Jersalem 1850 by

Gabe Ruskin

gruskin — 2014-05-22 20:11:36 UTC

In my opinion they should have stayed. Since no matter what things could not have gotten worse. They also saw how much of a good man Moshe was. Like when he made apartments for the Jew. Or when he made a windmill. I would have trusted him. In the old city they might have run out of water. Outside they might have a better chance with living even if they got robbed.

Josh

jsaltsman — 2014-05-22 20:12:16 UTC

I think the Jews should go because there is more space and there is no diseases so people should not be scared. I think the Arab Bandits will not attack the apartments. In case of attack the Jews can go back.

Judah

jalmo — 2014-05-22 20:13:36 UTC

I think that they should stay because it is a holy place and the Jews have been looking for a place to live 1,000 of years. I think that the Jews should make an army.

Emma

eyagolnitser — 2014-05-22 20:13:51 UTC

I think that the Jews should have gone with Moshe he is great and they should trust him and the land that he has is better sure the land that they have is more holy but sometimes you have to change and sometimes change can be for the better so maybe it that change would have been better for them. But maybe sometimes home is to important for you and you have to stay so maybe they have too much to just let it all go

lulu

mmaimon — 2014-05-22 20:14:04 UTC

I think they should move because lots of people would be brave to go and do it. Lots of people would get killed but not all of them and we would get freedom and get more space and we could live in our own space.

Sam

samuelmholland — 2014-05-22 20:14:49 UTC

I think the Jews should go because they would have more space and they might be a

little less scared.

Jakey Assouline

sha5jakey — 2014-05-22 20:15:00 UTC

What I think is that they should stay. I think this because, They should not have to leave a place were they belonged. I also think that since they should have stayed they should have had made a force to PROTECT and not attack different places because then they would have gotten week.

http://youtu.be/cuq3HyTvFeo

Shoshana

shbehar — 2014-05-22 20:15:26 UTC

I think we should have stayed because 1^st of all it would have been hard to move everything and 2^nd of all they could face a lot of dangers if they left but also if they stayed. But if we stayed I think would be less there danger. Lastly, If you were them would you want to be in more danger then you’re already in? I know I would just stay to maybe be in less danger.

Avi

sha5avikintzer — 2014-05-22 20:15:41 UTC

I think the Jews should have gone outside the walls even though they could have been attacked their still would be were other Jews there so they could have backup. If they stayed inside the walls they could have all got disease and died so I think they should have left the walls.

Beloria Levy

sha5beloria — 2014-05-22 20:19:37 UTC

I would not want to stay because if I did that I would be cramped, I would get diseases and more bad things. Also if I had a choice I would go where there is more space, where I would not get sicknesses but I would not want to go away from the kotell.

Binyamin

2014-05-22 20:19:57 UTC

I think that the Jews should go out of the Old City to the New City. The reason that I think this is that even though there might be bad things in the New City, there were also bad things in the Old City. Another thing is that if the Jews don’t move to the New City, then they would be cramped together not like in the New City since there would be more room. If I lived in Israel I would try to move.

Shimon

ssgamel — 2014-05-22 20:20:22 UTC

Jerusalem: Beyond the Walls

I think Israel should have expanded the walls of the old city

i. I’m pretty sure they don’t want to live in a city full of garbage.

ii. Do you want to live in a house with 4 families that’s crumbly?

iii. Would you want to live in a city where you haft to collect water when it rains?

I think they should go. I think they should go because They need to expand to make the city bigger. They are also so cramped that they should have there OWN place to stay, and not be stuffed into the same place. There obviously is some dangers about it, like people that disagree with it. Especially like MLK he wanted to expand the places that black people went but he got shot, but on the bright side he got what he wanted J. So its like Israel but very different.

kbalkany — 2014-05-22 20:22:54 UTC

-Kaden :-)

kebira

2014-05-22 20:23:04 UTC

I would move out because you can’t always be scared of the dangers around you. You have to face you fears. Or expand the walls in the old city.

yaniv

ynv1002 — 2014-05-27 20:52:39 UTC

I think that they should go because Moses was pretty sure that we should go. He thought that we should go because he built buildings