IRWS by https://padlet.com/oliverfrensch/2b462g96j4si464d Considering a good literature review en-us 2022-08-31 09:07:20 UTC 2022-08-31 10:16:40 UTC hello@padlet.com Contribution to existing literature oliverfrensch https://padlet.com/oliverfrensch/2b462g96j4si464d/wish/2277477994 The author clearly mentions the four branches of research she is contributing to and summarizes them in one to two sentences each.

The research gap is clear due to the novelty of the instrument and she clearly distinguishes her work from a previous study concerned with the same instrument.

The LR is quite short which seems like a big pro as literature is summarized by their common results]]> 2022-08-31 09:19:50 UTC https://padlet.com/oliverfrensch/2b462g96j4si464d/wish/2277477994 Pros & Cons mfreund16 https://padlet.com/oliverfrensch/2b462g96j4si464d/wish/2277481167
- well defined research question and research gap
- hypothesis are derived from literature
- authors emphasize their contribution
- understandably written

- now the literature is not up-to-date]]> 2022-08-31 09:24:06 UTC https://padlet.com/oliverfrensch/2b462g96j4si464d/wish/2277481167 nataliaphilipp https://padlet.com/oliverfrensch/2b462g96j4si464d/wish/2277490932 Pros

well structured - starts with a key definition, an illumination of the importance of the subject; key literature has been mentioned and critically evaluated - a gap identified 
the goal of the study is clear enough

literature review is divided into subchapters with good headings

red threat

a good line of argument
convincing arguments

a gap identified - the contribution of the research is clear to the reader; 

the importance of the subject and of the research question has been well explained

argumentation is clear and convincing

good reading flow


cons

too long
several gaps
perhaps a summery is needed




]]> 2022-08-31 09:36:57 UTC https://padlet.com/oliverfrensch/2b462g96j4si464d/wish/2277490932 A Review of Machine Learning Methods Applied to Structural Dynamics andVibroacoustic ernstnathanaelwinter https://padlet.com/oliverfrensch/2b462g96j4si464d/wish/2277492273 The Abstract states the areas that are covered by the review

-Machine Learning Literature state of the art

-SHM 
-Active Control powered by Machine Learning
-Vibroacoustic Product Design by Physics-Driven
Surrogates

On Future Trends and Perspectives:
-Digital Twins
-Physics Guided Machine Learning
-Research gaps and emerging opportunities]]> 2022-08-31 09:39:04 UTC https://padlet.com/oliverfrensch/2b462g96j4si464d/wish/2277492273 ernstnathanaelwinter https://padlet.com/oliverfrensch/2b462g96j4si464d/wish/2277516472 2022-08-31 10:15:27 UTC https://padlet.com/oliverfrensch/2b462g96j4si464d/wish/2277516472 ernstnathanaelwinter https://padlet.com/oliverfrensch/2b462g96j4si464d/wish/2277516844 2022-08-31 10:16:05 UTC https://padlet.com/oliverfrensch/2b462g96j4si464d/wish/2277516844