https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4 T+ 2nd Integration Workshop (3/4) BoG4 en-us 2021-06-11 06:46:42 UTC 2026-02-11 23:12:20 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet-uploads.storage.googleapis.com/1157448439/56af27d0159b00b17d21cfd2c7270884/image_T_.webp GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519639 - on-stream narration - is it possible to achieve a positive tipping point through it?


]]> 2021-06-11 06:46:42 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519639 GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519640 - similarities: on-stream narratives: PL/Germany: economic patriotism/economic security argument
- the on/off narrations are different in case of implementation details (on/off grid; top-down/bottom-up; external/local production), depending on the advancement of energy transition stage and the context of the country]]> 2021-06-11 06:46:42 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519640 GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519641 What region types did you identify?
-  formal 5 hydropowerplants in 5 regions, region defined by the powerplant
- search for regions with bigger potential for hydropower plants
- places where the goverment invested
- Perception has change since the 1980 where the focus was not on the ecological but the economical dimension. Today people also adress climate change

What region type(s) do you find more relevant for your case study and why?
- In the case studies the political narratives are analysed   hence focus on perceptual

Who is/are describing the region?
-

Are these region types aligned with the mainstream narratives?
-]]> 2021-06-11 06:46:42 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519641 https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519643 - for Balearic: all stakeholders follow same mainstream narrative; but on- and off-stream narrative depends on perspective
- are narratives that are not becoming more prominent "alternative narratives"
- difference of alternative and transformative narratives sometimes unclear
- difference of on- and off-stream:
possible interpretation:
on-stream: continuation with what has been narrated before
off-stream: new technologies, new ownership structures, new stakeholders carrying this narrative
- challenge: dividing stakeholders along narratives


]]> 2021-06-11 06:46:42 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519643 GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519644 What alternative narratives did you identify?
- on-stream: a need to continue of the coal extraction at the small scale (because of the energy security) - as it is safe and important from the economic side (export of German technologies)
- offstream: complete coal and nuclear phase-out is a must and the future should be based on the developing community-owned renewable energy installations;
-local offstream: thinking about hydrogen/logistics (Duisburg)



Which stakeholders have been historically underrepresented?
- coal miners in case of shaping future narratives about the region (from the general discussion)
-
-]]> 2021-06-11 06:46:42 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519644 GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519645 What alternative narratives did you identify?
- on-stream: fossil fuel phase-out,
new efficient, renewable energy system shall be implemented
- off-stream: fossil fuel phase-out as soon as possible
- different narratives in Majorka/Minorka/Ibiza and Formentera
- general consensus for the fossil fuel phase-out, but the clue is in the implementation details
- NGOs and local groups oppose implementation of installations by large companies

Which stakeholders have been historically underrepresented?
- 
-
-]]> 2021-06-11 06:46:42 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519645 GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519647 What alternative narratives did you identify?
- on-stream: "clean coal" narrative (it is important from the point of using existing industrial potential in the region, maintain coal extraction to some extent; also arguments such as energy security and economic patriotism)
- off-stream: coal phase-out narrative (necessary not only from the perspective of climate change mitigation, but also to transform the outdated regional economy, promote more healthy/living conditions, jobs in more promising industries and avoid the consequences of mining extraction for the local communities such as mining damages)


Which stakeholders have been historically underrepresented?
- NGOs/younger generation/citizens of mining municipalities not connected with the mining sector
-
-]]> 2021-06-11 06:46:42 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519647 GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519648 What alternative narratives did you identify?
- on-stream: the further development of hydro power plants and gas to some extent (top-down, steered by the government)
- off-stream: implementation of PV/wind power instead (as the more cost-effective and engaging solutions; oil prices are unstable); more bottom-up narrative


Which stakeholders have been historically underrepresented?
- younger generation less concerned with technical aspects of energy transition, and more vocal about the environmental aspects of going green.]]> 2021-06-11 06:46:42 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519648 GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519649 What alternative narratives did you identify?
- on-stream: building a grid to ensure the energy access to all rural communities (on grid electrification, dependent on fossil fuels, LNG, clean coal etc)
- off-stream: off-grid solar systems to replace traditional technologies and empower farmers


Which stakeholders have been historically underrepresented?
- farmers on the rural area without electricity access
-
-]]> 2021-06-11 06:46:42 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/AlternativeNarrativesCluster4/wish/1600519649