"The Monkey's Paw" LA 3 by Jennifer Bakaric https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71 *Put your name in the Title. 1-Tell if the film version stayed faithful (the same)to the text version, or if the film version departed (was different) from the text version. Explain your answer with specific examples. 2-Which version did you prefer and why? en-us 2018-11-02 14:55:47 UTC 2025-11-21 00:22:04 UTC hello@padlet.com Text vs. Film by Mary Tymchuk https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299858660 The film and text version were somewhat different from each other. The film followed lines from the text well, but didn't have as many details. The text includes a narrator to talk about the thoughts and feelings of the characters and adds more details. The film on the other hand, doesn't include as many details and scenes, so it was a little less interesting to watch. The text talks about two hundred pounds, and the film talks about three hundred. The film also shows the mother fainting when she found out her son passed away, but that didn't happen in the text.]]> 2018-11-02 15:56:33 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299858660 Text vs. Film Sarah Le https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299886433 The film version of "The Monkey Paw" is departed. At the beginning of the film it introduce Sergeant- Major Morris at an unknown place during the night. There were people around him saying a spell while the man in front of Morris started to move his hand in circle over a brown box. The old man give Morris the monkey paw, and Morris looked frighten. The rest of the video was the same like Herbert got caught in the machinery, and the part where Herbert father knows what is going to happen next if he bring his son alive. I would prefer the film version because it's more entertaining with the scary music in the background. I like part of the video where the parents found out that Herbert died in the machinery, and the part where Herbert mother fainted.]]> 2018-11-02 16:44:43 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299886433 Text v.s. Film by Abby Dahlberg https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299887086 The film of the "Monkey's Paw was slightly different than the story. In the article it states," 'I wish for two hundred pounds' "  (Jacobs 268). While this is said in the story version, in the film, it stated Mr. White wished for three hundred pounds. Another example of the film being different is stated in the article,"A cold wind rushes up the staircase, and a long loud wail of disappointment and misery from his wife gave him the courage to run down to her side'' ( Jacobs 278). This quote shows that the couple was very sad at the end, while in the film version it showed each character dead. I prefer the story version because it shows more details and descriptions.]]> 2018-11-02 16:46:07 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299887086 Movie V.S Text By Taylor Brown https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299889743 The film of "Monkey's Paw" was somewhat different than the text. The text will give you more information about what happened to everyone during the story, but the movie shows that they all die at the end of the story which was not in the text. I liked the text better because it was easier to see the foreshadowing]]> 2018-11-02 16:51:40 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299889743 Movie V.S. Story Allie Niehoff https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299891196 The film "Monkeys Paw" is somewhat different from the story. For example, some of the dialogue and parts of the story are slightly different. As it says in the text, "I wish for two hundred pounds"(Jacobs 268), in the film it says that the man wishes for three hundred pounds. Also in the film the whole family dies in the end in the story the husband and wife mourn the loss of their son, and that is the end of the story.]]> 2018-11-02 16:54:03 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299891196 MOVIE V.S STORY: Ryan Apuango https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299891444 The movie "The Monkey's Paw" is a little different from the text because in the film they say less words than the story. Such as when Boris wen to Herbert's house he didn't say all the words. Also in the story in didn'tt the husband and wife died. ]]> 2018-11-02 16:54:24 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299891444 Movie vs. Text - Hagan Schamberger https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299891672 The film of "The Monkeys Paw" had some noticeable differences compared to the text. The most distinct one was that the first wish was for three-hundred pounds instead of two-hundred pounds, as well as the payment from the Maw and Meggins company. Also, it showed the fakir placing the spell on the monkeys paw, then handing it to Sergeant Major-Morris. When reading the text, you had no perception of what "The Monkeys Paw" is supposed to represent. I think if someone reads the text and does not watch the short film, they would enjoy the whole concept of the monkeys paw much more, due to the poor acting.]]> 2018-11-02 16:54:46 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299891672 Nicolas Uribe https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299891813 The movie "The Monkey's Paw" was little different compared to the book.In the book it states"well,wish for 200 pounds,".(Jacobs 268)In the movie Herbert says 300 pounds.The movie version also states that the wind was making the knocking noise.In the story it states"Whats that? cried the old women,starting up.A rat.?(Jacobs 276)The story says its a rat not the wind.As you can see their both a bit different compared to each other.]]> 2018-11-02 16:55:02 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299891813 Reign Sosebee https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299892015 The movie of "The monkey's Paw" was different from the text. In the book the son touched the paw and shivered, but in the story that did not happen. Also at the end of the book only the son dies ,but in the movie everyone dies from asking the wishes. I prefer the book because the details in the book make it more interesting to read.]]> 2018-11-02 16:55:18 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299892015 Story V.S Movie https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299892296 Comparing and contrasting the film and text of "The Monkey's Paw", there are many differences shown. One example being between the story version was when they said, "'I wish for two hundred pounds,' said the old man distinctly." (W.W 268) Following up with the film version he said, "I wish for three hundred pounds." Based on these two pieces of evidence, readers or watchers can tell the difference. In the written story the characters asked for 200 pounds while in the film, the characters asked for 300 pounds.]]> 2018-11-02 16:55:42 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299892296 Text vs. Film Marianna Ramos https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299892463 The film "The Monkey's Paw" is different to the text. In the film it says that Mr.Whites first wish was 300 pounds however, in the text it said that he wished for 200 pounds. Another example is in the text only the son ends up dying, but in the film at the end it shows the sons gravestone, the mothers gravestone as well, and the father dead. I prefer the text over the film because in the text their is more description. ]]> 2018-11-02 16:55:55 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299892463 Ansley Pierce https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299892465 The film "The Monkey's Paw" is different to the text. The film creates the story to come to life, and it is easier to perceive the story line. One difference is that the numbers were off between the two. Also the movie just brings it all together,and answered all my questions I had about the story. ]]> 2018-11-02 16:55:55 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299892465 Movie vs. Story-Amy Lee https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299892649 The film of "Monkey's Paw" was departed from the text version. In the text, similar to the film, the first wish was for pounds. In the text, it had said 200 pounds. In the film, it had said 300 pounds. According to the text, it says, "Two hundred pounds,  was the answer" (Jacobs273). The text had a more descriptive way of showing the events taking place. But, the film wasn't as interesting and descriptive for the reader to take in. I prefer the text version because of its suspense that yearned me to read more of what's going on. ]]> 2018-11-02 16:56:14 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299892649 Ryder Glenn https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299892811 The movie of "Monkeys Paw" are different. In the movie It says 300 pounds and in the book it says 200 pounds. Another Example is it only says that the son died and in the film the mothers grave stone is right next to the sons with the father laying dead next to both of them. I prefer the movie it was way more enjoyable. ]]> 2018-11-02 16:56:31 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299892811 KYLE https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299892946 The movie of "Monkeys Paw" was different to the text version. In the book the it says the paw was thrown into the fire, but in the movie the dad held the soldiers hand. The movie showed more information about what happens to the family , but in the book it stopped when he did his third wish. I prefer the movie because you can see the action and visualize]]> 2018-11-02 16:56:45 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299892946 Text vs. Film Hector Gomez https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299894333
The film "The Monkey's Paw" did not stay faithful to the story because there were parts where the story said something and the movie did not show it. The son in the story, said that he didn't want to see the 200 pounds appear, but in the movie he never mention anything like that, it only showed the men announcing to the parents that he died and gave the 300 pounds. I preferred the movie because  it showed their emotions better than I imagined. It was even scarier then I imagined.]]> 2018-11-02 16:59:04 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299894333 Trevor Gutierrez https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299894780 The movie "Monkeys Paw" is different from the book because in the book the dad wishes for 200 pounds, but in the movie the dad wishes for 300 pounds.I say that the movie was better because i could watch and not read for me visual helps me comprehend.]]> 2018-11-02 16:59:56 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299894780 film vs. text -keilly rivera https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299894970 The film of "Monkeys Paw", was similar to the story in text. In the text it said he wished for two hundred pounds and in the film it said he wished for three hundred. I prefer reading the story because it has more detail and descriptions. And, the book is more interesting than the film, in my opinion. The film did have some actions that weren't in the text. Such as his mother fainting in the film and not in the text. They also say very less words in the film then they do in the story.]]> 2018-11-02 17:00:19 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299894970 https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299897807 2018-11-02 17:06:02 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299897807 Movie V.S. Story (Colton) colton_kersting9939 https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299897866 *Although not major, some lines of dialogue are changed in the movie version to make fit better as a film. EX: "A spell was cast. . ." VS "A curse was put. . . ."*
 The movie version of "The Monkey's Paw" departed mildly from the story version. First, the story describes Mr. and Mrs. White as being old, while in the film they appear as they are in their Late 30's. Second, in the film, a flashback showing when Morris first found the monkey's paw is shown, while in the story, no details are given whatsoever about Morris' first encounter with the paw. Last, in the film, it fast forwards to a year after the story ends. What is shown is very grim. We see Mrs. White's tombstone right next to Herbert's. Then, the camera draws back to reveal Mr. White, lying dead in front of the graves. We then switch to an overhead shot of the scene, which unveils that the monkey's paw atop of Mrs. White's grave.  Narration, presumably by Mr. White, then becomes audible. "It is finished," Mr. White narrates, "The retched paw is finished with us". I perfered the movie version, because more detail and insight is given to the lore of the story, and the epilogue took me by surprise, so the filmmakers did their job. ]]> 2018-11-02 17:06:09 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299897866 Test Vs. Film ℂ𝕖𝕕𝕣𝕚𝕔 𝕄𝕚𝕥𝕔𝕙𝕖𝕝𝕝 https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299900497  
The film version departed from the text version. First Mr. White wished for 200 hundred pounds but the film he wished for 300 hundred pounds. Also most noticeable the the text did not go in depth to what happened after Mr. White go rid of the dead Herbert. I like the film much better because I can picture it better. 
]]> 2018-11-02 17:11:31 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299900497 https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299902661 2018-11-02 17:16:07 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299902661 https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299902672 2018-11-02 17:16:08 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/299902672 Sus https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/2538745445 Sussus amongus sussy baka]]> 2023-03-30 17:31:53 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/43ey4xxiqg71/wish/2538745445