Session 1: Assessing proposals for mechanisms to price farm-level emissions by Isabella Cawthorn https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv The Commission is preparing to assess proposed Pricing Mechanisms for farm-scale emissions. SCROLL RIGHT FOR OTHER LENSES, AND DOWN FFOR MORE SPACE en-us 2021-11-29 22:53:29 UTC 2023-03-03 18:51:40 UTC hello@padlet.com LENS 1: how do we assess proposed mechanisms' EQUITY? IsabellaPorirua https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1921903595 2021-12-01 03:07:50 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1921903595 LENS 2: how do we assess proposed mechanisms' EFFECTIVENESS? IsabellaPorirua https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1921905137 2021-12-01 03:08:47 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1921905137 LENS 3: how do we assess proposed mechanisms' PRACTICALITY? IsabellaPorirua https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1921906018 2021-12-01 03:09:19 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1921906018 3. Practical in the eyes of the farmer - data collecting & align w/purpose https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932181169 - what's is going to b required? eg. stock records, irrigation scheme, etc
- do i have scales if am asked to weight livestock?
- fit in w/current farm practices & purpose?]]> 2021-12-06 21:27:14 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932181169 3. Pract. for government - auditing https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932181959 - Auditable things eg. kill sheets
- Govt staff need to understand farming system - build up skills - ongoing process]]> 2021-12-06 21:27:54 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932181959 2 https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932186000 Reduces overall sector's gross emissions ]]> 2021-12-06 21:31:14 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932186000 https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932186658 Pressure on sheep and beef farmers in terms of intergenerational equity, afforestation under ETS carbon farming. Cap on total amount of land transferred? Options for landowners to capture these credits and retain ownership?

Maori land, mechanisms and investment vs freehold land, considerations in land use change. ]]> 2021-12-06 21:31:44 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932186658 3. Linked with biological cycles https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932186842 - Sync w/current practices ]]> 2021-12-06 21:31:53 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932186842 https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932189248 Fairness of international competition - if UK offer subsidies NZ farmers may be disadvantaged. ]]> 2021-12-06 21:33:47 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932189248 3. Point of obligation with different practices https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932189912 - Obligations falling eg. mix cropping, grazier farms, finishing etc.
- eg. Head counts on/off trucks, weight]]> 2021-12-06 21:34:17 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932189912 3. On farm sequestration - avoid duplication https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932191576 - Reconcile LUCAS, Lidar, 
- Align w/environmental reporting, SNAs, bring all together
- Credible: Decent ground validation]]> 2021-12-06 21:35:28 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932191576 3. Skills available - variable across the country & not comprehensive knowledge https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932192434 - Not enough knowledge who could give advice on sequestration + farming
a. Knowledge on particular property
b. Knowledge on policy
c. Understanding how ag business system is working]]> 2021-12-06 21:36:09 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932192434 https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932192510 Regarding equity for Maori landowners - many farms/ownership structures, how to consider equity and practicality for these organisations. Practicality might look different for different farm types ]]> 2021-12-06 21:36:13 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932192510 Be clearer on what is meant by these criteria https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932192853 e.g. sector coverage - what will the Commission actually use to assess whether 'sector coverage' is appropriate?

]]> 2021-12-06 21:36:31 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932192853 Governance and ownership structures https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932194291 How to link the equity and practical criteria - workability for different farm types is key.]]> 2021-12-06 21:37:41 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932194291 3. Info database access - Facilitate knowledge transfer https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932196013 Data to support good decision making
Should be public knowledge]]> 2021-12-06 21:38:52 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932196013 https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932196427 Elanor Ostrom, CPRA, collective action can work better with community input into common pool resource use. What works in practice, equity for Maori, hapu, iwi level, should work in theory.


]]> 2021-12-06 21:39:10 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932196427 2 sector coverage https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932197245 Commercial farms - needs to cover major farms
Needs to include decision-makers
Needs to be clear on point of obligation (e.g. individual farmers vs collectives)]]> 2021-12-06 21:39:51 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932197245 3. Practicality - make or break https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932197677 2021-12-06 21:40:15 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932197677 2. gross emissions reductions https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932198025 e.g. is 1% reduction enough?]]> 2021-12-06 21:40:33 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932198025 2 https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932200297 Needs to account for responsibility for reducing different GHGs for different farm types

]]> 2021-12-06 21:42:20 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932200297 https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932200604 Farming has been effective at delaying, there's going to be outcry, protect international competitiveness but at the same time we need to take action. ]]> 2021-12-06 21:42:34 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932200604 1. Māori have different state of development & little access to debt https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932200982 They would see as limiting their choices. 
Disadvantaged by any pricing mechanism.
Access to debt - ]]> 2021-12-06 21:42:52 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932200982 3. Price https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932204154 Mechanism for setting price needs to be practical - (there are different methods for setting price e.g. split gas etc)]]> 2021-12-06 21:45:25 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932204154 1. Ability to pay - dairy vs sheep&beef & cropping https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932204175 2021-12-06 21:45:25 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932204175 https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932204445 Availability of skills - multi-angle approach, skills for farmers and consultants, support farmer ownership of their data]]> 2021-12-06 21:45:39 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932204445 3. Tools https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932205259 Single tool or multiple aligned tools
Mechanism and timing of reporting/monitoring
Picking the best compliance point]]> 2021-12-06 21:46:23 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932205259 https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932205664 Regulatory framework - allow on-farm mitigation approaches, reg systems can take a long time]]> 2021-12-06 21:46:43 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932205664 Regulatory arrangements https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932205895 Can take a really long time for regulatory arrangements to get up and running - big barrier]]> 2021-12-06 21:46:55 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932205895 1. Differentiated impacts by farm business structure https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932205937 2021-12-06 21:46:57 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932205937 3. timing https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932206979 Timing important on point and regularity of reporting and monitoring]]> 2021-12-06 21:47:47 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932206979 1. Price shocks - principles on how to handle https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932207539 2021-12-06 21:48:17 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932207539 https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932207758 Play to farmer values and innovative operators. ]]> 2021-12-06 21:48:29 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932207758 2. Balance between financial incentive and doing right thing https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932207899 2021-12-06 21:48:37 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932207899 https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932207909 Widest possible sector coverage - leakage, work to farmer values and farmers taking initiative. Regen ag talks of 3-4 year transition, supporting that transition financially. ]]> 2021-12-06 21:48:37 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932207909 https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932208664 Need t ensure wide sector coverage]]> 2021-12-06 21:49:13 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932208664 2. Use of recycling of revenue https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932208668 2021-12-06 21:49:13 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932208668 1. Existing actions https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932209382 Recognising farmers who have already taken action
Setting the right baseline]]> 2021-12-06 21:49:51 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932209382 https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932210201 We are looking at a major restructuring of the science system - Connectivity across institutions and sectors is crucial, often fragmented. 

How mitigation is actually going to work - regen ag provides mechanisms]]> 2021-12-06 21:50:38 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932210201 https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932210551 Science system. Thinking through details of actions needed to reduce emissions. Need to plan for a 10-15 year pathway.]]> 2021-12-06 21:50:54 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932210551 Effectiveness - How do you balance implementation of a pricing scheme. Farmers may choose to simply pay the check rather than reduce GHGs (costs and benefits) https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932211592 2021-12-06 21:51:50 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932211592 1. Equity should be based on emissions https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932212221 Price paid should be proportional to emissions.]]> 2021-12-06 21:52:23 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932212221 Mechanisms for emissions reduction https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932214187 We are often very diffuse in the policy environment for practical reductions that can achieve a lot over 10-15 years. Consider what's emerging around regenerative and circular economy principles for agriculture - more work needs to be done to identify practical mechanisms that have clear potential but can't go into the models we have.

]]> 2021-12-06 21:54:02 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932214187 1. Income https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932239999 Pricing system needs to reflect differences in income between farms - (ability to pay)]]> 2021-12-06 22:16:57 UTC https://padlet.com/IsabellaPorirua/1unz0fffqrkocvvv/wish/1932239999