Five People by Laura Benetis

PAGE 9, Padlet 1

2025-05-05 01:23:09 UTC

In this section of the novel, Mitch Albom gives the reader context and backstory snippets of Eddie's life. Some of the parts giving context on Eddie's life prior to his death made his life seem seemingly small. However, these were also crucially defining moments for Eddie; particularly seeing his one true love, Marguerite. It doesn't just give a descriptive image of the boardwalk, it a cute depiction of his emotional memories and connections to people in his life previously. The fact that even in his older age, Eddie can remember exactly what Marguerite was wearing and how he was feeling around her was heartwarming, and may even foreshadow Marguerite being one of the five people he meets in heaven.

PAGE 41

benetisl — 2025-05-05 01:31:17 UTC

To give some background, The Blue Man was the first person Eddie had met in heaven. He was explaining to Eddie that he wasn't always all blue, it was because of his anxiety and the lack of medical information in the past that he had been prescribed to take silver nitrate. It wasn't working to help him, so he took more and more until his skin turned blue. This can be seen as an important lesson to not just Eddie, but the reader as well. Everyone has a hidden story — don’t make assumptions based on appearances.

PAGE 34

benetisl — 2025-05-05 01:41:00 UTC

After Eddie woke up in heaven, he felt amazing; he could jump, run, and exist without feeling any pain. However, he was still stuck at the boardwalk. Finally meeting the Blue Man, he thought that the boardwalk was his personal heaven, and began to freak out because he did not want to be stuck there forever. This is significant to note because of this instances relatability: nobody wants to be stuck in their hometown forever. Although this was not what Eddie wanted, it is exactly what the Blue Man wanted. This can be applied to real life; somebody might be dying to get away from their hometown, while others are excited to move there because they see opportunities and potential happiness.

PAGE 49

benetisl — 2025-05-05 01:59:21 UTC

When the Blue Man reveals that Eddie was the reason for his death, Eddie was full of remorse for what had happened. The Blue Man eases his guilt by saying that we as humans are all connected, essentially saying that everything happens for a reason. This reminded me of Ray Bradbury's short story, "A Sound Of Thunder", in which a time traveler steps off a path and crushes a butterfly in prehistoric times. When he returns to the present, the entire world has changed. From this story, comes the butterfly effect: a single, seemingly minor action can drastically change the course of the future. Eddie's small, unintentional act of running into the street as a little boy killed the Blue Man, which ultimately led up to the moment the audience read; it shows to the reader that our actions can deeply affect other people's lives, and exacerbates the idea that humans are all connected- a seemingly big theme in the book thus far.

PAGE 58

benetisl — 2025-05-08 20:04:11 UTC

Before enlisting in the army, Eddie had been saving money to go to college to study engineering. Prior to the beginning of the war, the Ruby Pier was having good business, so he was able to work hard and save his money: but as it began, his customers were mainly children and their mothers. What struck me was how this moment—what the narrator called his "call to manhood"—marked a turning point not just in his life, but in the lives of so many young men of that era. It made me think about how personal dreams can be so easily disrupted by forces like war, and how the emotional aftermath of PTSD, depression, or simply a loss of direction can keep someone from ever returning to the path they once imagined. The trauma of combat left deep psychological scars, and Eddie, like countless veterans, returned home with emotional wounds that made it difficult to resume the life he had planned. Unfortunately, this was the harsh reality for many soldiers at the time.

PAGE 63

benetisl — 2025-05-08 20:04:53 UTC

Going to war can teach a person a lot about themselves and the world. In this part of the book, the narrator is listing things that Eddie learned while in Vietnam. As the list continues, it becomes increasingly bleak, revealing not just physical hardship but deep emotional trauma. The highlighted section shows that Eddie was prepared to die, and he understood that his entire life could end with one shot; it shows the quiet and unspoken toll that war can take. This section resonated with me because it reminded me of my own family members who have served in the military; it made me wonder what they carried with them emotionally and what fears they had to suppress just to keep going.

Page 97

benetisl — 2025-05-09 16:08:39 UTC

The day after Eddie's death, his coworkers, Willie and Dominguez came to the pier regardless of it being closed because of the incident. When he was still alive and working, Eddie seemed like he felt purposeless; he was wrong. At the bottom, it says that "they were waiting for the old man to come in and get the workday started". Obviously, Eddie had a significant role in these people's lives as well as the piers dynamic. His absence left a visible void, showing that even without grand gestures, people can have a lasting impact. I was reminded of my middle school art teacher, who had a similar quiet influence. My friends and I used to skip other classes just to paint ceiling tiles in her room and it was our way of bonding. When she passed away during my sophomore year, the dynamic of our friend group shifted dramatically. Her classroom had been a place of connection and comfort, kind of like Eddie’s role at the pier. This parallel helps show how someone’s presence can deeply shape the lives of others.

Page 94

benetisl — 2025-05-09 16:19:15 UTC

After meeting The Captain, the second person Eddie met in heaven, it was revealed to him that he was shot by The Captain. Towards the end of his time in Vietnam, there was a massive fire, in which Eddie thought there was a little kid caught in the midst of it. It reminded him of his cousins, so he tried to run into the fire. He was ignoring the people telling him to stop, so thats why The Captain shot him in the knee to stop him. This moment is significant because it reshapes Eddie’s perception of his past and his relationships. The Captain’s decision to shoot Eddie seemed like a betrayal at first, but it was more like an act of protection. This encounter helps Eddie confront not only his physical wound but also the emotional burden he carried for years. It shows the idea that heaven is a place of understanding and reconciliation, where even the most difficult truths can bring healing. I hope that this is what heaven is actually like; if it were just pure joy it wouldn't be as meaningful or peaceful as complete understanding of what happened in my life.

PAGE 101

benetisl — 2025-05-15 15:34:56 UTC

Before Eddie met his third person, he teleported to a restaurant where he saw his dad sitting at a booth. He kept yelling for him, not getting a single reaction or response from him. It was later revealed that his dad cannot see or hear Eddie; it was just his soul sitting at the booth. I feel like this has a deeper connotation to it; Eddie's yells and his fathers nonchalance represent their dynamic on earth when they were both still alive. In childhood, his father didn't pay attention to him, and after conflict, his father did not speak to him at all. All Eddie wanted was his dad's attention, but he wouldn't give it to him, as seen in this scene. In a way, it foreshadows what we will learn about Eddie and his dad's relationship.

PAGE 107

benetisl — 2025-05-15 15:41:32 UTC

When describing Eddie and his father's dynamic, it consisted of avoidance for most things. The rare moments of approval Eddie received were tied to "toughness" or "manliness". Eddie would fight kids while trying to defend his brother, and his dad encouraged it. During the summers, Eddie worked tirelessly at Ruby Pier, following his father's orders and performing physical labor, while his brother enjoyed a more leisurely job as a lifeguard at a pool. His father dismissed his efforts with the comment, "That one ain't tough enough for anything but water," referring to Eddie’s brother. This moment emphasizes their father’s values: to earn his approval, one had to fight, work relentlessly, and show physical toughness. Emotional connections or alternative forms of success were not recognized, only the ability to endure and obey. It made me think about how often people are unfairly judged or undervalued by their parents...not for a lack of effort, but for not fitting into their mold. I find this important because it reveals how deeply a parent’s approval (or lack thereof) can shape someone’s identity and self-worth.

PAGE 114

benetisl — 2025-05-15 15:52:57 UTC

Ruby, an old woman and the third person Eddie met in Heaven, was telling the story of how the Ruby Pier came to be. She was describing what her life was like; she was beautiful and had many men trying to marry her, but she rejected them over and over. Her sisters would always ask her why; they were distraught by this, as highlighted in the quote. It's just interesting how they acted in different time periods; it was just normal to marry the first person interested in you. What struck me about Ruby’s story is how bold she was for setting her own standards in a time when women had very little social power or independence. It makes me reflect on how drastically social norms have changed and how grateful I am to live in a time when women are allowed more autonomy over their lives and relationships. Personally, I can’t imagine being pressured to marry someone I didn’t love, or being expected to give up a career to cook, clean, and raise children just because that was considered a woman’s duty.

PAGE 134

benetisl — 2025-05-15 16:00:59 UTC

When Ruby started telling the story of what led to Eddie's dad's death, she showed him a scene with Mickey Shea trying to assault Eddie's mom. He was drunk and had just gotten fired from his job. Clearly, he was really unwell, and Ruby highlights that even though what he did can be seen as evil, it was purely a moment of weakness. Even though his behavior was inexcusable, it didn’t define him as a bad person. What surprised me most was Eddie’s father’s reaction, forgiving Mickey. Despite what had happened, and despite how serious the betrayal was, Eddie’s dad pulled him out of the water when Mickey later nearly drowned. That moment stuck with me because it felt so unexpected. For most of the book, Eddie’s father is portrayed as cold and emotionally distant. But here, he demonstrates mercy, loyalty, and forgiveness that painted him in a better light for me.

PAGE 190

benetisl — 2025-05-28 13:47:26 UTC

The description of Tala as a little, frail child with dark eyes and scarred skin instantly draws up feelings of tragedy, suffering, and innocence. Eddie inevitably faces the most painful scar of his past—the fire in the Philippines, where he thought he saw a child in the flames but was never certain. Tala confirms that it was her and that Eddie killed her without realizing it. This moment's connections to guilt, forgiveness, and lost innocence really stood out to me. In a way, you can see it as Eddie's lifelong emotional scars being symbolized by Tala's physical attributes, such as her small body and scars. Her being there in his arms symbolizes his acceptance of the negative things in his life. Experiencing the type of shame Eddie did is difficult to imagine, and forgiving him for something so terrible is even more difficult.

PAGE 188

benetisl — 2025-05-29 03:19:44 UTC

Tala tells a sad story to Eddie on page 188: her mother warning her against approaching the huts because of the fires the soldiers started. It provides an insight that before a war she didn't understand took her life, Tala was a small girl who was loved, safe, and human. This moment made me think about times in my own life when I didn’t listen to warnings or when I brushed off someone’s advice. I've had times when I only realized the significance of parental warning too late. It also got me thinking about how easily we might undervalue the consequences of our decisions, especially if we aren't immediately aware of them. This reminded me to be more conscious of the significant impact that even seemingly insignificant actions can have.

PAGE 180

benetisl — 2025-05-29 11:52:09 UTC

When summoned into the heaven of Eddie's fifth person, he is surrounded by loud noise that he is unable to decipher. To him, it sounded like his trauma-- burning builds, death, etc. He had nightmares that sounded like Tala's heaven. These noises, however, were not from any violence or malice. They were from the laughter and joy of small kids playing. I thought this was worth noting because even in death, Eddie's PTSD and trauma sticks with him, which isn't something I would expect. Heaven seems like it would be more joyous than that, but it also goes to show you can't replace who you once were and what you have experienced; maybe heaven is the amplification of that.

PAGE 192

benetisl — 2025-05-29 12:03:11 UTC

Throughout the book, Eddie asked every person he met in heaven whether or not he saved the little girl at the pier. All of them didn't know, except for Tala. The highlighted dialogue reveals to the audience that not only did Eddie push the girl out of the way of being crushed, the hands that he felt were actually Tala's taking him to heaven. This was worth taking note of because I was as curious as Eddie to figure out if he saved the girl. He put his life at risk for her, but if she died too it would be so disappointing. This process of living, dying, and then meeting people, is a never ending cycle, and it could make for a great sequel to this book.