Identifying Transformative Narratives in Cluster 3 (Tourism/migration) by

Identifying Transformative Narratives in Cluster 3 (Tourism/migration) by https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3 T+ 2nd Integration Workshop (4/4) BoG3 en-us 2021-06-22 08:47:19 UTC 2021-06-22 15:25:54 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet-uploads.storage.googleapis.com/1157448439/56af27d0159b00b17d21cfd2c7270884/image_T_.webp What synergies were identified between CS and WPs? GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3/wish/1619312574 -national and local government as main actors. Top-down approach (GR, IT, MX), whereas in RO the top-down vision is lacking
-selfish principles as a reason for opposition
-some narratives have emerged as counter-narratives
-tourism in Balearic Islands and RO is important, forseen by IT and GR .
-are the policies accepted by the citizens?
-distrust is common
-we have similar approaches: top-down
in RO is more bottom-up self-organization--> changing the rethoric

]]> 2021-06-22 08:47:19 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3/wish/1619312574 Bosnia GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3/wish/1619312575 ^{What region types did you identify?}^{- Mainstream: Many projects coal+biomass
-solar-thermal.
- International investments -Tuzla 7-coal power plant originally funded by Chinese investments, may be withdrawn.
- Formal 5 hydropowerplants in 5 regions, region defined by the powerplant
- search for regions with bigger potential for hydropower plants
- places where the goverment invested
- Perception has changed since the 1980 where the focus was not on the ecological but the economical dimension. Today people also adress climate change}
^{What region type(s) do you find more relevant for your case study and why?}^{- In the case studies the political narratives are analysed hence focus on perceptual}^{Who is/are describing the region?}^-^{Are these region types aligned with the mainstream narratives?}^-]]> 2021-06-22 08:47:19 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3/wish/1619312575 Any other points (remarkable insights; problems; other questions; etc.) https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3/wish/1619312576 -what is the direction/can we imagine a SETP that would intervence
-What is the role of expectations?
identify: relationship with tourists. how do outsiders look at the locals? the locals want to be seen as green, for the future, to fulfill external expectations, instead of pursuing local goals.
--are the policies accepted by the citizens? are the citizens supporting the tourism branding? how to make ligitimate policies? -do citizens trust policies? (not in GR)
-local capacity?

]]> 2021-06-22 08:47:19 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3/wish/1619312576 Spain 1 (Balearic Islands) GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3/wish/1619312577 info coming from sth interviews/workshops
Main transformative narrative is to reach 100% RE by 2050 and ban ICE cars by 2030

At what stage (e.g. peak or decline of the mainstream narrative, or emergence of an alternative narrative, etc.) is your CS now?
- decline of transformative narrative due to lack of implementation/results and rise of local conflicts/protests
-
What transformative capacities do you see?
- Right policies in place: Balearic climate and energy policy approved in 2019
- missing capacity: poor land-use planning
- financial capacity is provided by private sector (energy utility)
How consensual (among the stakeholders) are these transformative narrative(s)?
- local NGOs protests (visual impact vs land use)
- national and regional government supports the agenda
- local government lacks technical capacity and political interest
Can you foresee SETPs in your CS?

- Balearic climate and energy law approved in 2019: ban of ICE cars by 2030 and 100% RE by 2050
challenges:
-lack of political/technical capacities to create land-use planning. to see where they can use the land for food production, tourism, etc.
-government does not have the (political, technical, financial) capacity

-financially tourism makes sense, but covid has changed it.

]]> 2021-06-22 08:47:19 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3/wish/1619312577 Italy 1 (Sulcis) GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3/wish/1619312578 At what stage (e.g. peak or decline of the mainstream narrative, or emergence of an alternative narrative, etc.) is your CS now?
-
-
-
What transformative capacities do you see?
-
-
-
How consensual (among the stakeholders) are these transformative narrative(s)?
-
-
-
Can you foresee SETPs in your CS?

-
-
-

]]> 2021-06-22 08:47:19 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3/wish/1619312578 Greece GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3/wish/1619312579 At what stage (e.g. peak or decline of the mainstream narrative, or emergence of an alternative narrative, etc.) is your CS now?
- alternative narrative the hot topic: off-stream, closure
--PV installations happening now
-agricultural production --> economic diversity? hydroponics
What transformative capacities do you see?
- explode infrastructure,
-green energy sector
-mountains, water resources could be exploded for RES energy projects
-high solar potential
-promote projects that include young generations for just transitions
How consensual (among the stakeholders) are these transformative narrative(s)?
-transition is supported by diverse groups: environmental, economic groups
- survey: serve the interests of NG companies (37%)
-it is European plan (25%)
Can you foresee SETPs in your CS?

-/
-
many people think that the transition is promoted by NG companies/interests--> distrust; however, most people agree with the transition.

]]> 2021-06-22 08:47:19 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3/wish/1619312579 Romania (Jiu Valley) GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3/wish/1619312581 At what stage (e.g. peak or decline of the mainstream narrative, or emergence of an alternative narrative, etc.) is your CS now?
-before 1998, the industry was subsidized. After that, the mining sector does not have a future.
-
-
What transformative capacities do you see?
-tourism, RET for the whole country, GDP/capita increase in Romania. The economy at the national level is doing good
-
-
How consensual (among the stakeholders) are these transformative narrative(s)?
-transotioon should be better organized
-government not capable of being the major actor of the transition?
-each municipality is on its onw, no collective action. --> hard to coordinate capacities
-the mainstrem narra. is still present
Can you foresee SETPs in your CS?

-the moment when the power unions was washed away and the mining sector started to decline
-tourism can become significant if there are investors. Mines could attract tourists.
-

Challenge:
-out-migration is part of the problem (decline of the sector?)
-

]]> 2021-06-22 08:47:19 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3/wish/1619312581 Mexico gcf_marcel https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3/wish/1619718261 At what stage (e.g. peak or decline of the mainstream narrative, or emergence of an alternative narrative, etc.) is your CS now?
- mainstream: fossil fuels on the rise again due to investments
- private sectors tends more to renewables
-
What transformative capacities do you see?
- small scale local needs as driving force, support for many communities
-
-
How consensual (among the stakeholders) are these transformative narrative(s)?
- alternative narrative is still a minority
- Government bodies have not yet taken part in a energy transition road map
-
Can you foresee SETPs in your CS?

-
-
-

]]> 2021-06-22 14:01:34 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/TransformativeNarrativesC3/wish/1619718261