Inclusion criteria for projects on a citizen science platform by Daniel Dörler https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft Here you can see first draft-versions of criteria that have been created based on a literature search and on personal experience of citizen science platform coordinators. As mentioned, this is a first draft and not a final product. We want to involve you at this early stage to create criteria that are comprehensive, measurable and inclusive. We welcome your input and ask for a respectful cooperation in the document. If you want to be part of the working group or have any questions on the process, please send an e-mail to Daniel and Florian office@citizen-science.at. Please note: if you want us to be able to contact you in case we have any questions about your comment, please use your real name and send us an e-mail with your e-mail-address to office@citizen-science.at. To add a comment or question to one of the criteria, please click on the + just below the criterium you want to add a comment or question to. You can also add links, pictures, other padlets or just use one of the many other options available to add your thoughts. You can also like already existing posts by clicking on the heart-icon directly under the post. We will use the number of likes as an indicator if the post is important for many of the participants or not. en-us 2020-08-17 13:33:44 UTC 2021-05-20 07:12:34 UTC hello@padlet.com What about monitoring environmental conditions? Or creating a database? Need to be clearer about "new research-based knowledge" https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft/wish/724837604 2020-09-07 13:26:05 UTC https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft/wish/724837604 CS includes research activities in which citizens and researchers (and other actors) collaborate to develop knowledge that is valuable: valuable for individual citizens, valuable for science, valuable for society. https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft/wish/724847722 2020-09-07 13:33:00 UTC https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft/wish/724847722 There are lots of different ways in which someone might "benefit" and they may not anticipate them all in advance. It may therefore be hard to measure this, e.g. someone may contribute because they want to sort out a local environmental problem, but the main benefit they end up getting is scientific education and career advancement https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft/wish/724866767 2020-09-07 13:46:09 UTC https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft/wish/724866767 tt https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft/wish/729296936 2020-09-08 22:00:37 UTC https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft/wish/729296936 https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft/wish/729297997 aware that the initial wording may exclude narrative/qualitative contribution?]]> 2020-09-08 22:01:26 UTC https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft/wish/729297997 Co-create scientifically valid methods? https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft/wish/729346604 2020-09-08 22:37:05 UTC https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft/wish/729346604 This would imply that CS projects are driven by member of the (professional) scientific community and might be interpreted as excluding projects initiated by citizens (organisations). If this is not intended, the text (also in other criteria) needs to be rephrased. (contact: Brigitte T.) https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft/wish/1125445387 2021-01-26 07:51:17 UTC https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft/wish/1125445387 https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft/wish/1125462217 not to forget the issue of minimum requirements for citizens to participate (technical, personal, know-how etc.) and if and how training will be needed / provided to participants (Brigitte T)

]]> 2021-01-26 07:56:27 UTC https://padlet.com/danieldoerler/criteria_first_draft/wish/1125462217