Address to the Commonwealth Club of California" - qualitative analysis by Ms. Sarah Rebecca Altschul https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u Made with love en-us 2021-07-19 18:36:00 UTC 2026-01-12 17:15:14 UTC hello@padlet.com connerparkinson https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656284620 Meaning: 
- implications of being a migrant (why so many work on farms as opposed to in other jobs)
- concept of labor, worker's rights, etc.
- significance of political actions and achievements (voter's rights, citizenship, etc.)
- who is the target audience?

Structure:
- speech
- narrative
- 1st person, personal

Knowledge:
- geography
- history of racism and prejudice against migrants
- history of labor movements and organizations
- Bill of Rights

Language:
- figurative language ("beast of burden", "tunnel-vision")
- challenging vocabulary (ex. exploitation, mortality, malnutrition, irrigation)

]]> 2021-07-20 21:10:41 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656284620 estherjwong https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656285581 Vocabulary:
Tier 2: imported, freight train, tunnel vision, conversion, unidentified, savage, excrement, vicious
Tier 3: Bracero, harvesters, malnutrition, agricultural implements, racism, Chicano, union


Meaning: the weight of what he's saying (students may not be exposed to texts that show this level of injustice so explicitly -- important to learn how to navigate that and understand)

Structure: I didn't think it was too difficult to understand

Language: uses some words that students might not know, have to use context clues to understand (Braceros, excrement, agricultural implements, etc.)

Knowledge: students might not know the context of what he's addressing, especially if they didn't grow up in California (history of migrant farm workers in CA)]]> 2021-07-20 21:12:41 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656285581 jerico https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656286372 knowledge:
* social movements
*context behind worker unions + migration
*farming
*maps

meaning:
*identity and connection to own positionally related to the text (how do you relate or not relate to this text. what does that indicate?)
*injustice/oppression
*racialization + capitalism

structure:
*purpose behind this text
*what type of text is this?
*when was it written?
*how is it organized?
*audience?

language:
*wording? intentions behind words?
*is this metaphorical or is it retelling truths/stories?]]> 2021-07-20 21:14:26 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656286372 sarahncarter24 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656286500 meaning: importance of understanding 
Knowledge: knowing about the bracero program, the bill of rights, history of farm worker's civil rights
Language: some vocabulary words: implementation, inflation, 
Structure: starts with a narrative, then a description 
3 Terms: bracero, UFW, Chicano
2 terms: organizing, rights, union]]> 2021-07-20 21:14:42 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656286500 badu4151 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656286930 meaning: Being a migrant worker and the importance of organizing both urban and rural workers for fair rights.
knowledge: California history, implicit racism and bias.
language: Some words might be difficult to understand in context,(implements, excrement, exploit, malnutrition)
structure: A speech, narrative]]> 2021-07-20 21:15:31 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656286930 edies341 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287016 Language:
-context specific: Salinas, Bracero
-complex or unfamiliar: infant mortality, malnutrition, implements, chattel
Structure:
-features of the speech genre, like rhetorical questions
Knowledge:
-background for the context of the speech: who was Cesar Chavez? what is a union and what does it do?
Meaning:
-largely seems straightforward
-maybe more challenging to understand the last few paragraphs about why the UFW is "more than a union" - what is Chavez trying to say about the UFW? about unions?
-and what would be the counterarguments/what would Chavez's opponents say, and how is he responding to/preempting them?]]> 2021-07-20 21:15:36 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287016 Kamille https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287041 Knowledge: students might need background knowledge on unions / political organizing / civil rights movement / who was Caesar Chavez and what were the struggles of the farm workers?
-map of California

Meaning: It is a heavy subject and I think having background knowledge on the civil rights movement and Caesar Chavez would help 

Structure: I think the structure of a speech is nice and accessible--it is personal, not abstract and names specific grievances that students can grasp 

Language:  terms to define: Bracero
tunnel vision
chattel
exploit
urban vs. rural]]> 2021-07-20 21:15:39 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287041 lizardi_cassandra https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287126 Knowledge: needing to know who Cesar Chavez is, the bracero program, what organizing involves, knowledge on the labor & conditions of farm work

Structure: public speech

Meaning: figuring out/predicting the purpose of this speech. What "embarrassment" refers to

Language: "agricultural implements"? "beasts of burden"]]> 2021-07-20 21:15:51 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287126 itzelcmedina211 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287339 meaning: what is the purpose of this text? Is it only important for farm workers to know this history? What was the context of this speech? Who is it addressed to? 

knowledge: who is cesar chaves, who is the UFW, what is a chicano? what was the bracero program? 

language: organizing, unionizing, Anglo, abuse and exploitation 

structure: narrative ]]> 2021-07-20 21:16:20 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287339 lcroll1 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287342 knowledge: background on worker's conditions, specific facts/figures, incidents, details on living situations
 
meaning: the way his consciousness grew  from these surroundings, organizing grew from lived experience, and shared lived experience 

structure: speech (is rhetoric/rhythm  here?) 

language: rhetoric: use of repetition, "it grew, it grew..." , rhythm to text  uplifting tone , switch 1st person to 3 plural (i --> we) 

]]> 2021-07-20 21:16:21 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287342 yolandazacarias https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287427 Meaning: audience of this speech, the purpose of the speech, events that led up to this,
Knowledge: knowledge on Braceros, field workers/field workers rights (or lack of), migrant workers, Cesar Chavez, UFW, Salinas as an agricultural town, union strikes
Structure: speech, narrative
Language: exploitation, organizing, unionizing, "tunnel" vision]]> 2021-07-20 21:16:31 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287427 Key Questions addressing this text megan_odell1 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287599 knowledge- WHAT was the specific [location/time period/history/frame of reference] regarding... CA, Cesar Chavez, migrant farming industry+implications, Indigenous history, Immigrant history? WHERE/WHEN was this speech was given? WHO were his audiences?

meaning- WHAT is(are) Chavez's central point(s)? WHY did he give this speech? WHAT was his purpose/were his intended impacts? HOW were these initially received by his audience vs. how are they received now?

TIER II VOCAB: inflated, mortality, unionizing, Anglo, infamy

structure- HOW did Chavez organize his speech? WHAT are the commonly used organizational systems for organizing a "thesis" (a work that makes an argument,  i.e. Chavez's speech)

language- HOW did Chavez DELIVER his speech? What languages did he engage during the [development, drafts, planning, delivery] of this speech? Is there evidence [interviews, letters, photographs, video] out there of this process? HOW did his audience PERCEIVE/REACT to the speech?]]> 2021-07-20 21:16:49 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287599 Noam: https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287642 meaning: empower, inform, connect, represent, create change, organize, celebrate, pride, justice, community, care, love, overcome oppression, importance of unions
knowledge: Cesar Chavez history and advocacy, location,  time period/political and social context, migrant, immigration, history of child labor, activism/protest, field work, labor, labor rights, civil rights, Braceros
structure: speech, short paragraphs that can be connected and also independent, sentences that don't fit sentence constructs the way they are normally taught, spoken vs written English and reading vs listening, 
language: union, Braceros, UFW, War on poverty, 

]]> 2021-07-20 21:16:55 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287642 veronicaignao https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287749 Meaning: to understand experience 
Knowledge: time period, Northern 
& Southern California, Cesar Chavez, Braceros, migrant farm workers
Structure: narrative 
Language: unfamiliar terms, figurative language
Tier II: union, injustice, poverty, racism
Tier III: migrant, malnutrition, Bracero, chattel

]]> 2021-07-20 21:17:08 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287749 charlotteblanc https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287862 Meaning: 
- empower organizing efforts, power of organizing, celebration, continue the fight
Knowledge:
- Cesar Chavez, braceros, california history, history of mexican migrants, farm workers and their rights and working conditions historically, civil rights, bill of rights, what unions are
Structure:
- a speech, small parts of text, emotional
Language:
- farm workers, poverty, migrant, child labor, unions, organization]]> 2021-07-20 21:17:21 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287862 neyney_le https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287908 Meaning:
Language:
Knowledge:
-define Bracero
-give a quick bio about Cesar Chavez
Structure:]]> 2021-07-20 21:17:29 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287908 han19772 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287940 Meaning: Deciphering the purpose of this speech. Identifying the rhetorical questions and what their implied answers are.

Knowledge: Knowledge of the context, of who Chavez is, of what this was in response to.

Structure: Occasionally, Chavez swaps from one talking point to another, and if one were to miss the transition or not make the connection as to how the topics are related, that might make this piece difficult to follow. 

Language: There's some terms that stem from his background, so this and knowledge are connected. For instance, 'Bracero,' etc. Using context clues may help. You may not know exactly what a 'Bracero' is, but you might be able to get the gist. ]]> 2021-07-20 21:17:32 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656287940 latashataylor https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656288068 language. There are a lot of words I'm not sure all students will know. Without knowledge of the words it makes it hard to understand the context. There is also some data that I don't think students will have the vocabulary to interpret. ]]> 2021-07-20 21:17:45 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656288068 Stella: https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656288149 Meaning:
-audience
-lived experience

Knowledge: 
-some California history and geography
-what a union is (history of organizing and labor laws)
-migrant workers/migration
-Bracero 

Structure:
-anecdote 

Language: the difference between 25% higher and 10 times higher (just the way we use these numbers to understand proportions and statistics)]]> 2021-07-20 21:17:54 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656288149 sgoetz7 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656288453 meaning: the elaboration on Chavez's dream may be confusing to students because he uses "It" to refer back to the dream
knowledge: what unions are and the purpose of organizing, how migrant workers are treated, who Cesar Chavez is, Bill of Rights
purpose:
language: hand-outs, infamy,   Braceros
chattel

2nd Tier Words: inflated, exploit, condemn, infamy

3rd Tier Words: organize/organizing, discrimination, union, hand-outs, Bracero]]> 2021-07-20 21:18:35 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656288453 kelinsophia https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656288468 Meaning: The text immediately jumps into descriptions of workers' conditions and initially allows students to infer Chavez' goal to make sense of these examples before he provides his call to action. Students can also apply the meaning of this text to continuing conditions and consider the significance of the text during the time it was written and today. 
Structure: The text is organized in a way that first introduces examples of working conditions and then reveals Chavez' call to action. It furthermore layers general experiences and examples with Chavez' own personal experiences and dream of change.
Knowledge: Students can apply background knowledge surrounding who Cesar Chavez is, rural working conditions, unions, and more.
Language: Words and sentences vary in both length and complexity.

Tier 2 words: excrement, implements, exploit
Tier 3 words: Bracero, inflated, union]]> 2021-07-20 21:18:37 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656288468 jindi_zhang https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656288727 meaning: has meaning to those who might have personal meaning to struggling or resisting or seeing their parents labor being exploited and being angry
structure: Speech
language: 
tier 2: nurtured, humiliation, condemned, savage, malnutrition
tier 3: union, exploit, organizing
knowledge: the braceros, union, United Farm Workers, Commonwealth Club of Cali, Cesear Chavez

]]> 2021-07-20 21:19:07 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656288727 Meaning: jjuarezm1 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656288806 Language: organizing, government agency, irrigation pumps, agricultural implements, organizing, child labor, union, malnutrition
Structure: 
Knowledge: purpose of unions, bracero program, Cesar Chavez, ]]> 2021-07-20 21:19:14 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656288806 jasmin_espinoza1 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656288929 Meaning: historical implications, the importance of the address

Structure: length, lots of points being made one after another, 

Language: vocab, figurative language

knowledge: math concepts to understand the data given, the UFW, history of labor, labor laws

Vocab:
Tier 2:converted, exploit, organizing
Tier 3:Braceros, migrant worker, union

]]> 2021-07-20 21:19:32 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656288929 frank_klopotowski https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656289164 Meaning: The reality of lived experiences for farm workers and the importance of organizing in empowering Chicano people.
Knowledge: the Bracero program in CA, history/purpose of unions,
Structure: attention, problem, solution, visualization, action
Language: some words might need explanation/historical context, use of repetition and rhetorical devices ]]> 2021-07-20 21:19:56 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656289164 mchen11998 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656289293 meaning: "tunnel vision -> what are they actually saying? there are technically three layers: the Braceros case, the broad concept of farm workers, and Cesar Chavez + UFW
language: Longer sentences than they might be used to, inclusion of rhetorical questions (intent of the rhetorical questions) 
structure: Transition from the case to broader terms, then the connection to Chavez himself and the questions knowledge: geographical (where is Salinas/101), who is Chavez, what is a union/UFW

Tier II: converted, excrement, malnutrition, exploit, empower, condemn, infamy

Tier III: union,  agricultural implements, chattel, Bracero, social movement, War on Poverty]]> 2021-07-20 21:20:12 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656289293 madelynbrauer https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656289328 Meaning: 
- understand the positionally of farm workers
-Cesar Chavez
- UFW Unions, organization
-Migrant workers
Knowledge:
-the abject conditions of many California farm workers 
Structure: narrative, speech 
Language: 
-understanding who Cesar Chavez was + civil rights
]]> 2021-07-20 21:20:17 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656289328 vanessaveronica14 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656289336 Meaning: highlights the importance of organizing efforts, implications of being a migrant worker
Structure: narrative, written in first person
Language: There are some vocabulary terms that may be difficult for students to comprehend.
Knowledge: location, time period, Bracero Program, who Cesar Chavez is, civil rights, unions]]> 2021-07-20 21:20:18 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656289336 aywang10 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656289522 Structure: understanding where this argument is headed (why he is talking about a car crash one moment and then life expectancy the next), being able to see the three overarching chunks, how footnotes work
Knowledge: context about when 1984 was, how unions work/what organize means in this context, Bracero program, the Civil Right movement, geography of Salinas/CA/Mexico, that child labor is illegal, how to compare mortality rates (what does 25% more mean)
Language: vocabulary like Bracero, excrement, chattel, exploit, infamy; noticing the use of "imported" to emphasize the dehumanization
Meaning: that this is a speech (who are the Commonwealth Club? would it be an audience he has to convince? or just celebrating successes?) What is the point he is trying to make?]]> 2021-07-20 21:20:37 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656289522 johnwlarsen https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656289854 Meaning:
Needed: An understanding of who Cesar Chavez and the UFW are, what was going on more broadly in history at this time
Language:
  • Vocab:
    • TIER III: Bracero
    • TIER II: “Tunnel” vision
      • Idiom
    • TIER II: Savage / vicious
      • This also builds on tone, purpose, rhetoric
  • TIER II: Inflated prices
  • TIER III: Child labor
  • TIER III: life expectancy
  • TIER II?: agricultural implements
  • TIER II?: Beasts of burden
  • TIER III: Chattel
    • also, metaphorically used
  • TIER III: Anglo.
  • TIER II: Humiliation.
  • TIER II: Condemned
  • TIER II: Exploit
  • Grammar: colons
    • “All my life, I have been driven by one dream, one goal, one vision: To overthrow a farm labor system in this nation which treats farm workers as if they were not important human beings.”
Structure:
  • Persuasive speech
  • “tomatoe fields which use the most modern farm technology.”
    • Rhetorically, placed in a way that draws a juxtaposition, but isn’t obvious about it
  • Rhetorical questions
Knowledge:
  • Migrant workers
  • "state-conducted union elections" / unions
  • Math literacy:
    • 30 percent
    • 25 percent
  • Infant mortality rate / Malnutrition / mortality rate
  • Racism
  • Civil Rights history
    • “in an era when Black Americans were just beginning to assert their civil rights and when political awareness among Hispanics was almost non-existent.”
  • the Bill of Rights.
  • the War on Poverty.
]]> 2021-07-20 21:21:17 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656289854 rmveenstra1 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656289902 Meaning: the weight of being a person of color, specifically a migrant farm worker or a family member of one. Encouraging people to take action to liberate these people
Structure: pretty short "paragraphs" - tend to be only 1-3 sentences. Easier to digest this way, especially for 7th graders.
Language: Sentences are pretty short and clear, not much figurative language, pretty straight forward.
Knowledge: I don't know if 7th graders know much about organizing or unions, so the last page/part of the speech may be harder to understand. Probably need some context/background knowledge on unions. Some other words/phrases 7th graders might not know: Braceros, tunnel vision, infant mortality, agricultural implements]]> 2021-07-20 21:21:25 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656289902 Gustavo https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656289990 Language]]> 2021-07-20 21:21:38 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656289990 jonotsteve https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656290641 Structure: The format is fragmented into a bullet point type of narrative.
language: using language that have been associated with different eras and rhetorics that allude to dehumanization.
Knowledge: Schemas that relate to social injustices and civil rights.
Meaning: connects to the dehumanization of specific events and specific groups.]]> 2021-07-20 21:22:53 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656290641 Chavez and Text Complexity https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656290886 (Shellie)

Meaning:
-"tomatoe fields which use the most modern farm technology" (layers of meaning)

Language:
-"Braceros" (regional dialect)

Structure:
-repetition of "How..?" (text structure)

Knowledge: 
-"U.S. Highway 101 near Salinas" (knowledge of location/local area)]]> 2021-07-20 21:23:23 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656290886 fefeyamaguchi https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656290890 Meaning: Can be difficult as students are not given an explicit purpose / meaning behind this text; it demands them to be critical & think deeply about what the text is trying to convey and why they are reading it in the first place.
Language: Vocabulary, sentence length and sentence structure can all pose as a roadblock to some students (e.g. "Braceros" and non-defining clauses)]]> 2021-07-20 21:23:24 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656290890 ahrin1 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656290919 Meaning: 
structure: Sentences are mostly direct and not very long. Paragraphs are short. Speech!!
language: Vocabulary (ex: life expectancy, overthrow, flourish ). figurative language (ex: Vicious rats gnaw on them as they sleep.)
knowledge: Cesar Chavez, United Farm Workers, historical context, political context]]> 2021-07-20 21:23:27 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656290919 Knowledge: abmp1781 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656290965 Having background knowledge of the issue.
What do the numbers mean?

Meaning:
Understanding vocabulary
Understanding tone and imagery
 (ex. What is tunnel vision?)
What is speaker's purpose of this text?
How do students relate to the numbers in terms of picturing quantity
Learning more of migrant farmers

Structure:  Fragmented, easy sentences



]]> 2021-07-20 21:23:34 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656290965 cnguy5 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656290981 Knowledge:
- how unions work, cesar chavez, context on 1984, immigrant workers in the US, 
Language:
- bracero
Meaning:
- goal, actionable item
Structure:
- personal narrative view, I statements]]> 2021-07-20 21:23:37 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656290981 jaceydelatorre https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656291021 Meaning: situating the identities invoked (Chicano, Bracero, farm workers) in a historical context.
Knowledge: specific places and phenomena, such as unionism, civil rights, Salinas, UFW, San Jose, etc.
Structure: understanding what type of text this is (address/speech) and why that is important.

Tier 2: racism, crops, minority, injustice, overthrow, farm

Tier 3: exploit/exploitation, agricultural, union, election, War on Poverty, UFW, labor system, Bracero

]]> 2021-07-20 21:23:43 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656291021 nmflores16 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656291091 knowledge: background on Bracera program, the larger Chicanx movement, the UFW movement, historical context as a social movement alongside and with other freedom struggles, background on Cesar Chavez and his legacy. 

Structure: genre (speech), audience (what is the Commonwealth Club of CA?)

Language: figurative language, rhetorical strategies]]> 2021-07-20 21:23:52 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656291091 zanderrounds1 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656291186 Tier II
Exploit, Organize, Farm Workers

Tier III
Union

Knowledge - histories of civil rights, organizing, unions
Structure - no marked demarcations of sections (e.g. subheaders)
Language - Vocab words
Meaning - goals / audience?]]> 2021-07-20 21:24:05 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656291186 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656291235 Meaning: The oppression of Mexican American and Migrant farm workers as well as the historical struggle taken upon them.

Language: Written in English. Vocab-Union, Bill of Rights, exploitation

Structure: Short paragraphs, well spaced out.

Knowledge: Braceros, History of the UFW]]> 2021-07-20 21:24:12 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656291235 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656292407 Structure: Shift from speaking on issue to speaking about personal experience is sudden.

Knowledge: Bracero, unions, issues/oppressions faced by farm laborers]]> 2021-07-20 21:26:44 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656292407 cieloaguirre https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656292482 Language: chattel, excrement, beasts of burden
Structure: speech, rhetorical questions
Meaning: racism, discrimination
Knowledge: inflated prices, Braceros, United Farm Workers, War on Poverty]]> 2021-07-20 21:26:55 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656292482 alicia_lopez7 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656292918 Knowledge: Info on Chavez, reasoning behind the opening story, context of the region, context of the times, child labor laws implemented before 1984
Meaning: inequality, racism, class differences
Tier II: experience, organize
Tier III: Bracero, child labor, racial discrimination

]]> 2021-07-20 21:27:47 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1656292918 Vocabulary aywang10 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658623906 Tier III: organize, union, migrant
Tier II:  exploit, child labor, vicious, conditions]]> 2021-07-22 20:17:42 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658623906 madelynbrauer https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624094 Tier III: Bracero, exploitation, UFW,
Their II: farm workers, ]]> 2021-07-22 20:18:04 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624094 yolandazacarias https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624317 Tier II: inflated, tunnel vision
Tier III: Bracero, migrant, United Farm Workers/UFW, injustice, child labor, exploit]]> 2021-07-22 20:18:21 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624317 Vocabulary edies341 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624361 Tier II: malnutrition, implements, chattel, exploitation
Tier III: Bracero, migrant, organizing]]> 2021-07-22 20:18:25 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624361 Vocabulary fefeyamaguchi https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624443 Tier II: inflated, mortality, chattel, exploit / exploitation, assert, irrigation
Tier III: Braceros, union, Commonwealth]]> 2021-07-22 20:18:34 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624443 Tier I and Tier II itzelcmedina211 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624489 Tier I :
Paralleling 
tragic
Conversion
"tunnel vision"
savage conditions
amid
inflated prices



Tier II:
Bracero 
irrigation pumps
state conducted 
union elections 
infant mortality
chattel 
expoitation]]> 2021-07-22 20:18:38 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624489 vocab stella_ray https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624666 Tier 2: Anglo, organizing, excrement
Tier 3: Bracero, unions,  Chicano, migrant, child labor

]]> 2021-07-22 20:18:46 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624666 connerparkinson https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624675 Tier 2:
paralleling
conversion
excrement
irrigation
gnaw
mortality rate
implements
inflated prices


Tier 3:
Bracero
grower
labor system
chattel
Anglo
organizing
discrimination
social movement
union
War on Poverty]]> 2021-07-22 20:18:47 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624675 Vocab neyney_le https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624676 Tier II:
-converted
-farm workers

Tier III: 
-imported
-tunnel vision
-migrant
-agricultural implements
-exploit]]> 2021-07-22 20:18:47 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624676 Tier III Words: government agency, inflated prices, union, labor system, exploitation menaka_gentle https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624723 2021-07-22 20:18:49 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624723 vanessaveronica14 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624758 Tier II: paralleling, conversion, inflated
Tier III: Bracero, migrant workers, United Farm Workers, child labor]]> 2021-07-22 20:18:53 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624758 lcroll1 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624930 Tier II paralleling , exploitation, racial
discrimination, injustice  

Tier III  Braceros, union (UFW) organizing, migrant workers, 

]]> 2021-07-22 20:19:18 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624930 nmflores16 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624952 tier 2: conversion, savage, irrigation, organizing, flourished

tier 3: bracero, inflated prices]]> 2021-07-22 20:19:20 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658624952 Vocabulary jjuarezm1 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658625010 Tier II: government agency, tunnel vision, excrement,
Tier III: braceros, United Farm Workers, union, ]]> 2021-07-22 20:19:30 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658625010 Vocabulary https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658625026 (Shellie)

Tier 3: agricultural; migrant; union; organize; exploit; racism; shame]]> 2021-07-22 20:19:32 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658625026 jonotsteve https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658625049 tier 2: paralleling, conversion, amid, gnaw, savage, excrement, 

tier 3: Bracero, government agency, employed, inflated, irrigation, state-conducted, union election, infant mortality]]> 2021-07-22 20:19:34 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658625049 vocab badu4151 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658625221 tier 2- imfamy, migrant, excrement
tier 3-malnutrition, exploitation, conditions-beneath, rage-emotions, braceros, United Farm Workers]]> 2021-07-22 20:19:55 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658625221 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658625548 Gaby
Tier 2:
 overthrow
discrimination
politics
Tier 3: 
bracero
migrant 
worker]]> 2021-07-22 20:20:27 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658625548 (Jonah) https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658625620 Teir 3
-Bracero
-Migrant
-United Farm Workers(UFW)
-Injustice
-Union

]]> 2021-07-22 20:20:38 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658625620 Vocabulary ahrin1 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658626009 Tier 2: labor, agricultural
Tier 3: racial discrimination, harvester, injustice]]> 2021-07-22 20:21:24 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658626009 abmp1781 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658626123 Tier 2:
inflated
implements
exploit

Tier 3
Braceros
Union 
migrant workers

]]> 2021-07-22 20:21:40 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658626123 vocab lkflores1 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658626467 tier 2: bodies, labor system, racism
tier 3: migrant, urban, bracero ]]> 2021-07-22 20:22:16 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658626467 cnguy5 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658626695 Tier III:
- bracero
- migrant
- minority
- chicano
- anglo

Tier II:
- union
- exploitation
- labor]]> 2021-07-22 20:22:43 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658626695 vocab words jerico https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658627370 tier ii
* tragic
*conversion
*unidentified
*employed
*savage
*inflated
*harvester
*malnutrition
*human beings
*beasts of burden
*nurture
*humiliation
*politics
*minority

tier iii
*Braceros
*labor
*union election
*workers
*migrant workers
*labor system
*racism
*chattel
*exploit/exploitation
*empower
*voter registration
*racial discrimination 
*War on Poverty]]> 2021-07-22 20:23:48 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658627370 han19772 https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658627383 Tier 2: 
Tragic, Savage, Migrant, Malnutrition

Tier 3
Braceros, union,

]]> 2021-07-22 20:23:49 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658627383 FinneganNatale https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658627494 Tier 2:
excrement
amid

Tier 3:
Bracero
freight train
irrigation pumps
beast of burden]]> 2021-07-22 20:24:03 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658627494 madelynbrauer https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658628008 Tier III: Bracero, exploitation, UFW, anglo, chicano 
Their II: farm workers, labor, migrant

]]> 2021-07-22 20:24:54 UTC https://padlet.com/sarahaltschul/3dmdv02ubgu6h97u/wish/1658628008