Nile river & Ancient Egypt Socratic Seminar by Mackenzie Dill

29santhoshh — 2025-09-23 15:02:33 UTC

Erin had gone off with what everyone said but put in her own words and I think it was done very well. Simon also made good points as well

29thomasc11 — 2025-09-23 16:27:58 UTC

I agree with Julz because she referenced the document b and how if the Nile wasn't there they would have no religion

29dominiquet — 2025-09-23 16:28:18 UTC

I agree with the girl in the white hoodie, she cited Document B, how the Egyptians based their seasons off of the Nile's flooding seasons, which is why Egypt wouldn't be the same without the Nile.

2025-09-23 16:28:56 UTC

Brie and autumn had a good point about the flood cycles because of the Nile.

29thomasc11 — 2025-09-23 16:29:40 UTC

I agree with pink hoodie because she talked about how the planting seasons are shaped by the Nile and made silt for crop growing

29dominiquet — 2025-09-23 16:30:08 UTC

The girl with the pony tail made good points. She said that, without the Nile, their government wouldn't be the same, and they wouldn't have papyrus to write on.

29tirrellt — 2025-09-23 16:30:22 UTC

Brie talked about the flood cycles and how when they would flood it would provide food which is a good point and a smart thing to talk about.

29medior — 2025-09-23 16:30:23 UTC

Issac was very vague with his answer, feel like he could have added a few more details

29eisingerc — 2025-09-23 16:30:24 UTC

Isaac had great point about the Nile providing water and crops, very nice and simple

29lopezciancaglinib — 2025-09-23 16:30:48 UTC

Everyone is having good points about the Nile.

29thomasc11 — 2025-09-23 16:31:09 UTC

The pink hoodie girl and the white hoodie girl and Julz talk about the him and the religion part of the Nile

29tirrellt — 2025-09-23 16:31:12 UTC

Julz mentioned Ra and how he influenced the religion of the Egyptians which is also a very good point

29dominiquet — 2025-09-23 16:31:15 UTC

Isaac had a good point but didn't articulate it well enough

29eisingerc — 2025-09-23 16:31:59 UTC

Julz had very good connection with Ra being the reason of the Nile and basically everything and she did a great job at explaining it.

29eisingerc — 2025-09-23 16:32:50 UTC

Everyone had very good response.

29tirrellt — 2025-09-23 16:34:13 UTC

I agree with Brie on when she talked about how they would get fish from the Nile and they would trade with it

29quilesj — 2025-09-23 16:35:12 UTC

The pretty girl with pink pants (I'm sorry I don't know your name) made a good point mentioning the flood season

29napolescollazoa — 2025-09-23 16:36:37 UTC

the guy with the black short sleeve shirt made a good point to go based off of.

29quilesj — 2025-09-23 16:37:40 UTC

Willow made a great point by referring how the stability was shaped in Ancient Egypt and how without technology now we could analyze the patterns the animals and plants follow to understand the flood cycle.

29napolescollazoa — 2025-09-23 16:39:00 UTC

The girl with the glasses explained well how the Egyptians could figure out when to date the seasons.

29saccomannoa — 2025-09-23 16:39:25 UTC

Autumn Saccomanno

Brian was talking about technology and how if we didn't have it it would be harder to find flood cycles and a lot for growing crops. Willow was talking a lot about watching nature as in plants and animals to tell what is happening around with life. There was mentions of travel going around and fertilization of the soil. The flooding cycle, in Rashad's words, was the definition of when they could grow crops and check their lands.

29mortonl — 2025-09-23 16:39:51 UTC

Mia made a good point about the flood season, The girl with the black hoodie made a good point about selling crops, Mikayla made a good point about how to tell the seasons.

29klepadlob — 2025-09-23 16:40:27 UTC

The girl with the black hoodie and braid was going off what others where saying but in a good way, she was making more points, building off it.

29klepadlob — 2025-09-23 16:42:08 UTC

the guy in the white Tshirt was very clear and I understood what he was saying

2025-09-23 16:42:09 UTC

Rashad Hill

Thomas makes a great point about an ancient empire that formed without a major river.

29piercew — 2025-09-23 16:42:35 UTC

Thomas held a strong voice and was confident with his speech setting a good debate tone for everyone else.

29solea — 2025-09-23 16:43:06 UTC

Everyone made good points about why and how a civilization could survive without a major river with good explanations

2025-09-23 16:44:37 UTC

Thomas had a good response and he said that the Nile was very important and got them everything they needed but the civilizations can still manage to be stable without rivers.

29sheffm — 2025-09-23 16:45:14 UTC

It was good that everyone was able to agree with each other.