https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400 1) What does citizenship mean to you? 2) How is Kimmerer's conception of citizenship in conversation with your conception of citizenship (ex: similar/dissimilar/shared facets)? 3) What questions or thoughts are produced by Kimmerer's conception of citizenship? en-us 2017-10-11 17:26:36 UTC 2023-10-11 23:06:59 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742541682 1. It's your identity and a sense of belonging.
2. I think we have a shared belief. I particularly agree with the statement "...the law of reciprocity, of regeneration, of mutual flourishing".
3. I think it's a thought provoking abstract with regards to "your sense of belonging". Who or what are you a citizen of? ]]> 2023-10-11 22:48:22 UTC https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742541682 bezamuzein https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742542088 2023-10-11 22:48:59 UTC https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742542088 https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742542731 1. Relationship between an individual and the country they live in.
2. Similar I feel that citizenship is definitively a matter of shared beliefs as we are a global community and need to understand and respect others beliefs.
3. Makes us ponder how difficult it is to assimilate into a new community or country and the challenges that are faced when doing so. 

]]> 2023-10-11 22:50:06 UTC https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742542731 https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742544253 1) It means your intelligence, labor, and knowledge are shared/used for the development of a community. And you receive the benefit of others' sharing in that community.
2) I feel it is possible that one builds up belief/understanding first and then finds citizenship. However, I think for lots of people, citizenship is born before they know it. So I don't know if I agree with it.
3) Even you do not agree or feel belonging to a community, you own the citizenship of that community - it's tricky.]]> 2023-10-11 22:52:43 UTC https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742544253 https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742544381 1) Citizenship is belonging to a country. It can also mean to have humanity within a community
2) Kimmerer's community is nature.
3) Kimmerer encourages man to break the mental colonialism mindset. ]]> 2023-10-11 22:52:55 UTC https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742544381 https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742544515 1) A sense of where you come from and/or live that you have a sense of belonging to.
2) Kind of similar because it has to do with idea of belonging in terms of working together and being part of a unit.
3) Thought- I like the idea of thinking about mankind as a whole and not always separating depending on geographic location]]> 2023-10-11 22:53:11 UTC https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742544515 https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742545347 1) A relationship and support for an institution and its history with a feeling of belonging.
2) It's similar in that you have the same beliefs, but different in that you're not claiming fealty to a leader nor does it necessitate supporting all of its laws. 
3) It makes me consider the complexity of the relationship between citizens and residents and the spectrum of beliefs/ties. Also, how some naturally born citizens may not actually share the sense of belonging as those who became citizens later.]]> 2023-10-11 22:54:31 UTC https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742545347 https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742546387 1.Our every thought is anthropocentric. My thought is also. Meaning of citizenship to me is being a member of human society in this world. We are human race who should rule this world. 
2. Kimmerer's thought is biocentric where human does not have any special position in nature.
3. Kimmerer's thought generates the question that if we can rest our existence on the lap of nature?

]]> 2023-10-11 22:56:14 UTC https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742546387 https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742546928 1.  Citizenship to me means to obtain status from a particular country. Specifically where one was born and raised. 
2. Kimmereers conception of citizenship is similar but more so focuses of it being based on reciprocity 
3. Kimmerers conception advocated for a sense of belief system. Forces individuals to ask themselves why they reside with a certain identity?]]> 2023-10-11 22:57:05 UTC https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742546928 https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742547200 Citizenship to me is about being a member of a community or place. My conception of community/place includes the biotic and abiotic members of a space at various scales (local, regional, continental). Although I had not read Kimmerer's definition prior to today, I can appreciate their loyalty to the nature or natural law. Good citizens, in my opinion, take care of shared resources as to prevent a "Tragedy of the Commons". The only planet that we have inhibited to this point is planet Earth. I think this idea is consistent with Kimmerer's conceptualization of citizenship. I admire the bold stance Kimmerer takes. I wonder what level of deconstruction it would take for the tenets behind Kimmerer's citizenship to be adopted by others. How could others be more in tune with the natural world? ]]> 2023-10-11 22:57:26 UTC https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742547200 https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742549247 To me, citizenship means to be loyal to a country and follow its laws which are beneficial for everyone. It is not only bound to citizen, but much more from the other side as well, whether that citizen is getting the basic amenities or not. A good citizen is the one who tries to keep a balance and try to follow the rules set up for that country. It follows Kimmerer's conception of citizenship.]]> 2023-10-11 23:00:36 UTC https://padlet.com/morganptate/indigenousknowledgequal8400/wish/2742549247