by

Mr. Potter

2014-02-20 15:39:20 UTC

Does doing bad things make you a bad person?

What if you were forced to do it? What if you had

no choice? Do you always have a choice?

javier

2014-02-20 16:04:20 UTC

no,because you are being forced to do something bad and even if you know what you are doing it can be that they are being therthend and if you dont do it you can get hurt.

Emily

2014-02-20 16:06:47 UTC

I think its both right and wrong and right ,bad:The reason cause its bad is because they PROBRABLY know right from wrong and HOPEFULLY they have self control for them to stop themselfs in any situation. Good:I think its good because they are protecting others so I think thats good.Okay, im finished writing,im bored now,im finished,BYE!!!!!!!!

Dakota

2014-02-20 16:07:15 UTC

I think they will be bad because they know what there doing and why they are doing it. so like if let's say that this guy named Billy wanted this other guy to rob the bank. what I would do is go tell someone, be the one that tells the bully to stop. Be the one that tells an adult. you should be the one that can stand up to the bully.
I also think that because you can go and tell you parents and if they don't believe in you than you go and tell the police person. So if you are in between being bully than you should stand up for you self or go tell someone like you princeiple.

Paul

2014-02-20 16:09:15 UTC

no i dont think doing something bad in this situation would make you a bad person because if somebody forces you to do something that you dont want to do and they gave you no say then its not your fault for instance if someone says sell these drugs and you say no and they try to kill you its not your fault.

cameron

2014-02-20 16:12:22 UTC

no i do not think doing bad thing make you a bad person because if you are forst under your will you don't have a choice. for an example if someone tells you to rob a bank

owen

2014-02-20 16:12:43 UTC

No, because you know you're the bad thing but you cant do the right thing or the person will severely injure you. But you don't have a choice to do the right thing

so you're forced to do the bad thing not the right thing. so i think if you're forced to do something but you don't want to do it so it doesn't make you a bad person.

Aidan

2014-02-20 16:12:58 UTC

just because you think you dont have a choice doesnt mean you have to take someones life . It can be hard to play god and decide bweeteen life and death but its beter to save someones life rather than take one .

maria

2014-02-20 16:17:16 UTC

Doing something bad makes you nor good nor bad. I think so because you know you

are doing something bad.But your life could be at steak

Cordelia

2014-02-20 16:19:29 UTC

No because... you are getting forced to do something very,very,very,bad .Even when you know what you are doing.

Ava

2014-02-20 16:21:20 UTC

I think it depends on the situation. If you are being threatened to either kill or be killed you should just die. Then, you might make an influence on other people and stop everything. If they are threatening to hurt your loved ones then that's a different story. If that's the situation then doing whatever your told is to protect someone therefore it is not bad. It all depends.

Kyle

2014-02-20 16:22:06 UTC

No, because someone's life could be

at risk, so what would you do? Risk someone's life, or

do one bad thing. Many innocent people are forced to

do something bad, but that's to protect other people's

lives. Which is more bad? Not doing something

and someone be killed, or stealing a few candy bars? There's

really no choice there. You have to remeber

they are still innocent.

daniela

2014-02-20 16:22:08 UTC

yes because you know what you are doing and you could stand up for yourself. And even if you died during the process you know you died doing something good. And you always have a choice to stand up for you or someone else.

Erandi

2014-02-20 16:22:54 UTC

Bad things make you bad people because if someone forces you to do something bad, you can stand up to them, and you will know what you're doing

Cassidy

2014-02-20 16:23:32 UTC

I belive that even if someone is forceing you to do something like go and kill your freind or you die. you can stand up for your self becuase you know what your doing, also you ALWAYS HAVE A CHOICE. you should never listen to a stranger anways. even if it your aunt or uncle you should not do what you know is bad but go ahead and die if you must.if you die you know you will go to heaven. what do you think good or bad. i think that even if you are held agenst your will you should do the right thing uh......... peace

Ashana

2014-02-20 16:27:57 UTC

It does not make you bad.I think it is not bad beacause

you are forced to do it .Like if somebody said they would hurt you(kill you). You kill them because you dont know them yet then run away!

XAVIER

2014-02-20 16:31:48 UTC

No because you do not have a choice what if someone told you that I am going to kill your family . Also you have someone point at you with a gun and harm you I will kill you .

Daniel

2014-02-20 16:41:36 UTC

yes it is bad because you know or

somebody you know is doing something bad

then you know you can stop it but you don`t!!!!!

$TEVEN

2014-02-20 16:44:08 UTC

it depends on the situation.

if someone said if you dont rob that person i will kill you and your family i would expect the person to do it . YOU DO HAVE A CHOICE BUT if you would rather have your family dead than give the crook what he\she want i find that messed up. Even if hes only threatening you no one would want there family going when will he be home, when will he be home and find out that there DEAD

or if someone comes to your house and tryies to rob and kill you its not the owner fault if he had to make a decision to protect their family even if it involes the guy not wakeing up for a LONG LONG time

THE END. :)

sydney

2014-02-20 16:45:48 UTC

dose doing bad things make you a bad person or a good person?

no because if someone is a good person and they wear pushed to do it

they cant do enything about it because they are being pushed to do it

jycir

2014-02-20 16:47:16 UTC

I think that if u are forced to do something that u are not supose to do

like this if your family is on the line and u have to kill somebody for no reason and i think it is not your fault and DOING SOMETING DOES NOT MAKE U A BAD PERSON!!!

Martelle

2014-02-20 19:57:36 UTC

No because if someone threatens to kill your family if you don't do something bad it isn't doing something bad it's protecting the ones you love.

Ciaran

2014-02-20 20:31:03 UTC

If you are

Forced to do

Something

Bad you

Are not a bad person

You were like forced to do it

It's like they said

If you don't

Do this bad thing I will hurt you

$teven 2

2014-02-20 20:36:47 UTC

Does lying make you a bad person?

Does using tobacco make you a bad person?

Does cussing make you a bad person?

These are all things we probably all seen people use/ do but are the bad people all of the things listen are not exactly good for you but just because people do it there not bad people.