Remake of Love Potion #10 PART 3: by Erin Valentie

Part 3: (1/2 Block)

evalenti — 2017-08-09 19:39:52 UTC

Answer Questions 9 and 10 on this padlet as a team.

Sam, Sutton, Carson, Jaden

2018-01-25 14:56:12 UTC

9)We do not believe that she had enough people take part in the experiment to prove anything, so we do not believe this to be credible. We think that people looking only at the numbers and percentages would say yes, but not if you look deeper into the data.
10)Other people likely haven't recreated this experiment because it is likely hard to get enough of the pheromone to recreate the experiment. She conducted an experiment on her own product and likely doesn't want to be proven wrong.

2018-01-25 14:57:00 UTC

Wafiya, Brianna, Lauryn, Oru-Ntui

2018-01-25 14:57:56 UTC

9.) Yes, it shows that she conducted an experiment on humans with substantial evidence to prove that the pheromone works. People might say no because there is not an abundance of evidence showing that the pheromone actually works.
10.) No, we feel like if we replicated the experiment, the results would be different depending on the personalities of the subjects being tested. You would also need to test the same gender, same amount of people, same age group, and sexual orientation. Her research has not been replicated because everything has to be the same and constant and the resources are not available.

Karen, Sharice, Marti, Ryan

2018-01-25 14:59:00 UTC

9) people would say yes because of what the data showed and the people taking the pheromone showed increased activity and people would say no because it might be made up and it's not a reliable study
10) we don't know because we all agree we would have to conduct the experiment to find out our own results and it would be too expensive for us to try to conduct

Ryan, James, Sydney, Adhishta

2018-01-25 15:01:16 UTC

9. People might say yes because of the experiment and the data that proves men who took the pheromone increased in romantic relationships. People might say no because the data could have been easily changed and corrupted.
10. I do not think that we would get the same results because the experiment depends on the subjects and the other factors that might play a part in it. The experiment might not have been duplicated by other researchers because they cannot do the same experiment as the first one

Jillian, Jacob, Patrick, Ethan

10024053 — 2018-01-25 15:06:36 UTC

9) We don't think that Dr. Cutler's research is credible. It was based completely on the men's perception of their love lives. People might answer yes to this because there is data, and it does seem to support the hypothesis. People might answer no because the data is only based on men, it hasn't been replicated, and it was completely based on the perception of men.
10) We don't think that the same results would occur if Dr. Cutler's experiment was replicated because the groups were small and the results could have been completely coincidental. Her experiment wasn't very reliable, it seems, and other researchers probably haven't replicated the experiment because they know that the data will not be the same.

Hunter, Margot, Basith, Kathy

2018-01-25 15:09:57 UTC

9) Cutler's research doesn't seem to be credible. It was only based on men's perspective. This made the results very biased and the product was also marketed to women. They might say yes because they are gullible. Most people would answer no because it doesn't seem true.
10) No. The experiment was biased and was probably partially faked. Most scientists probably have not recreated it because they know it's not true.

Kelsea , Scotty , Mark , Taylor

2018-01-25 16:34:54 UTC

9. We believe that Cutler research doesn't give the Love position #10 a better perspective in our eyes because the research was done on men but it is more of women's type of product so why not experiment on women.Also the product already looks like a scam and the "research" just adds to it.
10. We don't think the results were credible because it the groups were small and biased and her results just so happened to prove Love position right , making us believe that its fake.