HRBAD seminar padlet by Manu Klimis https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj comment on the principles or the discussions en-us 2021-12-14 08:29:03 UTC 2021-12-15 09:20:43 UTC hello@padlet.com equity instead of equality? https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946486939 2021-12-14 09:04:29 UTC https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946486939 Importance to engage in long term perspectives for such changes (being aware we must show results) https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946502300 2021-12-14 09:14:06 UTC https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946502300 need for clear "terms and conditions" with duty bearers (political dialogue key) and concrete applications (benchmarks) to avoid "misunderstandings"/ non implication on HRBA.... long process https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946511722 2021-12-14 09:19:52 UTC https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946511722 Difference between empowerment and capacity-building? https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946537705 2021-12-14 09:36:20 UTC https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946537705 so you could say 'empowerment' has a more political notion compared with capacity building https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946544007 2021-12-14 09:40:13 UTC https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946544007 integrating HRBAD seems quite impossible, too much expectations. How can a partner answer to all these challenges ? a HRBAD analysis can discourage any partner to go through this approach... https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946548446 2021-12-14 09:42:52 UTC https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946548446 Tkx for this presentation. To concretize a bit the MEET principles I think it's useful wen designing a program to refer to the specific recommendations of the UN or Regional Human Rights Institutions (eg : the Human Rights Committee, the Committee on ESC Rights, the Committee on the Rights of Children, etc.) and the many concrete recommendations of the Special Rapporteurs. Those are valuable information to holds durty bearers accountable. https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946549768 2021-12-14 09:43:44 UTC https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946549768 Social movements play an important role in this regard, as they tend to reach out to and organise people in vulnerable conditions in societies. Moreover, this has the advantage of collective empowerment and therefore collective action. Groups do find it seasier to stand up for their rights, compared to individuals (espacially those who are very exposed to multiple vulnerabilities). https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946551506 2021-12-14 09:44:47 UTC https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946551506 How we frame concepts is super important. CSOs and groups from the global south have long argued that Intl. Cooperation actors don´t "build capacities" - as that implies a baseline where capacities do no exist. Capacities are there and all the groups we aim to support do have many capacities to address their problems and needs and struggle for their rights, already before our projects target them... "Capacity strengthening" is a more fair concept. Besides, in many cases our target groups are already empowered as well, just lack the material means (in many cases just economic, but also protection/safety, access to intl. mechanisms, etc.) to advance their struggles. Very, very important to carefully frame all these concepts. Greetings from PI. https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946557495 2021-12-14 09:48:48 UTC https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946557495 Both for meaningful participation and accountability, it is important to to acknowledge and promote the narrative of meaningful and structural interaction between 3 key stakeholders in any given society: the state, the private (for profit) sector and civil society. The study now speaks of 'accessible mechanisms'; in research undertaken by HIVA, a call is made for institutionalised forms of dialogue where these 3 actors can effectively interact with one another on issues of key interest to society. I https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946557550 2021-12-14 09:48:51 UTC https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946557550 focus on interlinkages, but how they are situated over time in the life course and how accumulation of disadvantage happens is of relevance. Hence, time-dimension is important and not only a multidimensional perspective https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946561624 2021-12-14 09:51:39 UTC https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946561624 During certain exchanges with the duty bearer of our partner countries on the concept, some regret that the mention of certain obligations of the right holders (ex: peaceful and non-violent demonstrations, ...) is not recalled. Doesn't certain applications of this approach sometimes risk fostering opposition between HR and DB rather than promoting dialogue? https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946573261 2021-12-14 09:58:57 UTC https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946573261 could who explain more the intermediaries/social movements? (examples/diff with CSOs...) https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946587776 2021-12-14 10:08:13 UTC https://padlet.com/emmanuelklimis/296nbd4tf087lhhj/wish/1946587776