chapter 12 Question response by Mei An https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e en-us 2018-01-08 05:03:19 UTC 2018-01-08 08:08:58 UTC hello@padlet.com Maggie- answer those following questions briefly man21 https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219230497 4. Why didn’t Gene cry for Finny’s death? 
5. Do you blame Gene for Finny’s death? Why or why not?
]]> 2018-01-08 05:09:46 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219230497 Li Xiaoxue https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232343 1. Finny control his emotion because he is still angry about what Gene did to him, and in Finny's deep heart hiding little secrets-- he desires to enlist. 
2.Gene thinks that even though Finny attend the war, he could not do nothing, and he could not become hero in the war. 
3.Both of them are reach the same realization of the incident of tree. The reason they given to could not satisfy audiences because even Gene could not believe what's the reason he pull Finny falling down to the tree.
4. Because Gene totally switch the mind with Finny. No one will cry when they attend his own funeral. 
5. No, because it is merely to find someone who likes Finny. Everyone contains the jealous emotion toward things which is superior than your's. ]]> 2018-01-08 05:34:20 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232343 https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232371 2018-01-08 05:34:47 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232371 Wang zhengyang Spike https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232436 1.Part of it because of the friendship. Besides, Finny himself is kind.
2.Finny is useless if he goes to the war
3.The explanation could not satisfy me although they have made an agreement. I think Gene should confess what really happened that day since that is what he did, and he need to take all the responsbility. Regret is useless, and he does not know what he was doing is not an explanation. Besides, I believe if he really finds out his "nature", he can change himself.
4. He thinks that the funeral also is "his", which means Gene is influenced by the Finny, he eventually become "Finny" because Finny is always his goal, and now he reaches it.
5. Yes, no matter is the injury, or the psycological damage is caused by Gene. ]]> 2018-01-08 05:35:56 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232436 Darktion 1078377307 https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232482 1. Finny did not want to show his hate to Gene and he knew the truth.
2. Gene told him that he could not do well in the war even if his leg was not broken. Yes. The war is extremely different with sports, whatever how Finny does good at sport, it does not mean he can also do well in battle.
3. Gene did that due to some crazy things inside of him. It does satisfy me. Sometimes I also have an intention to do something rush, whatever, it makes sense to me.
4. He also felt there is a funeral for him either, he just felt some cold chill.
5. Yes. I do blame him, Gene caused all of the starting-made Finny's leg broken; but he also got punishment by himself, he was judged by himself and lost his soul for the cost.]]> 2018-01-08 05:36:45 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232482 shansihui https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232493 1. The first reason is that Finny at that time doesn't tolerant Gene, so he uses unfriendly voice to Gene. And another reason is that Finny also has a secret---he writes letter to Army---, and he wants to control his emotion in order to make sure he will not tell this secret to Gene. however, he actually tells this secret to Gene.
2.Gene tells to Finny that Finny wouldn’t be any good in the war, even if nothing had happened to his leg since actually Finny isn't an appropriate person for war.
3. At the end of the conversation, they have the same conclusion: the reason why Gene does that kind of thing on the tree is that it was just some kind of blind impulse Gene had in the tree, and Gene didn’t know what his was doing. And I satisfy this conclusion since Gene is just a teenager, which means he can't control his feelings such as envy as mature as adult. Therefore, even though Gene does an unpardonable thing, the conclusion is still reasonable for me. I think this event is a kind of thing which can help Gene grow up.
4. Since Gene thinks that this was his own funeral, and he do not cry in that case, and from this part, I think Gene eventually losses his identity.
5. I think Gene feels regret to Finny since from Finny's death, Gene grows up. He becomes a part of Finny not only because he wants to be a person like Finny but also he feels regret, and he thinks he should live for Finny.]]> 2018-01-08 05:37:03 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232493 Dong Changhao https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232500 1.In fact, at the bottom of Finny’s heart, he wants to attend the war even though he chooses not to believe in it namely. He has tried to send application but got rejected because of his leg injured. However, Gene got one and brought a suitcase to ready to attend the war Finny want
2.Gene announces that even if Finny go to the war, he probably could do nothing. I think it makes sense because Finny isn’t fit for going for a war anymore.
3.Everyone gets to know that Gene pushed Finny not intentionally because of jealous. They think it is because of blind pot. They accept what they believe. It satisfy me because everyone would like to believe in it even Finny himself
4.Gene thinks that he and Finny have already understand the situation and agree with each other’s thoughts about Finny’s leg
5.Yes. Because he is the only reason why Finny got injured. He basically ruined Finny’s life.]]> 2018-01-08 05:37:13 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232500 Guoyi https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232514 4 Because Gene believes that Finny had already became part of himself and it is not necessary to cry for him own funeral.
5 From my perspective, I would like to say that I do not think that It is Gene’s responsibility for Finny’s death. It is true that Finny was gone due to the medical accident and Gene did nothing to that. Also, Gene had felt that he has became Finny so in some way, Finny is still alive.
3 They have an agreement that Gene had some kind of blind impulse on the tree accident. I think this is satisfy to me since Gene indeed regretted for this accident.
2 he told Finny that he would not good in the war,even his leg is good. Honestly, this actually makes sense since Finny does not like war at all he even doubts that if war is exists
1 Because Finny still blame for Gene and he believes that Gene is a bad guy who always wants to hurt him.]]> 2018-01-08 05:37:21 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232514 Y https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232517 2018-01-08 05:37:23 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232517 Y https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232518 2018-01-08 05:37:24 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232518 Yang Qijin https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232519 1: Finny doesn't forgive Gene. He act very unfriendly toward Gene. Finny also write letter to Army and he doesn't wants to tell Gene this thing.
2: it won't work if Finny join the war because of his leg. Finny can't be a hero even he join the war. It didn't make any sense. Finny write many letter.  
3:They have same conclusion. What happened on the tree even Gene doesn't know what he did.
4:He could not escape a felling that this way his own funeral.
5: Yes, I think Gene is the one to blame. It is Gene who hurt Finny's leg and also hurt Finny's felling. At last, Finny didn't forgive Gene.]]> 2018-01-08 05:37:24 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232519 f h b https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232526 1.
2.Gene said he can do nothing whatever his leg is broken.
3.]]> 2018-01-08 05:37:27 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232526 SHANYUANJI https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232632 1.Finny control his emotion for the secret that he wrote many letters and for the latter burst of his emotion.
2.Gene announced there was nothing he can do，it did make sence because it is impossible for young teens like him to stop the war and the war happened inevitablely.
3.Gene shook the tree and make Finny injury due to the impulse of Gene’s jealousy to Finny. However, everyone make mistakes but if the victim is your best friend, there should be something that they understand both.From this chapter, The fact doesn’t satisfy me because even though they were best friends they didn’t said what they actually feel deep inside their heart. Real friends would unlikely be like that.
4.Because Gene feel the emotional torture that beyond tears, and Finny seems be with Gene forever as a soul, which motivates Gene to do his best to achieve glory
5.Yes.Because What Gene did is serious and somehow unforgivable, which made Finny disable to accomplish his goal]]> 2018-01-08 05:39:07 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232632 Zhangyuxuan https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232669 1. Because he didn’t want to tell Gene his thought at first.
2. He told him he won’t become a good soldier even his legs didn’t broke. I think it make sense,because he will mess out the war.
3. It was just some kind of blind impulse Gene had in the tree there. This explanation can’t satisfy me because I think Gene did this because he had a kind of jealousy upon Finny.
4. Because Gene thought it was his own f]]> 2018-01-08 05:39:55 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232669 Yangrenyu https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232682 1 Because Finny has a secret in his mind that he wrote a lot of letter to military offices to service, but none of these offices answer yes to Finny.
2 He said to Finny that even if Finny didn't break his leg, Finny is not suitable for the war. It makes sense, because Finny is exactly that kind of person that he treated the war as a game.
3 Finny believe that it was something negative inside Gene caused Gene to make Finny fall down the tree and break his leg. However, the explanation of Gene couldn't satisfy me. Because it was Finny always hurt from the relationship between him and Gene. It is not fair for Finny to bear all the truths in mind and pretend to be friend with Gene.
4 Because Gene felt the death of Finny is the death of himself
5 I don't blame Gene for Finny's death, because after the injury of Finny, Gene is always the one to care about Finny and treat him well to atone for his crime. Everyone is like Gene, and everyone would make mistakes. If one could admit his or her crime and try to do something well to pay back, the one should not be blamed. Besides, Gene is not the one directly caused Finny's death.]]> 2018-01-08 05:40:03 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232682 Wei Shutao https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232725 1:Because Finny doesn't hate Gene anymore. Even though he still not forgive gene, Finny can control himself.
2: Gene said that it is impossible for Finny to go to the war. I think it makes sense because Finny is disable to go to the war.
3:They have an agreement that Gene had some kind of blind impulse on the tree accident. No. I think Finny should hate Gene forever.
4:Gene thinks that he and Finny have already understand the situation and agree with each other’s thoughts about Finny’s leg.
5: .Yes.Because What Gene did is serious and somehow unforgivable, which made Finny disable to accomplish his goal]]> 2018-01-08 05:40:39 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232725 jinyun 1257116182 https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232749 1. Finny keeps his emotion under control because he wants peace and love in his mind instead of dark truth.
2. Gene says there would have nothing he can do. It makes sense because he broke his leg and he is not suitable for the war.
3. They both believe that it was an accident . No, this explanation is just a kind of escaping from mistakes. Finny has reason to hate him about his legs
4.Gene fells that Finny becomes part of him so he does not need to cry for it.
5. Yes. It was Gene's fault , and Finny cannot be the same as before again because of his pulling. Sometimes broken someone' s heart is a kind of action that as same as killing that person, especially for those innocent people just like Finny.]]> 2018-01-08 05:40:59 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232749 Cui Wendong cwd19991207 https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232757 1. Because Finny didn't want Gene to know his feeling
2. He think Finny's idea is ridiculous. He think a person with a broken leg would not be excellent in the war
3.No,it does not satisfy me because it is not the truth. People does mot know what really happened at that moment.
4. Gene did not cry for the Finny's death
5. Yes, I blame him, Finny's death is Gene's fault]]> 2018-01-08 05:41:08 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232757 LKW https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232803 1: Finny has a secret that he sent a mail to the troop, however, they reject him because of his injury. Also, Finny doesn't forgive Gene. So, Finny wants to calm down himself since he cannot accept the fact. 

2: Gene said that it is impossible that Finny engage in the war since his characteriestic is not appropriate to the war. It make sense, because Finny cannot hate others, he's too kind. 

3:They think that it was not anything personal, whereas it is just impulse. It not satisfy me, because if the explanation is impulse, I think that the incident in the tree would be very irrational.

4: Gene thinks that he could not escape a feeling that this was my own funeral, and he does not cry in that case. 

5: Yes, because if I were Finny, what Gene has done is really not excusable. The incident in the tree makes Finny crippled, so that he cannot achieve his goal. ]]> 2018-01-08 05:42:00 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232803 FHB https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232913 1.Finny controls himself, he doesn't want to believe Gene. Finny does not forgive Gene.
2.Gene said Finny is not suit for war whatever his leg is broken or not.
3.Gene can't let others to believe the reason why he hurt Finny. I think it is the impetuosity. Gene envys Finny, and during that time it explodes.]]> 2018-01-08 05:44:00 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219232913 Weihanrong https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219233404
  • Because he forces himself to forgive Gene when they have the conversation.And after the conversation，they both reach the consensus.He trys to believe and he believe Gene pushes him because his temporary impulsion and Gene does not really mean he is going to hurt Finny. Meanwhile，Finny wants to attend war. He had already wrote many letters to different troops；however，no troop lets him to enlist . Therefore，he does not share the secret to any one else.
  • Gene tells Finny that he had make a mess，a terrible mass，out of the war. Because he thinks Finny does not really fit the war. 
  • They both believe that Gene pushes Finny unintentionally and he does it because his temporary impulsion triggers him and he does not really hate Finny
  •  
    Because Gene and Finny ‘s personalities transforms.They share their lifestyles by living in each other’s lifestyle.Therefore，Gene says he could not escape a feeling that this was his own funeral，and he does not cry in that case.Therefore，when Finny dies，he thinks he is also buried .


    • ]]>     2018-01-08 05:51:49 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219233404     Fhb https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219233763 4. Becaues it is the end of the war between Gene and Finny.
    5.I think Finny's death is not totally caused by Gene. Finny's personality that has no enmity, which decide him that he does not suit for enlist.

    ]]>     2018-01-08 05:58:23 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219233763     Zhangyuxuan https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219234123 4. Gene thought that it was his own funeral, which he do not cry in that case.
    5. I will blame Gene for Finny ‘s death,because all the things happened for Gene made Finny fall down from the tree ]]>     2018-01-08 06:03:59 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219234123     Wei Hanrong https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219234784 1. Because he forces himself to forgive Gene when they have the conversation.And after the conversation，they both reach the consensus.He trys to believe and he believe Gene pushes him because his temporary impulsion and Gene does not really mean he is going to hurt Finny. Meanwhile，Finny wants to attend war. He had already wrote many letters to different troops；however，no troop lets him to enlist . Therefore，he does not share the secret to any one else.
    2. Gene tells Finny that he had make a mess，a terrible mass，out of the war. Because he thinks Finny does not really fit the war. 
    3. They both believe that Gene pushes Finny unintentionally and he does it because his temporary impulsion triggers him and he does not really hate Finny
    4.  Because Gene and Finny ‘s personalities transforms.They share their lifestyles by living in each other’s lifestyle.Therefore，Gene says he could not escape a feeling that this was his own funeral，and he does not cry in that case.Therefore，when Finny dies，he thinks he is also buried .
    5. I blame Gene for Finny‘s death. Because of him，he lets Finny’s mind changes.Before Finny breaks his legs，he is an optimistic person.After he breaks his legs，Finny can not go to war like others；therefore his mind changes and he is always going to hide his real feelings like writing letters to troops.Also，when Finny breaks his leg，his whole life breaks too. Because the athletic activities are the reason why he chuoose to live. Gene breaks his dream
    ]]>     2018-01-08 06:11:21 UTC https://padlet.com/man21/5p2dlh2fu00e/wish/219234784