•The ending should have been a sad ending because the mother and Bawang Merah were mean to Bawang Putih and Bawang Putih didn't forgive her.then her mother and Bawang Merah became poor and could not meet their needs and then died and Bawang Putih lived peacefully

After Bawang Putih got a gift from the mysterious grandmother, she returned home with a happy heart. Seeing Bawang Putih's kindness, Bawang Merah felt jealous and tried to do the same. However, because of her greedy and rude nature, when she brought home a large pumpkin, on the way home, Bawang Merah was reluctant to carry the pumpkin and fell into a ravine.

Happy Ending)

After enduring mistreatment from Bawang Merah and her stepmother, Bawang Putih is rewarded by a magical fish or fairy with a gourd filled with gold and jewelry. Meanwhile, Bawang Merah, out of greed, tries to get the same reward but instead receives a gourd filled with snakes or poisonous creatures. In the end, Bawang Merah and her mother regret their actions and apologize to Bawang Putih. They eventually live peacefully together.

When Bawang Merah's mother told Bawang Merah to go to the mysterious grandmother, Bawang Merah chose a big pumpkin. After she brought the pumpkin home, Bawang Merah and her mother then cut the pumpkin. When cutting the pumpkin, what came out was a poisonous animal instead of expensive jewelry. Bawang Merah and Bawang Merah's mother were angry with Bawang Putih. Then Bawang Putih was thrown out by her stepmother and Bawang Merah because she was considered to have lied to them.

(sad ending)

Bawang Merah, who realized her mistake and Bawang Putih's sincere kindness, decided to change. She sincerely apologized to Bawang Putih for all the bad treatment and cruelty she had done. Struck by regret, Bawang Merah promised to treat Bawang Putih as a real sister at that time. Their mother, who witnessed this change, was very happy and finally understood the importance of justice and love. Since then, the three of them lived together in harmony, sharing tasks and supporting each other, proving that kindness and forgiveness can really change the heart.

(happy ending)

Bawang Putih did not forgive Bawang Merah. Bawang Putih's father kicked out Bawang merah and his mother because they made the house full of dangerous animals. Bawang merah and his mother were chased by dangerous animals and bitten. Bawang merah mother died. Bawang merah was sad, he returned home and apologized to Bawang Putih and his father. Finally Bawang Merah, Bawang putih and his father lived happily.

(happy ending)

Bawang Merah and her mother became increasingly jealous seeing Bawang Putih living happily after receiving a gift from the goldfish. In desperation, they planned to get rid of Bawang Putih forever. One night, they took Bawang Putih to the forest and left her there. However, karma soon came. On the way home, the stepmother and Bawang Merah got lost and fell into a deep ravine. Bawang Putih, who was alone in the forest, tried to find her way home, but no one could help her. With a heart full of wounds and sadness, she finally settled in the forest, living alone in silence. Although she had forgiven her stepmother and Bawang Merah, fate had separated them forever.

(sad ending)

In the end Bawang Merah and her mother realized that happiness does not lie in wealth or external beauty but in kindness and honesty. They both began to live together peacefully. Bawang Putih's tireless kindness spread throughout the village and they both became increasingly respected by everyone. In a short time, Bawang Putih met a prince who was very impressed by her kindness and beauty. The prince proposed to Bawang Putih and they were married in a lively ceremony surrounded by their loved ones. With great happiness, Bawang Merah and Bawang Putih lived their respective lives but this time they supported each other and reminded each other to always do good. Evil was finally defeated by good and everyone in the village lived happily ever after.

(Happy ending)

After being treated unfairly, Bawang Putih left home and found a small village where she was welcomed for her kindness and hard work. Meanwhile, Bawang Merah and her mother struggled without her.

Realizing her mistake, Bawang Merah searched for Bawang Putih and apologized. With a kind heart, Bawang Putih forgave her. Soon after, their stepmother also came, regretting her actions.

In the end, the three of them lived peacefully in the village, becoming better people and leading a happy life together.

(Happy Ending)

However, when she entered the cave, the cave door suddenly closed tightly. It turned out that the cave was a cursed place that would only lock up people whose hearts were filled with greed. Bawang Merah screamed, cried, and begged for forgiveness, but no one could save her.

On the other hand, Bawang Putih waited anxiously for her sister to return. Days turned into weeks, but Bawang Merah never returned. Although Bawang Putih had searched everywhere, she never found a trace of her sister. With a sad heart, Bawang Putih could only pray that one day Bawang Merah would find peace. Since then, she has lived alone, always missing the figure of a sister who, although cruel, is still part of her family.

(tragic ending)

Rain poured heavily over the village as Bawang Merah walked alone toward the river. Her tears mixed with the raindrops, falling onto the damp earth. After all the wrongs she had done, she was now completely alone. Her mother had been banished from the village for her greed, and the villagers refused to speak to her. Silence and regret haunted her every step.

As she stood at the river’s edge, she saw her reflection in the water. But something was strange—her reflection wasn’t following her movements. Instead, it smirked and whispered, "Do you wish to erase your mistakes? Step into the water, and you will have a chance."

Startled, Bawang Merah stepped back, but deep inside, something urged her forward. She knew she had hurt Bawang Putih, stolen what wasn’t hers, and caused suffering. With a deep breath and a heart full of courage, she stepped into the water.

Suddenly, the world around her shifted. She was no longer in the river but in a mystical forest glowing with golden light. Trees whispered in hushed tones, and the river shimmered like crystal. Before her stood an elderly woman in a white robe, smiling kindly. "Bawang Merah," the woman said, "you have been chosen to undergo the trials of redemption. If you succeed, you will have a second chance. If you fail, you will remain trapped in your past mistakes forever."

Without hesitation, Bawang Merah nodded.

The Trial of Honesty

The old woman handed her a gleaming mirror. "Look into it," she instructed.

As Bawang Merah gazed into the mirror, she saw every wrongdoing she had committed—every lie she told, every time she let her mother mistreat Bawang Putih, every moment she laughed at her suffering. She wanted to look away, to shatter the mirror, but she knew that running away was not the answer. With tears streaming down her face, she whispered, "I have done wrong. I want to make it right."

The mirror glowed brightly before shattering into a thousand sparkling fragments that disappeared into the air.

The Trial of Courage

Next, the old woman led Bawang Merah to a hanging bridge stretching over a dark abyss. "On the other side lies the key to your redemption," she said. "But to cross, you must walk without fear."

Bawang Merah took a step forward, but the wind howled fiercely. The bridge swayed, and a voice from the abyss echoed, "You will never change. You are evil forever."

She almost lost her balance, but then she remembered how Bawang Putih had always been kind, even after all the pain she had endured. With newfound determination, Bawang Merah walked firmly, crossing the bridge and taking the glowing key at the other end. As she grasped it, the bridge disappeared, and she found herself back with the old woman.

The Trial of Sincerity

For the final trial, the old woman asked, "If given a second chance, what would you do?"

Bawang Merah paused before answering, "I don’t just want to apologize. I want to dedicate my life to helping others, just like Bawang Putih has always done."

The old woman smiled. "You have passed."

Suddenly, Bawang Merah felt a warm light surrounding her. When she opened her eyes, she was back at the riverbank, but something felt different. The village, once cold and distant, now seemed warmer.

She ran to Bawang Putih’s house. When the door opened, Bawang Putih stared at her in surprise. "I don’t need your apology, Bawang Merah," she said softly. "I only want to know if you have truly changed."

In response, Bawang Merah knelt, taking Bawang Putih’s hands in hers. "I swear, from this day forward, I will be the sister you deserve."

Bawang Putih smiled and embraced her tightly.

From that day on, Bawang Merah and Bawang Putih lived together in harmony. Bawang Merah worked hard to help the villagers, caring for those in need and redeeming herself through acts of kindness. Every night, she looked up at the sky, remembering the trials that had changed her and vowing never to return to the darkness of her past.

Her fate was no longer one of jealousy and hatred—but of redemption and love.

(Happy ending)

Once Bawang Merah got home, she immediately called her mom to open the pumpkin. Both of them were super excited, but in a wicked way, while Bawang Putih watched from another room with a suspicious look on her face.

When they finally split the pumpkin open, they were shocked to find not gold, but the grandma, who turned out to be a witch. The witch grandma already knew about Bawang Merah and her mom's evil plan and was ready to get her revenge. Without saying a word, she cursed Bawang Merah and her mom into becoming flightless bees.

After that, the witch grandma called Bawang Putih over gently. As Bawang Putih walked towards her, she accidentally stepped on her mom and Bawang Merah, who had turned into bees. The witch grandma just said, "Oopsie," and then magically transformed Bawang Putih into a stunning fairy. Now, Bawang Putih lives in the heavens as a beautiful fairy.

Bawang Merah, consumed by resentment, attempted to poison Bawang Putih, but her plan failed, and she fled with her mother in a small boat. However, the strong river currents overturned their boat, drowning them both and leaving Bawang Putih in sorrow. Despite all the pain they caused her, she still felt a sense of loss. From that day on, she regularly scattered white flowers into the river as a sign of mourning and an apology that would never be heard.