LR Outline T/Th by Daniel McCarthy

LR Outline T/Th by Daniel McCarthy https://padlet.com/daniel_j_mccarthy91/8ugl46vgcmci en-us 2019-10-03 15:23:39 UTC 2019-10-03 16:37:07 UTC hello@padlet.com Group 5 daniel_j_mccarthy91 https://padlet.com/daniel_j_mccarthy91/8ugl46vgcmci/wish/393085251 1. Self-citation is very frequent in academic writing. 1) Snyder and Bonzi (1989); 7) Falagas and Kavvadia (2006); even for scholars of high reputation 3) Phelan (1999)

2. there is concern of credibility for the effects of self-citation. some say that they are supporting

Fowler and Aksnes (2007) ;
some think it is not significant 6. Medoff (2006)

3. how the motivation of self-citation differs against normal types of citations is also debated
2) Bonzi and Snyder (1991)
4) White (2001)
5) Hyland (2003)

]]> 2019-10-03 15:24:05 UTC https://padlet.com/daniel_j_mccarthy91/8ugl46vgcmci/wish/393085251 Group 3 daniel_j_mccarthy91 https://padlet.com/daniel_j_mccarthy91/8ugl46vgcmci/wish/393085354 Paragraph 1 - Phenomenon of self-citations:

a. Fowler and Aksnes (2007);

b. Snyder and Bonzi (1989);

c. Falagas and Kavvadia (2006);

d. Phelan (1999)

Paragraph 2 - Evaluation:

a. Fowler and Aksnes (2007);

b. Medoff (2006)

Paragraph 3 - Motivation of self-citations:

a. Hyland (2003);

b. White (2001);

c. Bonzi and Snyder (1991)

]]> 2019-10-03 15:24:12 UTC https://padlet.com/daniel_j_mccarthy91/8ugl46vgcmci/wish/393085354 Group 2 daniel_j_mccarthy91 https://padlet.com/daniel_j_mccarthy91/8ugl46vgcmci/wish/393085389

1) The frequency of self-citation in various academic fields

1. Snyder and Bonzi (1989)

7. Falagas and Kavvadia (2006)

2)The reasons why self-citations are commonplace in academic writing

2. Bonzi and Snyder (1991)

4. White (2001)
5. Hyland (2003)

3)The correlation between self-citation and total citation by others

3. Phelan (1999)
6. Medoff (2006)

8. Fowler and Aksnes (2007)

]]> 2019-10-03 15:24:16 UTC https://padlet.com/daniel_j_mccarthy91/8ugl46vgcmci/wish/393085389 Group 1 daniel_j_mccarthy91 https://padlet.com/daniel_j_mccarthy91/8ugl46vgcmci/wish/393085449 1.Evidence and Patterns of self-citation in different disciplines(description)

Citation: Snyder and Bonzi (1989), Phelan (1999), Falagas and Kavvadia (2006), Fowler and Aksnes (2007)

2. whether self-citations should “count” in evaluations:

a. Supporter: they should “count” in evaluations.

Citation: Medoff (2006), White (2001)

b. Opponent: they should not “count” in evaluations.

Citation: Fowler and Aksnes (2007)

3. whether the motives for self-citing are somehow different from those of citing others.

a. Indifferent: Bonzi and Snyder (1991), White (2001)

b. Different: Hyland (2003)

]]> 2019-10-03 15:24:18 UTC https://padlet.com/daniel_j_mccarthy91/8ugl46vgcmci/wish/393085449 Group 4 daniel_j_mccarthy91 https://padlet.com/daniel_j_mccarthy91/8ugl46vgcmci/wish/393124623 I. General characteristics of self-citations in different fields

a. Snyder & Bonzi (1989)

b. Phelan (1999)

c. Fowler & Aksnes (2007)

d. Falagas & Kavvadia (2006)

II. Motivations for self-citations

a. Bonzi & Snyder (1991)

b. White (2001)

c. Hyland (2003)

III. Effects of self-citations on the academia

a. Medoff (2006)

b. Fowler and Aksmes (2007)

]]> 2019-10-03 16:17:17 UTC https://padlet.com/daniel_j_mccarthy91/8ugl46vgcmci/wish/393124623