2.Think about who took the cookies and why they would do it.

    - Everyone had their own plausible alibis. But Mina found out who ate the cookies. It was… 

4. Confirm and write the reason for each person in groups.

2. Share your diary and give comments to each other.

3. Edit it with the comments. 

Mina’s sister ate cookies because  (                                                     ).

                                  vs.

Mina’s sister didn’t eat cookies because  ( she doesn't like sweet things                                                     ).

Mina’s dad ate cookies because (                         ).
                                  vs.

Mina’s dad didn’t eat cookies because (    he needed to be hurry. He went fishing.                                                ).

 [Suspect  2. mom ]  

Mina’s mom ate cookies because  ( she wanted to eat a lot before she goes to the dentist                                                     ).

                                  vs.

Mina’s mom didn’t eat cookies because  (                                       ).

Mina’s brother ate cookies because  (                                                       ).

                                 vs.  

Mina’s brother didn’t eat cookies because  ( he is on a diet                                                       ).

Yesterday I got a cookie jar for my birthday gift.

Name :         / Comments:

Yesterday I got a cookie jar for my birthday gift. It was so precious so I didn't eat at that moment. This morning I wanted to eat my cookies. But! Tada~ There were no cookies. Who took the cookies from the cookie jar??? I began to doubt my family.
Dad, mom, sister, and brother. "Did you take my cookies??" Everyone made their excuses and said, "No, I didn't!"
Dad went fishing so he was in hurry. Mom went to the dentist so she can't eat anything. My sister doesn't like sweeties so no. My brother was on a diet so he's not! Then who??? Who took my cookies!!!!!?????
Soon my mom hugged me and said she ate all cookies. Before she went to the dentist, she needed a little present for herself. I understand her because the dentist is the scariest place in the world! 
Mom gave me a bigger cookie jar this evening.
I'm very happy!!!!

Name :         / Comments:

I'm sure she is the one. She was brushing her teeth carefully after lunch.  She insisted on the dental reservation on this afternoon. 
I know her, she seems like to be an elegant and polite lady, But she loves the cookies, she never succeeded She never succeeded in resisting the temptation of cookies, especially. 

I don't know which one to choose between her favorite cookie or the best dentist, but I've seen pieces that look like cookie crumbs on my mom's dressing table. Also she was looking out of her window when I entered her room and she suddenly turned her body.
Actually when I found the cookie jar, I thought it was a gift for my mom, not my birthday present. Because it was her favorite taste so much.

Name :         / Comments:

Yesterday I got a cookie jar for my birthday gift but I found that everything was gone. I was so sad I wanted to know who ate my cookies! 
First, I think dad didn't eat cookies because he was busy to go fishing with his friends. He didn't have enough time to take my cookies. 
Second, my sister didn't eat cookies, either because she is not a big fan of cookies. She likes spicy and salty food not sweet things like cookies. 
Third, my brother didn't eat cookies because he is on a diet these days. He only eats salad every day. 
Then the only one left is my mom. Did my mom really eat my cookies? I don't want believe this but I am sure she did it because she really likes cookies and it was the last chance for her to eat cookies before she went to the dentist. 
I am so sad that my mom took my precious cookies. I hope my mom never takes my snack any more. 

Name :         / Comments: