinion, or if you want to reinforce their ideas and comments.

mst98 — 2019-02-12 08:09:15 UTC

Each person from the outer circle has a column in which they can write and critique.

mst98 — 2019-02-12 08:09:56 UTC

Please only use constructive and Unbiased Criticism on other people's works.

Finally

mst98 — 2019-02-12 08:10:25 UTC

The name of each person in the outer circle is going to be on the top left corner on each of his text boxes.

Keep this for the end

mst98 — 2019-02-13 09:06:19 UTC

We'd like you guys to rate How the Socratic Seminar went , And how much you personally enjoyed the discussion for this book.

Ratings For The Seminar

mst98 — 2019-02-13 09:08:19 UTC

Ratings For The Book

mst98 — 2019-02-13 09:08:36 UTC

nice work

2019-02-19 07:51:00 UTC

abdullah ahli

ahli33445573 — 2019-02-19 07:52:23 UTC

my partner name is abdullah qazm.
TBH abdullah did a great job,he participated in the discussion he had good eye contact to all of them while he was talking and listing. he asked many question.One of the questions was about the protagonist that made the discussion move on.That shows that he read the novel and he understands it .the Socratic seminar was perfect all of them participated,the only one that didn't take apart was Zaid maybe because he didn't read the novel.Saif was the star of the seminar he actually did a excellent job. i learned a lot about the novel from this Socratic seminar.

Ali bin Ali

mohdadel193 — 2019-02-19 07:53:07 UTC

Ali bin ali started by talking about the author's mom but he was looking at the teacher instead of his classmates and he was talking in a low voice.

zaid aq

mohamad8440041 — 2019-02-19 07:53:54 UTC

He is not active in the conversation but he is listening
nice question
quiet but he is listening but don't have the confident to ask a question
he is entering the conversation just by saying yes or no
he asked a nice question now with confident
zaid entered and changed the topic

taqi al wazzan

yx21511 — 2019-02-19 07:54:48 UTC

you have to participate more but your responds are good when they ask you and you engage in side conversation and your eye contact to your partners is good

azizalbazaaz — 2019-02-19 07:56:30 UTC

bin ali

A great question

mohdadel193 — 2019-02-19 07:57:30 UTC

Ali asks Taqi on his personal view of what will he do if they were in that time. He asked a good question related to great depression.He asked another great question.Ali asked Safrini with a great question relating it to the title of the story"Do you have any fears in life"

Seif tahayneh

mst98 — 2019-02-19 07:58:27 UTC

Seif tahaynah is demonating the conversation and participiating in every discussion.

He speaks and interacts

mohdadel193 — 2019-02-19 07:59:38 UTC

Ali interacts and speaks in the discussion but he cut of Omar Fares and Seif. He again cut of Tamer.Ali turn the seminar to a debate.Ali cuts out Nasouh. Ali also cuts of Zaid. Ali cuts out Abdulla Kazim with a question.Ali interrupted Tamer again. He stopped interacting after some time.He did't interact alot at the end of the seminar.

He responds to question

mohdadel193 — 2019-02-19 08:02:12 UTC

He responded to Omar's question "Do you think the father left to help?" ali responds "Yes! he obviously went to help not on a vacation."(question and answer not accurate). He sited evidence from the story to support his answer.

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:02:27 UTC

He sometimes interrupts to others to exclaim his thoughts.

OMAR

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:04:49 UTC

He joined the conversation with a really good answer, he is actually really particapating.

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:06:31 UTC

Seif was connecting to previously read knowledge in a relevant way such as the lord of the flies to the story that they're discussing

tamer

ahmadrefai — 2019-02-19 08:07:39 UTC

he is active in the socratic seminar but he interrupted his friends 2 times

Abdalla kazim

ahmadrefai — 2019-02-19 08:08:48 UTC

He interrupted his classmates and had side conversations with his friends and he ask a few questions but the questions he asked were very good and referable to the text

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:09:40 UTC

He is listening well to the conversation but isnt sure when to involve into the equation, I think that he should build up more confidence.

abdalla kazim

ahmadrefai — 2019-02-19 08:10:00 UTC

every time he says something and then stays quiet

Nasouh

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:10:35 UTC

Nasouh is listening well and he is not participating. He seems to be out of focus or in a reverie during the conversation

abdalla kazim

ahmadrefai — 2019-02-19 08:10:48 UTC

he hears out his friends

His comment about the theme

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:13:48 UTC

Seif talked about the theme and called it a responsibility which is relevant and was able to fix a mistake which a partner in the discussion said.

abdalla kazim

ahmadrefai — 2019-02-19 08:14:09 UTC

he always involves in the side of the conversation

abdalla kazim

ahmadrefai — 2019-02-19 08:14:31 UTC

answered nasouhs question

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:15:39 UTC

Nasouh has potential but isnt able to express himself. He should try to be more active within the conversation.

Nasouh

mohamad8440041 — 2019-02-19 08:15:49 UTC

Nasouh answered a question seif asked. I feel like nasouh can talk more. Nasouh asked a question about who is the protagonist and antagonist. It was a really good question
Nasouh answered a question seif asked about how the lives of people was better before the great depression. And how its bad and that everyone lost his job. Nasouh disagreed with taqi
\

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:16:35 UTC

He expressed his opionion about the story in a well thought manner which initiated a conversation about symblosim and figurative language.

abdalla kazim

ahmadrefai — 2019-02-19 08:18:02 UTC

having side talks with tamir while saif is talking

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:18:06 UTC

Omar is being consistent with his participation and isnt falling back in the conversation and is always trying to add more information into the topic.

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:18:42 UTC

Nasouh's participation is a bit inconsistant but now he is improving and is trying to be more active and also related the topic to the great depression which took over the world in the 20th century.

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:20:42 UTC

There was a bit of a riot in the conversation due to a disagreement which seif calmed down and instead tried to curve that topic and changed it instead.

Side conversation

mohdadel193 — 2019-02-19 08:20:45 UTC

Ali did not engaged in any side talks.

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:23:36 UTC

Nasouh is starting to start new conversations by asking critical questions

at the end of the seminar Zaid started answering,and Ali was a bit daydreaming.the question that Ali asked Mohammed was really a nice question

ahli33445573 — 2019-02-19 08:24:17 UTC

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:25:12 UTC

Seif tahayneh critically analyzed the story in details and he said about how it's still difficult to live even in this century and he said that auther would still struggle in this era. However I believe that with all the current technology, it's alot easier to find a job and it's currently easier to live a healthy life

he is looking at his novel more than he is looking at his claasmates

rashed_bm9 — 2019-02-19 08:27:00 UTC

he answered seif's question and opened a new disscusion. till know he is so good. and his performance is good from the beginning.
he is getting silent for a while.
i rated 4 out of 5

taqi al wazzan

yx21511 — 2019-02-19 08:27:00 UTC

you have to ask more questions but you referred to text and you did not interrupt another speaker

taqi al wazzan

yx21511 — 2019-02-19 08:30:04 UTC

taqi listens to his partners without interrupting them

he involved in the conversation about the moms pregnancy

ahmadrefai — 2019-02-19 08:30:07 UTC

ibrahim9_2002 — 2019-02-19 08:30:18 UTC

omar is determined and focused more than the others 👍

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:30:25 UTC

Seif successfully saved a conversation from being switched and instead elaborated within that conversation but he tried to shut off ali from the conversation

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:33:18 UTC

Nasouh related the story to a personal experience in a war torn country in a powerful way.

i loved his answer when saif asked a question about fear or death

ahmadrefai — 2019-02-19 08:34:35 UTC

ibrahim9_2002 — 2019-02-19 08:35:05 UTC

omar welcomed the hotspot “safarini” with a smart question.

My personal opinion about the book.

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:36:27 UTC

The story has been very montone and is just depressing with no figurative language, however I was able to relate to the narrator on a personal level with his powerful way of engaging the readers. This story would get an overall of 3/5.

my personal opinion about the book

ahmadrefai — 2019-02-19 08:36:49 UTC

is that its too depressing and i got give it 4 out of 5

My opinion about the seminar

mst98 — 2019-02-19 08:39:28 UTC

This seminar has been very well orginized. seif has been a good leader throughout the seminar and was able to keep it going smoothly. People who weren't participating in the begining got excited to participate and it was an overall good and interesting discussion which made me learn new information.