https://padlet.com/ee20a2s2/ayenskifzbi2l3ie en-us 2021-06-24 13:23:15 UTC 2025-11-12 10:53:49 UTC hello@padlet.com ee20a2s2 https://padlet.com/ee20a2s2/ayenskifzbi2l3ie/wish/1623582280 'a city where you don't need a car'
Language of 'cars' in the vision is central
It's a 'negative' vision
A vision of 'not having', not where you wanna go
People like cars - this sounds daunting
Vision discusses the process rather than the outcome
A reduced car dependant city is the aim and the vision statement aims to be neutral on its attitude to cars in order to minimise objection but isn't a truly positive vision

]]> 2021-06-24 13:27:43 UTC https://padlet.com/ee20a2s2/ayenskifzbi2l3ie/wish/1623582280 ee20car1 https://padlet.com/ee20a2s2/ayenskifzbi2l3ie/wish/1623585427 2021-06-24 13:29:35 UTC https://padlet.com/ee20a2s2/ayenskifzbi2l3ie/wish/1623585427 ee20a2s2 https://padlet.com/ee20a2s2/ayenskifzbi2l3ie/wish/1623593669 Large focus on CO2 emissions reduction and not on other aspects of environmental sustainability
No discussion of habitat fragmentation
Implicit reliance on cars and a transition to zero-emissions vehicle which reduces NOx, & CO2 pollution but leaves particulate matter from brakes, tyres, & road wear out
No consideration of resource cost of EV transition]]> 2021-06-24 13:33:06 UTC https://padlet.com/ee20a2s2/ayenskifzbi2l3ie/wish/1623593669 ee20a2s2 https://padlet.com/ee20a2s2/ayenskifzbi2l3ie/wish/1623598623 'Inclusive growth' - promotes a particular view of the economy; frame of reference is growth rather than sustainability - it assumes that with growth comes sustainability, rather than it being the focal point

]]> 2021-06-24 13:36:05 UTC https://padlet.com/ee20a2s2/ayenskifzbi2l3ie/wish/1623598623 ee20emb2 https://padlet.com/ee20a2s2/ayenskifzbi2l3ie/wish/1623603098 - Socially- lots of mention of broad trends and targets, but not much talk about the distribution/ which groups will benefit.

Fair
moving away from cars implicit, trying to give people equal opportunity in transport without need for expensive car travel
Reducing emissions and pollution which disproportionately effects marginalised groups

Unfair
'inclusive' elements are exclusive to certain groups e.g. assumption of choice around 'car use'; HS2]]> 2021-06-24 13:38:43 UTC https://padlet.com/ee20a2s2/ayenskifzbi2l3ie/wish/1623603098 ee20a2s2 https://padlet.com/ee20a2s2/ayenskifzbi2l3ie/wish/1623617547 Climate Change (environmental)
Emissions focused - what about other planetary boundaries? nature, biodiversity loss, ozone layer depletion etc.

Inclusive Growth (economic)
Direct conflict with other two objectives? assumptions of growth = sustainability, a particular view of what society 'values' 

Health & Wellbeing (social)
integration with other services is lacking, assumes a level of personal choice]]> 2021-06-24 13:46:53 UTC https://padlet.com/ee20a2s2/ayenskifzbi2l3ie/wish/1623617547 ee20a2s2 https://padlet.com/ee20a2s2/ayenskifzbi2l3ie/wish/1623625020 Climate change is everything - no mention of ecological emergency, biodiversity

Equality and social justice, distribution is not featured

Connecting with other city systems is lacking - employment, housing, nature]]> 2021-06-24 13:51:02 UTC https://padlet.com/ee20a2s2/ayenskifzbi2l3ie/wish/1623625020