Personal Project- Defining Command Terms for Success Criteria by Brent Puglisi https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w Basic, Appropriate, Appropriate AND Detailed en-us 2021-08-11 17:43:54 UTC 2023-09-19 12:44:44 UTC hello@padlet.com State and Present brentpuglisi1 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1675796533 STATE and PRESENT are command terms defined in our new assessment criteria as:

State:
Give a specific name, value or other brief answer without explanation or calculation.

Present:
To offer for display, observation, examination or consideration.
']]> 2021-08-11 17:48:22 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1675796533 Basic, Appropriate, Detailed brentpuglisi1 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1675807395 All command terms seem not to be created equal. These three are the differences in grade band but are not specifically defined like the others.

Here is how our new assessment criteria delineates the grade bands for student success criteria:

1-2  states their intended product

3-4  states their intended product and presents basic success criteria for the product

5-6  states their intended product and presents multiple appropriate success criteria for the product

7-8  states their intended product and presents multiple appropriate, detailed success criteria for the product



]]> 2021-08-11 17:58:21 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1675807395 Success Criteria brentpuglisi1 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1675813111 The Question:
How are we to guide the students in creating unique and rigorous success criteria that can be used to evaluate their projects?

The Problem:

The command terms-Basic(3-4), Appropriate(5-6), Detailed(7-8)- are used in the grading criteria(A: ii) to guide us in assigning grades yet they are not clearly defined.

The Task: 
  1. Read the info in this column below.
  2. Discuss with your group how you would define or explain each command term. 
    1. What is it that each word is trying to define in terms of the students success criteria?
  3. Add a post under each term summarizing your groups thoughts.(in the columns to the right)
    1. Bonus pints if you include examples.

]]> 2021-08-11 18:03:41 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1675813111 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770704219 Simple explanation of the task. Description of what you are doing but not with a lot of details. One criteria given. ]]> 2021-09-27 10:47:04 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770704219 Group 7: Listing the physical outcomes and/or specification but not clearly connected to research. elizaritt https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770707510 Ex: Student describes in several bullet points how they want their handbag to look with some physical details. The success criteria lacks research/rational to back up why that would be good a choice. ]]> 2021-09-27 10:48:47 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770707510 Group 2 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770710265 * All criteria are highly relevant
* Reflecting research
* Clearly explained/defined ]]> 2021-09-27 10:50:30 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770710265 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770711432 Multiple appropriate criteria, but not very detailed. A few aspects being considered. ]]> 2021-09-27 10:51:18 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770711432 Minimal form and function for the success of the product. https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770713083 2021-09-27 10:52:22 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770713083 Group 7: Success Criteria Research Based elizaritt https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770716639 The research informs the desired outcome of the product. The reasoning is lacking. 

Ex: An animal themed handbag is desired by many people according to Australian Consumer Reports. ]]> 2021-09-27 10:54:40 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770716639 Group 5 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770717781 Criteria are both relevant and specific to the product 
The criteria is explicitly informed by the research conducted

Example
'Use of complementary colours while also considering value in the composition and perspective ]]> 2021-09-27 10:55:25 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770717781 Group 5 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770717955 States more than one relevant criteria. 
Most of the criteria are clearly connected to research 

Example

'Use of complementary colours']]> 2021-09-27 10:55:32 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770717955 Group 5 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770718027 Some criteria are not relevant to the product. 
Criteria is loosely or inconsistently connected to research



Example

'Pleasing colours']]> 2021-09-27 10:55:35 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770718027 Group 2 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770721571 * Some but not all criteria relevant
* Some connection to research
* Criteria are stated but not clearly defined. (Some explanation)]]> 2021-09-27 10:56:52 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770721571 How many criteria can be considered as "multiple"? https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770722462 2021-09-27 10:57:22 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770722462 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770723600 - See the wider importance of a particular criteria when thinking about the success of the product. 
- Give an example to the students where you show the different "levels" of criteria. ]]> 2021-09-27 10:58:09 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770723600 Group 1: https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770724175 Specific criteria, with sub-strand descriptors, derived from high quality relevant research.


]]> 2021-09-27 10:58:30 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770724175 Group 2 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770726654 * Some, but not most criteria are relevant. 
* Minimal or no research
* Stated but not defined]]> 2021-09-27 10:59:57 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770726654 Group 7: Research Relevance Explained elizaritt https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770726816 The research, which can take many forms, is logically explained. Student makes clear how the research informs the criteria that they have developed and why it makes sense within the context of their product. 

Ex: A student explains that their Australian armadillo design bag, is a relevant criteria for their project because...(you get the idea). ]]> 2021-09-27 11:00:03 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770726816 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770729634 A range of relevant and concise criteria with details of form, function and design specifications of a successful product. ]]> 2021-09-27 11:01:43 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770729634 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770732862 Find a successful product similar to yours. Compare and investigate why is it successful? What can you use when doing your product. ]]> 2021-09-27 11:03:52 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770732862 Do the students need sub strands in their criteria? elizaritt https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770734577 2021-09-27 11:04:59 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770734577 Group 1 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770736034 Appropriate criteria with some descriptors, based on some research conducted. ]]> 2021-09-27 11:05:54 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770736034 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770738334 Multiple criteria, based on extensive research.]]> 2021-09-27 11:07:21 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770738334 Group 1: Example https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770745086 2021-09-27 11:11:38 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770745086 This level is better than basic because the inclusion of more description applies to more functions and forms of the product which show a wider description of success. https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770751507 2021-09-27 11:15:05 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770751507 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770752278 A range of relevant and detailed criteria, which describes the expectations with varied strands. The criteria could include form, function, impact on audience, manufacturing details, impact on the environment etc.]]> 2021-09-27 11:15:32 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770752278 The details are supported and informed to product success at a level of detail which supercedes basic and appropriate. https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770754531 2021-09-27 11:16:57 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770754531 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770754622 2021-09-27 11:17:01 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770754622 Supersede!!! https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770756571 2021-09-27 11:18:14 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770756571 https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770759754 It is good if the criteria are multidimensional, informed by different source types and the students are also studying examples "in real life" of products similar to what they would like to create.

I also think it is good if the research question / inquiry question, the goal and the success criteria all have connections with each other.  ]]> 2021-09-27 11:20:08 UTC https://padlet.com/brentpuglisi1/7f0c601durq0gv9w/wish/1770759754