Task: Fact vs. Fake News

1. Find a news article online.

2. Discuss in your group (4 students per group):

   • Identify the characteristics of the news article.

   • Decide if the article is factual or fake.

   • Provide an explanation for your decision.

3. Complete the following:

   • Group Name:

   • News Characteristics:

   • Fact or Fake? Explain:

4. Upload the news link.

-Dzaki

-Aimar

-Radith

-Azzaki

News Characteristics:

Source: CNN, a credible and reputable news outlet.

Author: Jennifer Agiesta and Ariel Edwards-Levy (listed in the article).

Publication Date: October 25, 2024.

Supporting Evidence: The article cites poll data conducted by SSRS, including sample size, methodology, and margin of error. Specific details and percentages are provided, reflecting rigorous analysis.

Bias or Sensationalism: The tone appears analytical, focusing on data-driven insights rather than emotional or exaggerated claims.

Fact or Fake?: Fact. The article provides verified polling data, transparent methodology, and balanced reporting. CNN’s credibility and the use of SSRS, a reputable research organization, further support its factual nature.

News Link: https://www.cnn.com/2024/10/25/politics/cnn-poll-harris-trump/index.html

https://www.canva.com/design/DAGW1xtWDmA/vGuesquJpLw_mhyikodoAg/edit?utm_content=DAGW1xtWDmA&utm_campaign=designshare&utm_medium=link2&utm_source=sharebutton

• Marsanda Ayu D. (18)

• M. Ihsan Firdaus (20)

• M Aditya R.H (21)

  
  

  https://www.canva.com/design/DAGW1G3749A/62TxWHQIGMKJaD8HefPAXA/edit?utm_content=DAGW1G3749A&utm_campaign=designshare&utm_medium=link2&utm_source=sharebutton

- Fikra Arisna (11)

- Leyina Fildza (16)

- Marsanda Ayu Darmawan (18)

- Nabila Nur Sabrina (26)

News Characteristics :

• Source : CNN

• Author : Esha Mitra, Aishwarya S Iyer and Helen Regan

• Publication Date : 1:38 AM EST, Thu November 21, 2024

• Supporting Evidence : The article discusses the severe air pollution in Delhi, highlighting the establishment of clinics for pollution-related illnesses and personal reports from affected residents, including the increase in respiratory problems and the government's response to the crisis. There are also photos of conditions in India within a period of 4 days.

• Bias or Sensationalism : The text leans toward dramatic depictions, evoking an emotional response at the expense of balanced reporting like the phrase "Throat-searing blanket of toxic smog" exaggerating the impact. A more neutral tone with a comprehensive view of efforts and challenges would improve objectivity.

• Fact or Fake : Fact, the article is based on real events and provides credible information about air pollution in Delhi.

• News link : https://www.cnn.com/2024/11/20/india/delhi-pollution-clinic-smog-climate-intl-hnk/index.html

• Fila Dalila (10)

https://www.canva.com/design/DAGXR9dkbhw/M0X-N9XPM_-JqhY6N7cC4w/edit?utm_content=DAGXR9dkbhw&utm_campaign=designshare&utm_medium=link2&utm_source=sharebutton

• Altha (04)

• Agdu (06)

• Lu'lu (17)

• Nayla (27)

• Zilfia (36)

1. Lu’lu Fathiyatur Rizqoh (17)

2. Nayla Muhbita Rahardian (27)

3. Sasrani (34)

4. Zilfia Qolbina (36)

News Characteristics:

- Source: BBC

- Author: Tom Gerken

- Publication Date: November 7th, 2024

- Supporting Evidence: The article provides supporting evidence, such as the mention of Ofcom's findings and the specific changes Roblox is implementing. It also cites Roblox's official statement.

- Bias or Sensationalism: The article appears to be relatively unbiased and factual. It presents both the concerns about Roblox's safety and Roblox's efforts to improve it. The article appears to contain some sensationalism. This is evident in phrases like "some have complained they have been exposed to upsetting and harmful content" without clear details or examples of the complaints. This might exaggerate concerns for emotional impact.

- Fact or fake: Fact, because the article comes from BBC News, a widely recognized and reputable news outlet with a strong track record of reliable reporting. The content aligns with current discussions around online safety and Roblox's role as a platform catering to young users. Furthermore, the updates mentioned (e.g., safety measures for under-13s) are consistent with Roblox's publicly stated initiatives to improve user safety, adding credibility to the report. The article also includes statements from Roblox, which helps substantiate the claims about the new safety measures and the company's stance on improving user safety. Roblox’s statement about transparency and its ongoing efforts in safety shows a degree of reliability in the reporting.

- News Link:

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwy9kry4lvko

Group members:

• Fadilah Yasin (09)

• Moh Fariz Zakariya (19)

• Muhamad Ihsan Firdaus (20)

• Nabil Razan Muhammad Ihsan (25)

News Caracteristics:

• Source: ESPN

• Author: Ryan Haley

• Title: Duke basketball remains second in the ESPN Basketball Power Index after Arizona win

• Publication Date: November 23, 2024

• Supporting Evidence:

  The article cites the ESPN Basketball Power Index (BPI) rankings, which are based on a complex statistical model that considers factors like team performance, strength of schedule, and other relevant metrics.

• Bias or Sensationalism:

  The article appears to be relatively neutral, presenting factual information about Duke's ranking and recent performance.

• Fact or Fake:

  The news is factual and based on the ESPN BPI rankings, which are widely recognized as a reliable source of college basketball information.

• News Link: https://dukewire.usatoday.com/2024/11/23/duke-basketball-espn-bpi-update-arizona-win/

Abdurrahman Azzaki (01)

Ghailan Alfarezi (12)

Muhammad Faris Z.M (19)

Nabil Razan M.I (25)

Link Project:

https://www.canva.com/design/DAGW1bgawlY/X0-9aHlhgB7yXo5DkCxy4Q/edit

Haifa Maulafida F

Hilma Nur Wildatinnisa Nuriza Haniyah

Siti Fatimah Az-zahra Rumaisyah Dzakiyyah

Link Project:

https://www.canva.com/design/DAGW1DLhG20/BvgyTyHI1U-8x34dz_3_yQ/edit?utm_content=DAGW1DLhG20&utm_campaign=designshare&utm_medium=link2&utm_source=sharebutton

Az-zahra Agdu Maharani(6)

Hilma Nur Wildatinnisa(14)

Nuriza Haniyah (29)

News Characteristics :

Source: BBC News

Author: James Fitz Gerald

Title: Just How Big was Donald Trump's Election Victory?

Publication date: 23 November 2024

Bias or sensationalism : The article explains Trump’s win using facts like vote counts and Electoral College results. It questions his claim of a "landslide" victory, saying the margins in key states were small. Words like "grandiose" show some doubt about his narrative. The focus on close results and critiques of his claims shows a slight bias, but the article isn’t exaggerated or dramatic. It’s mostly based on facts, but some parts are not completely neutral.

Supporting Evidence : The article provides several pieces of supporting evidence to evaluate Trump’s 2024 election victory:

1. Electoral College Win: Trump secured 312 Electoral College votes, surpassing the 270 needed but falling short of historic high marks like Ronald Reagan's 525 in 1984.

2. Popular Vote Share: Trump received 76.9 million votes, more than Kamala Harris, but fell below 50% of total votes, questioning claims of a mandate.

3. Swing State Margins: Critical wins in states like Pennsylvania were by narrow margins, highlighting the Electoral College's amplifying effect.

Fact or Fake: Fact, the news is factual according to a votes. As we can see in the articel, the votes had a trusted source by US Federal Electoral Commision, NEP/Edision via Reuters

News link :

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cn5w9w160xdo

Az-zahra Agdu Maharani

Hilma Nur Wildatinnisa

Nuriza Haniyah

News Characteristics :

Source: BBC News

Author: James Fitz Gerald

Title: Just How Big was Donald Trump's Election Victory?

Publication date: 23 November 2024

Bias or sensationalism : The article explains Trump’s win using facts like vote counts and Electoral College results. It questions his claim of a "landslide" victory, saying the margins in key states were small. Words like "grandiose" show some doubt about his narrative. The focus on close results and critiques of his claims shows a slight bias, but the article isn’t exaggerated or dramatic. It’s mostly based on facts, but some parts are not completely neutral.

Supporting Evidence : The article provides several pieces of supporting evidence to evaluate Trump’s 2024 election victory:

1. Electoral College Win: Trump secured 312 Electoral College votes, surpassing the 270 needed but falling short of historic high marks like Ronald Reagan's 525 in 1984.

2. Popular Vote Share: Trump received 76.9 million votes, more than Kamala Harris, but fell below 50% of total votes, questioning claims of a mandate.

3. Swing State Margins: Critical wins in states like Pennsylvania were by narrow margins, highlighting the Electoral College's amplifying effect.

Fact or Fake: Fact, the news is factual according to a votes. As we can see in the articel, the votes had a trusted source by US Federal Electoral Commision, NEP/Edision via Reuters

News link :

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cn5w9w160xdo