https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09 Please choose 1 member to begin the Padlet Note then type your NAMES first then your response. MUST BE COMPLETED BEFORE THE END OF THE PERIOD. NO QUOTE/NECESSARY--just group consensus (agreement) on response. NO QUOTE/NECESSARY. **QUESTION** The director of the film version of the book chooses NOT to include the scene of Sohrab's attempted suicide. Is this a good choice? Why or why not? Defend your answer. At least 3-5 complete sentences. en-us 2020-12-09 12:08:27 UTC 2026-01-13 18:42:27 UTC hello@padlet.com thorped2021 https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002273880 I think it was a good choice for the director not to add it because it might be graphic to watch someone try to attempt suicide in general it pretty graphic but caleb said wasnt that the whole purpose of the movie cause most people that have watched the movie have read the book we would assume.]]> 2020-12-09 14:32:39 UTC https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002273880 walkerh2021 https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002275118 I think it's a good choice because, there's been enough violence towards kids in the book. Ending it off with not showing Sohrab suicide attempt in the movie would be better for the audience. Also, we don't fully understand why he did it so showing it wouldn't be dramatic. ]]> 2020-12-09 14:32:53 UTC https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002275118 https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002279948 The scene should've been put into the movie. It leaves out a big detail in the story. That is a big piece of emotion missing and a part of character development is missed.]]> 2020-12-09 14:33:49 UTC https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002279948 https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002284106 The director shouldn't include the scene of sohrab attempting suicide, because the scene is too graphic to show in the form of a movie. Adding this scene would make it harder to reach a happy ending without it feeling depressing.]]> 2020-12-09 14:34:41 UTC https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002284106 https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002284753 I think that the film version didn't put the suicide part because I think they didn't think it was a big part in the story and how some people would look at it and they know some people in real life go through somethings like that.
I believe they should have put it in the movie because we could see how the person really feel. Also know that if a person have been through all he has gone through then they would have some type of way of showing it. Also I believe it's a big part of the story and we can see why they did it and we can know to watch that person.]]> 2020-12-09 14:34:49 UTC https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002284753 https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002284943 It is a good choice because it could of been a big trigger to a lot of people especially since hes a kid attempting suicide.]]> 2020-12-09 14:34:52 UTC https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002284943 https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002287958 because first thats a hard graphic to even think about. Because many people in real life hgas attemped sucide before, So it was prolly wouldve been to much to look at]]> 2020-12-09 14:35:30 UTC https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002287958 https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002297751 I think the director of the film version does not include the attempted suicide scene because it s too graphic. When it comes to films and movies things like that can change the rating of it and that can effect sales. Another reason I think the Director does not include the scene is because of its little importance. The scheme plays a role in the plot but maybe its not large enough to show when in a movie you have so much to show in not a large time frame.]]> 2020-12-09 14:37:26 UTC https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002297751 https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002300157 I think this is a good choice because the attempted suicide would have been really gruesome and graphic. Also I feel like it would have also been cool to just have the character say how he tried to kill himself or show the scars after he tried to do that to himself. I think he did good not putting in his attempted suicide ]]> 2020-12-09 14:37:55 UTC https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002300157 https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002309784 The movie director left out the suicide because that is extremely graphic for the audience to view. Especially a child attempting suicide. It may serve as a trigger to some who have attempted suicide and that is just a negative reaction that no one wishes upon another. Reading an attempted suicide and watching one are two extremely different different sensory experiences. It’s harder for the audience to visualize that scene from just a description but when it is viewable that is just something an audience couldn’t handle. It’s to graphic.]]> 2020-12-09 14:39:53 UTC https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002309784 https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002320528 Hosseini included the suicidal scene in the book to really dramatize it and show to what extent Sohrab was suffering. Even after everything Amir and Hassan went through they never considered anything like suicide as children. Hosseini wanted to show how negatively  effected this new generation of Afghans is. They’ve been victims of the loss of loved ones and witnesses to war, so in a sense, these kids are traumatized.]]> 2020-12-09 14:42:13 UTC https://padlet.com/smustafah/7n4ardir3oaxrx09/wish/1002320528