# data[].attributes.headline
prl practice-fatimah binti mohd izarrudin 

# data[].attributes.subject
prl practice-fatimah binti mohd izarrudin 

# data[].attributes.body
In the story Gibraltor by Mark Sultz, the story revolve twins brother, Oscar and Oliver . I thought the ending is good but suprising the story was sad ending.

I think Oliver did not reveal true his true identity of himself to anyone because he wanted to inherit the treasure on the Fathom.In the story Oscar married with Luisa who is daughter of the Captain Angelotti.In my opinion ,oliver was not doing the right thing pretended as Oscar.

In reality,being yourself is the prettiest things you can be.Based on this story Oscar and Oliver exactly alike ,two people walking the earth to be the same but their have diffrent identity.

In conclusion,we must think before we do something to avoid unwanted things.Honesty is very important to facilitate the affairs of people around

# data[].attributes.body
The story of Gibraltar by Mark Sutz is about identical twins,Oscar and Oliver who are exactly alike.They had been working on a research vessel or we called as treasure hunting with captain John Angeletti who is a friend of their father. Oscar was married with the captain's daughter, Luisa. At the end of the story, Oscar, Luisa and the captain died because of rainstorm incident. Oliver pretended to be Oscar after the incident.

In my opinion, Oliver did not reveal his true identity because he was doing the honorable thing for his brother. The crew told their parents that Oliver whos the one that died in the incident. For me, Oliver should have told about the truth to his parents. He should not pretended to be Oscar because its not a right thing to do.

In conclusion, Oliver should have made the right choice by telling the truth. Gibraltar is a very sad and interesting story.

# data[].attributes.body
Good morning madam

# data[].attributes.body
We are going to discuss on the story first before you do the practice.
What do you think of the story?

# data[].attributes.body
Based on the short story, Gibraltar by Mark Sutz, the story is about an identical twins, Oscar and Oliver that were indistinguishable by most people. The two had been apprenticing on a research vessel, the Fathom when they were eighteen. Unfortunately, Oscar, the captain John Angelotti and his daughter, Luisa died due to strong levanter.  At the end of the story, Oliver pretended to be Oscar, his twins.

In my opinion,I think Oliver did not reveal his true identity of himself to anyone  because he wanted to inherit the treasure and to become the heir of to its ownership. This is because, in the story, his twin Oscar was married to the daughter of the captain, Luisa. This made him the heir apparent to its ownership. Other than that, it is said that Luisa's choice of Oscar as her lover and companion made meant his place was way more secure than Oliver.

I personally think that what Oliver did was wrong because he was intended to take his brother part as someone honorable. In the story he mentioned that he wished as hard as he has ever wished for anything in his life that by taking his brother's place in this life, he was doing the most honorable thing.

To sum up, Gibraltar is a very interesting short story with unexpected ending.

# data[].attributes.headline
PRL (Nurhanna Safwa Binti Mohammad Bachtiar)

# data[].attributes.subject
PRL (Nurhanna Safwa Binti Mohammad Bachtiar)

# data[].attributes.body
Based on the short story "Gibraltar" by Mark Sutz, i find the reason Oliver did not reveal his true identity is because he had wanted a claim on the Fathom and the treasures as written in the story " without that possibility of working with him(Oscar) and Luisa  on the Fathom once the captain had retired and passed it onto them. Now i had no claim to it at all". This shows that Oliver had atleast wanted a claim on the Fathom and its treasures maybe for a memorabilia of Oscar and their adventures also by not revealing himself Oliver thought he was doing an honourable thing for Oscar.
By my perspective, Oliver was not doing the right thing as pretending to be someone else is wrong and can be harmful to the mind as it gives a sense of fake reality.

# data[].attributes.body
Based on the short story, Gilbraltar by Mark Sutz.The story is about identical twins Oscar and Oliver they were on adventure for treasure hunt on a research vessel. One day a rainstorm happen and Oliver survived but Oscar sadly didn't, after the incident happen Oliver never reveal himself.

I think Oliver never reveal his true identity of himself to anyone because he can inherit the Fathom with his brother identity so the Fathom will never gone. Oliver was never mean to live as Oscar but Oliver want to protect the Fathom. In my opinion, what Oliver did is wrong what if someday the truth was reveal,people will never trust him anymore and think he just want to inherit the Fathom assets.

Lying to others are big issues that can bring harm to yourself and others. In my opinion,lie as much as you much but the truth will always been told. For example, you told others that you study and that is why you have high grade but the truth you cheated in exam. When your result are great people around you are proud  and trusted you can do it but imagine if they know the truth alot of people might get hurt and throw to you.

In conclusion, think before you do sometimes it is better to tell the truth than lying even you didn't mean to harm anyone. The story of Gilbratar is quite intresting but I never expect that Oliver was going to lie about identity.

# data[].attributes.body
PRL(NUR AMALIN ASYIKIN BINTI MUHAMAD)

The short story titled 'gibraltar' by Mark Sutz, is tale about Oliver who was oscar's twin and the one  that survived from rainstorm incident.I think, he not reveal himself because he think his decision to pretended being his brother is something that he should to do.
For me, what is he doing is wrong.He cannot pretended as oscar. This is can make Luisa and others believe that oscar still alive.For example, he let Don called him as oscar and not telling that he is oliver actually.

# data[].attributes.body
PRL (NURUL IZZA BINTI YAZNAN)

The short story titled "Gibraltar" by Mark Sutz is a story about a twins brothers that goes on an adventure salvaging shipwreck. I think, oliver did not reveal his identity to anyone because he wanted to inherit the Fathom to gain the treasure.

In the story, oliver said that without oscar he will not have a claim to the Fathom at all. Even though Oliver hoped that it is an honorable thing to do for oscar, I still think that it was a wrong thing to do because no matter how identical they were, both of them were still a different person.

Being true to yourself is important. Living as someone else will never make you happy because you are lying to yourself. No matter how identical you are with someone, your heart is still different. I once read about twins and they develop different personalities from each other and everyone have different personalities.

In conclusion the story is an interesting story and it gives readers quite the confusion. Being someone else won't give you happiness in life even if you try your best to be that person.

# data[].attributes.body
PRL (MASYITAH BINTI ABDUL RAHMAN)

# data[].attributes.body
PRL(Nurfarah Ain Bt Adnan)
In the short story 'Gibraltar' by Mark Sutz, the story is about involving identical twins that goes on an adventure salvaging shipwreck and the one that survived from rainstorm incident. I think the reason why he did not reveal his true identity because he can inherit the treasurer.

In the story, Oliver said that he had no idea how life would even possible without Oscar. Oscar was made the heir apparent to its ownership, without that possibility of working with him he had no claim to it at all.That's why he pretended to be Oscar.

I think what he did was wrong because he deceived everyone and his own family for his own sake. In reality, we should not take away the rights of others in order to protect our own interests.The things that Oliver do should not be examplified by lack of honesty in doing something. The qulity of honesty must be present in a person because honesty makes people trust each others.

In conclusion, the short story is interesting and provide its readers with elements of surprise because thereaders did not expected that Oliver make decision to pretended to be Oscar.

# data[].attributes.body
The short story tiltled Gibraltar written by Mark Sutz is about an identical twins, Oliver and Oscar.They had been working on a research vessel with captain John Angelotti. At the end of the story, Oliver was pretend to be his own brother to everyone when his brother died due to the rainstorm.
In my opinion, he did not reveal his true identity of himself to anyone bcause he wants to inherit his brother treasure.He knew that his brother was made the heir apparent to its ownership when Oscar married with captain John Angelotti's daughter, Luisa.
I think what he did was wrong because he lied to everyone included his own parents.Based on the story,he did not tell the truth when Don called him as Oscar  after he awake from the incident.For me, he should not lying even though they were exactly alike because he may ruin everything in the future.
In conclusion, the story was quite interesting and it taugh us for being honest to everyone around

# data[].attributes.body
In the short story Gibraltar by Mark Sutz, the story about an identical twins, Oscar and Oliver who were indistinguishable by many people. The twin did been apprenciting a research vessel, the fathom when they were eighteen. At the end, Oliver pretended to be Oscar due to accident which caused Oscar, Captain John Angelotti and his daughter, Luisa to die due to the storm.

In my opinion, Oliver did reveal identity because he want to inherit the treasure all by himself and become the heirs of the ownership.This is because Oscar was married to Luisa, the captain's daughter and the chance to Oscar to get the ownership is more higher than him.

From my point of view, i think that what Oliver did was wrong by pretended to be someone else to inherit the treasure and take the ownership and as he said in the story, he wished as hard as he have ever wished for anything in his life by taking his brother's place in this life, he was doing honorable things. Pretend to be someone else is like lying to yourself and others. Also you will not be happy because you're not being yourself.

In conclusion, this story is interesting and quite confusing. From the story, we need to be a honest by not lying to others and you will live happily.

# data[].attributes.body
The story of Gibraltor by Mark Sutz is about the twins brother, Oscar and Oliver. They were been searching on treasure along with Captain John Angeletti.

In this story told us that Oscar, Luisa and the captain died because of the rainstom. Oscar were married to Luisa and Luisa is Captain John Angeletti's daughter. The reason why Oliver wanted to pretend to be Oscar because Oliver wanted to take position of Captain of the Fathom and want the treasure that he and Oscar were searching for. Although Oliver thinks that it is honourable thing to do for his brother.

The decision that Oliver decided to be Oscar was wrong. Everylife is different. You do not have to be someone else to do amazing things in life, just simply be yourself.

In conclusions, Oliver need to start appreciating who he was. He did not have to be someone else. Gibraltar was amazing story and it also had sad ending.

# data[].attributes.body
PRL (NURUL SYUHADAH BINTI MOHD ZAKARIA)

# data[].attributes.body
In the short story titled Gibraltar by Mark Sutz about an identical twins name Oscar and Oliver,going throught adventure in the sea to hunt a treasure,and how both of theirs life took a difference turn from each others.

In this story Oliver did not reveal his true identity to anyone in order to become Oscar,who is his twins brother who died in the storm ,along with Oscar's wife,Luisa and Captain Angeletti who is Luisa'Father,he did this to claim the possition as a Captain of the Fathom and he also thinks taking his brother's place,are the right and honorable thing to do.

In my oppinion what Oliver did,is not wrong because he had to hide his true identity in order to carried on not only his brother but also Captain Angeletti legacy as the Captain to the Fathom, he also said that he wish by taking his brother's place,he is doing a honorable thing for Oscar.He did not thing about the treasure or the Fathom during this time instead only thinking about Oscar and how lonely he feel without his brother around.

In conclusion, I find that the short story,Gibraltar a very interesting because you need to really understand the storyline in order to figure out the real moral of the story,which is in my oppinion,Only death can seperate the relantionship you had with your family,so always treasure your time with them before they gone.

# data[].attributes.headline
PRL PRACTICE - FADZILLAH HANIM BINTI IBRAHIM

# data[].attributes.subject
PRL PRACTICE - FADZILLAH HANIM BINTI IBRAHIM

# data[].attributes.body
In the short story titled Gibraltar by Mark Sutz the story revolved around a pair of identical twins, Oliver and Oscar which have been apprenticing on a research vessel, the Fathom, to learn the business call treasure hunting but then something tragic happen to one of them. Oliver did not want to reveal his true identity because he want to inherit his brother's possession.
This is proven when Luisa chose to marry Oscar rather than him, Oliver somehow triggered because his twin position is more secure than him. Oscar was made the heir apparent to its ownership. This meant that Oscar is going to be richer than him. Then, when he know that Oscar died and being washed overboard that night, he was shocked. But then he realized that Don, one of the ship crew member who survived from the storm called him by his twin's name. At that moment, he imagined if he chose to live with his brother's name, he can inherit all of his brother's wealth.
I do not think Oliver's lie was a right decision to make. Nowadays people tend to take advantage over other people for the sake of the possession.
In conclusion, the short story is interesting and it provide the readers with mixed elements of sad and surprise. The story also teaches us to not trust people easily.

# data[].attributes.headline
PRL PRACTICE - NUR HAZWANI BINTI ZAKARIA

# data[].attributes.subject
PRL PRACTICE - NUR HAZWANI BINTI ZAKARIA

# data[].attributes.body
The short story titled Gibraltar by Mark Sutz,the story about twins brother Oscar and Oliver goes on an adventure in the sea to find a treasure.when their on hunting for treasure,the rainstorm happen and Oscar,Captain John Angelotti and Luisa died.The end of this story will make many people wonder why Oliver changed his identity to become his brother's identity Oscar.

What I think about why Oliver did not reveal his true identity of himself to everyone because he wanted to inherit the treasure and to become the Captain of the Fathom.Before he change identity,I think he would be sad because he had lost his brother.But suddenly his want to stay the Oscar identity because Don call him as Oscar.Maybe Oliver thought that he did a honorable thing to replace Oscar position.

In my opinion,Oliver has made the wrong decision to live as his brother's identity. He should be honest and does not take advantage such as Oliver tries to take over the Oscar position. If he is honest, maybe he will be able to get some property because only he is living and he is a good twins to the Oscar.

In conclusition,this short story gives us a good message as we must be yourself and not being greedy. In addition, this story is very surprising readers because he able to living as someone else for his own interest.