https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j Made with charm en-us 2016-11-17 14:49:46 UTC 2016-11-17 15:16:20 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138424064  I think he found Elsewhere because he could hear music when he got to the bottom of the snow hill. Maybe the giver gave him a memory of music and he is just thinking about it. No I did not like the ending because it made me want to read on. Maybe she ended that way so we could think of different things that might have happened. I am ready to watch the movie. ]]> 2016-11-17 15:00:36 UTC https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138424064 https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138424139 I think that Jonas  was hallucinating and he is about to die. I think this is what happening because it is unclear what he is seeing and everything happened so suddenly. I didn't like the ending because I like closure, and I want to know what happened! I think the author did this to have the reader choose to think what happened. 

]]> 2016-11-17 15:00:42 UTC https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138424139 https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138424697 I think Jonas was going to Elsewhere because he started hearing and seeing people singing. Yes i liked the ending becasue it was a peaceful ending to Jonas. I think the author ended the way it did becasue she wanted the readers to imagine Jonas being happy in elsewhere.]]> 2016-11-17 15:01:44 UTC https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138424697 https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138424699 i think Jonas was hallucinating because the giver gave him the memory of the house and the sled earlier. and i think he will end up dead. no, i dont like the ending because the author left us hanging. i like when the author end the story detailed and lets us know exactly what happened, the author in this book didnt. i think the author ended the story like this because she wanted us to use our imagination and make us think how the story should end. like we are doing right now.

]]> 2016-11-17 15:01:44 UTC https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138424699 https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138425045 I think he found elsewhere because in the end it says he heard music. it gave Jonas hope for him and Gabe.

]]> 2016-11-17 15:02:25 UTC https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138425045 https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138425267 I think he was found elsewhere because how he could here the music at the bottom.  I don't like the ending cause it was kind of confusing. It made me want to keep on reading the giver cause it was a good book. I am hoping that the author will make another book. I think she ended the way she did so that other people are thinking about what might happen next.]]> 2016-11-17 15:02:46 UTC https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138425267 https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138425323 I believe that Jonas was dead because he was losing consciousness and had to force his eyes open. I liked  the ending because it showed that maybe the  his past society was enjoying life. I think the author ended the story this to leave you thinking what happened and thinking what you want to think.
:)
:)]]> 2016-11-17 15:02:53 UTC https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138425323 https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138425617 I think Jonas was hallucinating, because he was out in the middle of no where and heard singing and saw Christmas lights. I like the ending because it leaves me thinking about things and its confusing, and I like confusing. I think the author ended the book like this, because she wanted the reader to have their own ideas about what happened and she wanted to leave them wondering about Jonas's life.]]> 2016-11-17 15:03:28 UTC https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138425617 https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138425730 I think that he found a new community (elsewhere). I think he found elsewhere because of the memory that the giver had gave him of the Christmas party was actually real. I did not like the way she ended it because I do not like how she left a cliffhanger it felt like she did not finish the book at all. I think that she ended it the way she dose because she wanted us to figure out how it ended and how he got to elsewhere or if he died when he left the community so that the people in the community to get the memory.]]> 2016-11-17 15:03:40 UTC https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138425730 https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138425859 I think he died. he is not use to getting food [hunting] for himself so he has no experience to get food. i think he dies. No it was a cliff hanger . i dont enjoy cliff hangers]]> 2016-11-17 15:03:53 UTC https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138425859 https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138425871 I think he was hallucinating because it said he was losing conscious. I did like the ending because for me it was showing that he is becoming the giver
I think she ended the way it did because he was becoming then he learned the ability to HEAR beyond]]> 2016-11-17 15:03:54 UTC https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138425871 https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138430593 2016-11-17 15:13:35 UTC https://padlet.com/kmcguire5/6e58ulmd1t7j/wish/138430593