<?xml version="1.0"?>
<rss version="2.0">
   <channel>
      <title>What counts as collective memory?
How do collective memories differ from personal memories when recounting a historical event?
Whose memory do you think is more reliable, and why?
 by Sana Abou Ali (ACS Beirut)</title>
      <link>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz</link>
      <description>Post your response to the discussion topic by clicking the plus button below.</description>
      <language>en-us</language>
      <pubDate>2025-01-10 05:25:50 UTC</pubDate>
      <lastBuildDate>2025-01-10 07:03:33 UTC</lastBuildDate>
      <webMaster>hello@padlet.com</webMaster>
      
      <item>
         <title></title>
         <author></author>
         <link>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286211477</link>
         <description><![CDATA[<p>Collective memory is the shared  knowledge, experiences, or cultural narratives that a group of people have. It is often passed down through generations. It shapes a group's identity and can include historical events, traditions, rituals, and symbols that hold significance for the group of people. </p>]]></description>
         <enclosure url="" />
         <pubDate>2025-01-10 06:20:20 UTC</pubDate>
         <guid>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286211477</guid>
      </item>
      <item>
         <title></title>
         <author></author>
         <link>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286213321</link>
         <description><![CDATA[<p>I believe a collective memory is a significant event or series of events that impacted a community to the point where it became ingrained in their memory, as a collective, as opposed to the unreliable nature of a singular person's memory. A prominent example I can think of are the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombings in Japan at the end of the second world war, where millions of lives were impacted as a result of a traumatic event, and thus naturally leaving a scar in those who witnessed it.</p>]]></description>
         <enclosure url="" />
         <pubDate>2025-01-10 06:22:49 UTC</pubDate>
         <guid>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286213321</guid>
      </item>
      <item>
         <title></title>
         <author></author>
         <link>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286214053</link>
         <description><![CDATA[<ol><li><p>Collective memory is the shared recollection of certain events within a group or society. These memories are beyond personal experiences; they could refer to rituals, cultural norms, and literature. </p></li></ol>]]></description>
         <enclosure url="" />
         <pubDate>2025-01-10 06:23:55 UTC</pubDate>
         <guid>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286214053</guid>
      </item>
      <item>
         <title></title>
         <author></author>
         <link>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286214255</link>
         <description><![CDATA[<p>collective memory is a memory that is shared between a group of people. if someone lived through an event they would remember the details and if they weren't alive during it they would be taught about it. It is the shared pool of experiences. </p>]]></description>
         <enclosure url="" />
         <pubDate>2025-01-10 06:24:19 UTC</pubDate>
         <guid>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286214255</guid>
      </item>
      <item>
         <title></title>
         <author></author>
         <link>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286214665</link>
         <description><![CDATA[<p>Collective memories are shared narratives that people of a certain group have. They create a unified understanding of a historical event. However, personal memories are subjective and based on individual experiences. Personal memories may vary from one person to another, and capture unique details, whereas collective memories are more general. </p>]]></description>
         <enclosure url="" />
         <pubDate>2025-01-10 06:24:53 UTC</pubDate>
         <guid>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286214665</guid>
      </item>
      <item>
         <title></title>
         <author></author>
         <link>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286215829</link>
         <description><![CDATA[<ol start="2"><li><p>Personal memories are individual experiences not necessarily shared with a group and can be shaped by emotions. Personal memory can also be subjective since it is based on an individual's experience and is through their eyes.</p></li></ol>]]></description>
         <enclosure url="" />
         <pubDate>2025-01-10 06:26:24 UTC</pubDate>
         <guid>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286215829</guid>
      </item>
      <item>
         <title></title>
         <author></author>
         <link>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286216748</link>
         <description><![CDATA[<p>usually, collective memories have more details as there will be more people recalling the events and it will be less subject to emotional interference that personal memories are subjected to.</p>]]></description>
         <enclosure url="" />
         <pubDate>2025-01-10 06:27:50 UTC</pubDate>
         <guid>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286216748</guid>
      </item>
      <item>
         <title></title>
         <author></author>
         <link>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286217373</link>
         <description><![CDATA[<ol start="3"><li><p>Both personal and collective memory can be influenced by certain biases and motivations. However, collective memory would be more reliable because it involves multiple perspectives and historical records rather than a single, subjective viewpoint.</p></li></ol>]]></description>
         <enclosure url="" />
         <pubDate>2025-01-10 06:28:55 UTC</pubDate>
         <guid>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286217373</guid>
      </item>
      <item>
         <title></title>
         <author></author>
         <link>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286217599</link>
         <description><![CDATA[<ol><li><p>Collective memories are those that a collective group experiences, often defining and shaping social groups. Tragedies like the 9/11 attacks or the Lebanese port explosion are definition memories ingrained in people's memories.     2.  Personal memories are based on the accounts of a single person. We only have one perspective on a certain event.   3.  Due to the reconstructive nature of memory, memory is often considered unreliable, shaped by later narratives, and distorted to fit schemas. I would say that both personal and historical memories are just as unreliable. "Just as individuals can misremember personal events, nations and communities can collectively misinterpret historical facts, sometimes as a result of deliberate manipulation by those in power." </p></li></ol>]]></description>
         <enclosure url="" />
         <pubDate>2025-01-10 06:29:22 UTC</pubDate>
         <guid>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286217599</guid>
      </item>
      <item>
         <title></title>
         <author></author>
         <link>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286218586</link>
         <description><![CDATA[<p>Collective memories are more reliable because they are based on multiple perspectives. Personal memories can be influenced by emotion or bias, making them not as reliable. Since collective memories are based on dialogue, documentation, and shared narratives, they help us better understand certain historical events.</p>]]></description>
         <enclosure url="" />
         <pubDate>2025-01-10 06:31:01 UTC</pubDate>
         <guid>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286218586</guid>
      </item>
      <item>
         <title></title>
         <author></author>
         <link>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286219165</link>
         <description><![CDATA[<p>A collective memory is a shared area of knowledge by a group of people. These specific people have experienced the same experience or event, making it a shared memory among them. </p><p>The collective memories are usually shaped by societal narratives and traditions, and the personal memories are mostly based on emotions and opinions, as bias can take place. </p><p>While personal memories can be reliable at times, I think that a collective memory is more reliable in comparison to a personal memory. This is because a collective memory is shared by many people, thus adding more certainty to the events of the  memory. It includes more perspectives, and witnesses. </p>]]></description>
         <enclosure url="" />
         <pubDate>2025-01-10 06:32:04 UTC</pubDate>
         <guid>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286219165</guid>
      </item>
      <item>
         <title></title>
         <author></author>
         <link>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286219805</link>
         <description><![CDATA[<p>In most cases, collective memories are more reliable as with more people witnessing the event there will be more details about the event. even if someone doesn't remember the events correctly they will be giving out a different event recollection than other people, which will lead to an easy pick out from the masses.</p>]]></description>
         <enclosure url="" />
         <pubDate>2025-01-10 06:33:10 UTC</pubDate>
         <guid>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286219805</guid>
      </item>
      <item>
         <title></title>
         <author></author>
         <link>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286220794</link>
         <description><![CDATA[<ol><li><p>Collective memory is the memory of a group of people that has been passed down through generations. It can include culture, hardships, experiences, and traditions. </p></li><li><p>Personal memories are events that a single person experiences. They are influenced by the person's emotions, values, and immediate context at the time. On the other hand, collective memories offer a shared narrative that reflects the values and identity of a group of people. </p></li><li><p>I think both are unreliable. However, looking at the context of the memory and its purpose is important .  personal memories can be influenced by the personal personality and emotional being, while a group of people may have a more general saying on the memory, so it depends on what the memory is and what it represents. </p></li></ol>]]></description>
         <enclosure url="" />
         <pubDate>2025-01-10 06:34:47 UTC</pubDate>
         <guid>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286220794</guid>
      </item>
      <item>
         <title></title>
         <author></author>
         <link>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286242140</link>
         <description><![CDATA[<ol><li><p>Collective memory often refers to the shared pool of knowledge and information about past events within a group of individuals on the basis of shared experiences, cultural narratives, and societal values. Collective memory is constructed through multiple perspectives, cultural narratives, and traditions rather than individual recollections, where the event or memory is established as a shared narrative within a community and aligns with the group's cultural values, shaping its identity. </p></li><li><p>Personal memories refer to the individual's direct account of an event, which is influenced by bias, emotions, and the context of history. Nevertheless, collective memories are derived from the corroboration of multiple perspectives. These perspectives form a pool of knowledge established within a community that does not reflect each individual's recollection but creates a broader "picture" of an event that reflects the values and cultural significance of the group. </p></li><li><p>Both forms of memory are prone to  bias and subjectivity. Understanding memory as a direct account of an event may be considered unreliable due to its reconstructive nature. In this context, collective memories are deemed more reliable because they acquire an established account of an experience that is shared and created among multiple perspectives within a community. This somewhat limits the bias and emotional leniencies associated with individual recollection and memory. </p></li></ol>]]></description>
         <enclosure url="" />
         <pubDate>2025-01-10 07:03:32 UTC</pubDate>
         <guid>https://padlet.com/sabouali/aqgjkn7ly71vsgtz/wish/3286242140</guid>
      </item>
   </channel>
</rss>
