GOOD~BETTER~BEST (Feeney) by Heather Canzurlo

team1 Alexus, Devin,Courtney,Austyn

canz123 — 2015-05-14 00:21:18 UTC

We think C is good because personally we think it's wrong because it only supports a Claim that they think is true.

We think A is better because it only supports the Claim ( dont agree with marcus)and Evidence (neils height is rounded to the nearest 100 ,but marcus is rounded to the nearest 10).

We think B is the best because it supports the Claim (i dissagree with marcus) Evidence (neil rounded to the nearest 10 , but marcus rounded to the nearest 100) and Reasoning ( marcus is taller and neil is shorter).

DIRECTIONS FOR EACH GROUP:

canz123 — 2015-05-14 00:21:19 UTC

1) Study the 3 student work samples for Comparing Heights.

2) Evaluate the samples, looking for the CLAIM, EVIDENCE, and REASONING.

3) Rank the samples as GOOD~BETTER~BEST.

4) Post your response to the Padlet wall. Type your names in red next to where it says your team number. Identify the work samples as "A", "B", and "C".

Use complete sentences to explain your reasoning for your rankings.

Mrs. Canzurlo

canz123 — 2015-05-14 00:21:19 UTC

team2 Ben nedeen Juan

canz123 — 2015-05-14 00:23:55 UTC

we think c is good but personally it is bad because it has nothing to support it and there is no evidence or reasoning.

a is better because it only supports claim and evidence no reasoning.

b is the best because it supports claim evidence and reasoning .

team3 Abigail Gabriela.

canz123 — 2015-05-14 00:24:15 UTC

We think student C. Is good because it has claim,evidence but no reasoning. Also it is wrong

team4 Gabi S Alyssa Andrew

canz123 — 2015-05-14 00:25:00 UTC

Ranking for student A is good because it only has a claim it doesn't have evidence or a reasoning. Ranking for student B is the best because it gives a claim it gives evidence and it give a reasoning and it proves Marcus is wrong. ranking for student C is better because it gives a claim evidence and a reasoning also it doesn't prove the evidence.These are the rankings we give these students.

team5Carmine Kian Shaw

canz123 — 2015-05-14 00:25:32 UTC

B is the best because it has the C-E-R method.

A is the better than C. B only has C-E not C-E-R.

team6

canz123 — 2015-05-15 18:00:52 UTC

Kennedy Maggie Julia cami Ashley so we all think that it is B because B shows C-E-R and correct statements and includes facts that support the claim.Also includes facts that support the claim j