https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx Post your case analysis here - Include 1. Background 2. Legal Question before the Court 3. Decision by the Court 4. Impact of the decision en-us 2020-11-09 04:03:34 UTC 2025-07-11 04:22:03 UTC hello@padlet.com laymank1 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/912910034 Jefferson defeats Adams. Adams tries to pack the courts with new federal judges.  Federalists controlled the judiciary branch. Madison refused to grant the commissions that were left on his desk in March of 1801. William Marbury sued for his appointment.]]> 2020-11-11 14:29:44 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/912910034 laymank1 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/912911309 Deliver Marbury's commission?
Did the Court have jurisdiction under the Judic. Act of 1789?]]> 2020-11-11 14:30:01 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/912911309 laymank1 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/912912055 Turned down Marbury's request. 
No!]]> 2020-11-11 14:30:12 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/912912055 laymank1 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/912912224 Gives the Court the power of Judicial Review.]]> 2020-11-11 14:30:15 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/912912224 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/912998930 Do states have the right to tax divisions of the U.S. government like second national bank?]]> 2020-11-11 14:50:37 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/912998930 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/912999450 second national bank arose. charter for first bank not renewed bc people questioned constitutionality- didn't want to give national government too much power. "stamp tax" made to tax paper used for printing bank notes aimed at second national bank.]]> 2020-11-11 14:50:44 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/912999450 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/912999455 The case guaranteed protection of all types of contracts from government actions, benefiting the national economy and private corporations; states did not have authority over contracts underneath the constitution.]]> 2020-11-11 14:50:44 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/912999455 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913000484 Dartmouth College was given a grant by King George in 1769. Charter said 12 trustees would always run the college. New Hampshire legislature passed acts to make Dartmouth a state run college and add trustees. The board sued William Woodward. ]]> 2020-11-11 14:50:59 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913000484 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913000881 Georgia granted land to private investors, including John Peck who sold it to Robert Fletcher. After it was discovered that the Georgia legislators that passed this grant and the sale of land was void, Fletcher sued Peck for damages claiming that Peck lied when he said he had good title for the land.]]> 2020-11-11 14:51:04 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913000881 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913002627 Was the jurisdiction to place Dartmouth college under state control unconstitutional?]]> 2020-11-11 14:51:24 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913002627 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913003885 Ruled that the state of New Hampshire had violated the contract clause in an attempt to install a new board of trustees]]> 2020-11-11 14:51:41 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913003885 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913008376 The court ruled in favor of Parks that the repealing of land was unconstiutational and that it could not be repealed. The case was dismissed and the repeal of land was struck down. This set the precedent that the court had the power to enforce contracts states or the government engaged in.]]> 2020-11-11 14:52:45 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913008376 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913008791 Once a state finalizes the sale of land, is it Constitutional for that state to repeal the sale?]]> 2020-11-11 14:52:50 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913008791 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913011029 Georgia violated the Contract clause of the Constitution. Court ruled in favor of Peck, saying he was innocent.]]> 2020-11-11 14:53:19 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913011029 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913016012 It impacted the ability for state to regulate Native American lands and set the stage for Indian law in the US. Federal government determines if you can live on Native American land, not state government.]]> 2020-11-11 14:54:24 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913016012 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913017232 Georgia's law was unconstitutional and Native American land could not be regulated by the state.]]> 2020-11-11 14:54:40 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913017232 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913018294 Gibbons was sued for operating one of his ships in a bay between New Jersey and New York in which Ogden had an exclusive license. Gibbons was forced to forfeit his ship and then appealed this decision to the highest court in New York that had the jurisdiction to hear it. ]]> 2020-11-11 14:54:54 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913018294 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913018474 ruled in favor of McColluch
states do not have the right to tax agencies of the government, including banks]]> 2020-11-11 14:54:57 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913018474 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913021206 Do states have the right to impose regulations on Native Americans land?]]> 2020-11-11 14:55:32 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913021206 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913021410 Amerindians were being forced out of their land and attempted to live in Georgia. Andrew Jackson was the President and strongly supported kicking the Amerindians out. There was a law in Georgia that prevented citizens from going on Amerindian land without taking an oath of allegiance. Samuel Worcester did not follow the law and got arrested. He sued to the Supreme Court.]]> 2020-11-11 14:55:35 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913021410 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913021762 Could state legislatures pass laws that interfere with the free exchange of goods among states?
State's rights?]]> 2020-11-11 14:55:40 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913021762 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913027618 The court ruled in favor of Gibbons.]]> 2020-11-11 14:57:02 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913027618 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913033221 The decision impacted the national government's expansion of growth in the national economy. It enhanced congress' ability to promote westward expansion.]]> 2020-11-11 14:58:12 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913033221 https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913038000 This case established the supremacy that national institutions had over state ones. The states could not tax a federal institution like the National Bank]]> 2020-11-11 14:59:24 UTC https://padlet.com/garnetvalleyschooldistrict/46lay08ma1g5q7kx/wish/913038000