Was Kili and Fili right to say they had found a safe cave? by

Believing that they would be safe away from the monsters, yes they were right.

twarrilow — 2017-09-20 08:34:02 UTC

Actually, I also believe that they're right because they were going to die as the cave is safer than being outside in the brutal thunderstorm. KM

2017-09-20 08:39:28 UTC

I think your write because it is better than nothing BK

2017-09-20 08:39:31 UTC

I think they shouldn't lie because they may be away from the rain but that might be unsafe in the cave because they didn't fully search the cave so it might be the goblins lair LB

2017-09-20 08:39:35 UTC

OF I think it was wrong to lie because he put lives in danger.

2017-09-20 08:42:20 UTC

I also think that Fili and Kili should

2017-09-20 08:42:32 UTC

I believe they can lie because it safer than being out there there because theirs rock monster RR

2017-09-20 08:42:35 UTC

They were wrong to lie but tell them that they did not check it AD

2017-09-20 08:42:43 UTC

I think that they were right to lie because if they didn't they would have died anyway but, with the cave there was a 50 % chance that they'd survive. KA

2017-09-20 08:42:43 UTC

I think they should have tell the truth about the cave because if the dwarfs find out that they have lie they might not belief them again .

2017-09-20 08:43:00 UTC

J B

if they don't find a cave they might die if not LJPW

2017-09-20 08:43:01 UTC

JS

2017-09-20 08:43:08 UTC

I believe they were doing wrong when they told the lies.

Dh

2017-09-20 08:43:23 UTC

I think they shouldn't lie because kili and fili will make every one die even though they will probally die

Fili and Kili should have searched more so that they could find a safer place. BA

2017-09-20 08:43:26 UTC

I think they shouldn't lie because there putting everyone's life in danger.

2017-09-20 08:44:02 UTC

they are in a bad place and its not the right time to lie LC

2017-09-20 08:44:10 UTC

it was not all

2017-09-20 08:44:24 UTC

If they didn't find the cave they could of fell off the cliff and die if it was not for Kili and Fili. R

2017-09-20 08:44:32 UTC

Zak. Kili and FILI could say that its a safe cave but what if the rock monster smash the cave.

2017-09-20 08:44:54 UTC

Fili and Kili should of found a safer cave somewhere more away from the giants. RG

2017-09-20 08:45:17 UTC

2017-09-20 08:45:27 UTC

They shouldn't lie because there could be something in the cave that coul cause them to fight. Fam

They were wrong lying to them cause it was a life or death situation. Yes they were doing it for there safety and so they wouldn't get destroyed but they should have searched more of the cave.

2017-09-20 08:45:37 UTC

JLG

2017-09-20 08:45:50 UTC

Killi and Fili were actually wrong to lie because they got them into more trouble. Harrison

I think they where wrong they shouldn't lie about the cave

2017-09-20 08:46:31 UTC

i don`t think that it was all

2017-09-20 08:46:51 UTC

right for Kill Fill lied . CA

I think they shouldn't because they could make there lives in danger. Fam

2017-09-20 08:46:56 UTC

They should have searched more but they wanted shelter so they had no choice. If you were in that situation then you want to go somewhere safer.

2017-09-20 08:47:10 UTC

2017-09-20 08:47:54 UTC

i do not think they shon't of lied hd

RR

2017-09-20 08:48:05 UTC

They should lie because they could ever die out side in the cold dangerous place or fight the goblins and live but they might be friendly goblins or not!

2017-09-20 08:48:10 UTC

Yes becouse it is much more better than staying outside when it is raining and there are monsters there.

KILI could of died if the bold one dident catch him LC

2017-09-20 08:48:24 UTC

They could of died if Kili and Fili didn't find the cave. RG

2017-09-20 08:48:40 UTC

They should lie because the Rock monsters could of threw them off the edge. RW

2017-09-20 08:48:44 UTC

it was a life or death situation it was either get destroyed by rock monsters or find an unsafe cave which would you prefer

2017-09-20 08:49:08 UTC

Why would they lie to their king about the cave they should have searched more for their safety

2017-09-20 08:49:21 UTC

I think Kili and Fili are to lazy to find a proper shelter you never know what's in the cavee LB

2017-09-20 08:49:25 UTC

I THINK THAT THEY SHOULD LIE AND THAT THEY SHOULDNT THEY SHOULD AGREE BECAUSE IT IS HARD TO SURVIVE AND I SHOULDNT AGREE BECAUSE THEY MIGHT DIE BECAUSE THEY DONT NO IF IT IS SAFE OR NOT

2017-09-20 08:49:38 UTC

THIS IS MY FULLEXPLANATION

BK

JS

2017-09-20 08:50:07 UTC

They have put a lot of life in danger

JS

2017-09-20 08:50:08 UTC

I think that they were wrong they shouldn't lie about the cave

2017-09-20 08:50:33 UTC

2017-09-20 08:50:50 UTC

yes I think they should of because it is much more better than being outside when it is raining and there are monsters and it is thundering. JI

RG. The Hobbits were to close to the Rock giants fighting.

2017-09-20 08:51:23 UTC

if they did not find a cave or they might die LJPW

2017-09-20 08:52:14 UTC

tili and kili shud not of lied because they almost died from the Rock monters

2017-09-20 08:52:24 UTC

Kili and Fili shouldn't have lie because they are putting others life in more danger! ZB

2017-09-20 08:53:18 UTC

THE ROCK MONSTERS NEARLY KILLED THEM WHEN THEY THOUGHT EACHOTHER

2017-09-20 09:05:26 UTC

I think maybe kili and fili are trying to abandone their master and maybe trying to kill everyone

2017-09-20 09:06:52 UTC

AC.

2017-09-20 09:07:22 UTC

i think they shouldn't lie because
the others could die

I think that Kili and Fili should

2017-09-20 09:07:42 UTC

Mya

2017-09-20 09:07:45 UTC

I think that killi and filli shou'ld not of lied to there master .

2017-09-20 09:07:59 UTC