Marginalized Voices in Music Education by Travis Gratteau-Zinnel https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh Add quotes that you found interesting. en-us 2021-01-29 12:03:45 UTC 2021-01-30 18:09:32 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143802449 page 13- "questioning one's value and sense of belong in the profession, and grappling with the probability of 'selling out'-- trading one's experiential truth in exchange for social and professional acceptance." Institutionalized Whiteness (as the author describes above) affects everyone negatively (racism is about society, and truly has a negative impact on everyone)-- this is a point that REI (Racial Equity Institute) often makes.]]> 2021-01-30 16:49:39 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143802449 Cultural Bias https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143803188 It occurs when people make assumptions about conventions of appearance, language, repertoire, notation, ways of learning, ways of transmission, and ways of performing. Cultural bias permeates every sector of the field of music education, ....(p. 4). ]]> 2021-01-30 16:50:07 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143803188 representation in hiring https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143803476 not a quote - but I wasn't expecting the first item to be on representation in teachers - I've been thinking about this since reading - it makes sense to start at this point at the beginning of music education - and we may have a music position opening in the next year or so - I'm wondering how to think about hiring with diversity and inclusion in mind]]> 2021-01-30 16:50:19 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143803476 travisgz https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143803499 Bradley asserts that while multiculturalism is often modeled as a gesture of inclusion of music outside the western canon, paradoxically this action also places race and racism into a generic box of otherness which lessens meanings and distinctions unique to marginalized populations (p. 15)]]> 2021-01-30 16:50:20 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143803499 ...illustrating how specific structures and social actors in our profession perpetuate and legitimize an oppressive social order." https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143803733 2021-01-30 16:50:28 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143803733 travisgz https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143805041 My professors' rationale included that I would be perceived as "the one who only talks about race," that I would ruin my chances of finding employment in higher education, and that I would my doctoral experience difficult because no one talks about these things, especially focusing them into a dissertation (p. 19)]]> 2021-01-30 16:51:20 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143805041 Advocacy? https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143805284 The arts and the field of music education are trying to play catch-up, and we are looking for a band-aid to the problem—blaming the causes of inequity on lack of resources, lack of skill development, lack of parental support, and/or advocacy. Advocacy for our field would not be necessary if the broader population felt the work we did as music teachers represented and reflected their identities and daily lives. (p. 5-6).]]> 2021-01-30 16:51:29 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143805284 Charles Mills https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143805593 I'm not sure who this is-- will look up.]]> 2021-01-30 16:51:40 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143805593 "religious dogma used to mask the implication of colonialism" just the idea of the vast ways religion is used to justify things that seem so wrong https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143805612 I hate that she was told not to research something by a white male (probably)

I love the storytelling idea. I think it really becomes more empathetic

Just the fact that more money was given to students who were white as recently as the 70's than students of color in public schools should help us understand how student of color might be lower in skills

I didn't realize historically black schools weren't as entrenched in european music and reading skills

I've never heard the words race talk and find that interesting.]]> 2021-01-30 16:51:41 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143805612 pg 15- "a majority of the curricula is saturated by a Western musical canon." Yes-- this is incredibly frustrating, because it takes money to access non-Western music, and not all programs have the budgets. https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143806147 2021-01-30 16:52:01 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143806147 Discouraging Minority Voices https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143807300 Why does my own profession wish to silence me? Are these opposing voices acts of terror to discourage minority voices from contributing authentic pieces that would threaten a narrative dominated by White voices? (p. 24-25). ]]> 2021-01-30 16:52:42 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143807300 "Until the story of the hunt is told by the lion, the tale of the hunt will always glorify the hunter" https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143807333 2021-01-30 16:52:44 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143807333 Multiculturalism https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143807644 Lots of multiculturalism conversations that I appreciate-- especially being heavily involved with ACDA DEI work (state level and DIC). ]]> 2021-01-30 16:52:54 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143807644 Storytelling https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143809163 "The power in storytelling lies in its ability to destroy mindset." ]]> 2021-01-30 16:53:53 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143809163 Race talks https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143810330 Her discussion of conversations with friends and professors... not "wanting to be perceived as the only who talks about race." (top of pg 19). This is a very "old school" approach in academia, but one that is very real-- because talking about race upsets the donor base.]]> 2021-01-30 16:54:41 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143810330 racism vs multiculturalism and social justice. https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143810335 Obstacles include our struggle to confront colonialism, institutionalized Whiteness,  . . . tendency to sideline issues of racism w/in pluralistic platforms such as multiculturalism and social justice. ]]> 2021-01-30 16:54:41 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143810335 "...subscriptions to colorblindness, as the new racial ideology, reinforces White privilege." https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143810770 2021-01-30 16:54:57 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143810770 Privilege https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143811340 They could be unapologetically honest and bold because speaking race as a White person has far fewer consequences. (p. 23).]]> 2021-01-30 16:55:20 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143811340 Powerless https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143811931 pg 19- "institutionalized Whiteness can leave one feeling quite powerless." Yes, because ultimately, this is all about who brokers the power and holds onto it.]]> 2021-01-30 16:55:44 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143811931 othering to keep Whiteness on top https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143813501 while muti-culturalism is often modeled as a gesture of inclusion of music outside the western canon, paradoxically this action also places race and racism into a generic box of otherness which lessens meanings and distinctions unique to marginalized populations]]> 2021-01-30 16:56:48 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143813501 pg 22- https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143813509 "I think those theories got in the way of what I really wanted to say." This is an issue.]]> 2021-01-30 16:56:48 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143813509 Perceptions https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143814676 I mean, I knew what to say, but I didn’t want to appear as if “I’m going off” on the profession or that I was the angry Black woman. But, I was! I was angry, Black, and a woman,... (p. 21-22) ]]> 2021-01-30 16:57:39 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143814676 https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143925623 2021-01-30 18:07:33 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143925623 https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143925803 2021-01-30 18:07:41 UTC https://padlet.com/travisgz/5zy5grrx4rhl88bh/wish/1143925803