# data[].attributes.headline
HOW IS LYNETTE A TRAGIC VICTIM OF DISCRIMINATION?

# data[].attributes.subject
HOW IS LYNETTE A TRAGIC VICTIM OF DISCRIMINATION?

# data[].attributes.body
" I don’t want to live in a world where what I am isn’t good enough, where nothing I do will ever be good enough because I’m a nought"

# data[].attributes.body
'One of them pressed something into Dad's hand...immediately stuffed it into his jacket pocket'.

Technique- foreshadowing

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.title
“Racism & discrimination played a very real part in the response to this tragedy” - Grenfell Inquiry closing statement | News | Garden Court Chambers | Leading Barristers located in London, UK

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.description
Module 4 closing statement on behalf of some bereaved, residents and survivors, including those represented by Alison Munroe QC and Thalia Maragh of Garden Court Chambers.

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.readable_text
Just before 01:00 on 14 June, fire broke out in the kitchen of a fourth floor flat at the 23 storey tower block in North Kensington, West London.

Within minutes, the fire had raced up the exterior of the building and then spread to all four sides. By 03:00, most of the upper floors were well alight.

Seventy-two people died. Here is how events unfolded that night.

This page was originally published in 2017 and has been updated as further details have emerged from official reports. It contains graphic images of the fire.

What happened on the night?

The fire began "in or around" a Hotpoint fridge-freezer in flat 16 on the fourth floor, according to a provisional report by Dr Niamh Nic Daéid, director of the Leverhulme Research Centre for Forensic Science at Dundee University.

Her report contains extracts from a witness statement by flat occupant Behailu Kebede, who described being woken by the sound of a smoke alarm.

He went into the kitchen and saw smoke in the area of the fridge-freezer and near the kitchen window.

Mr Kebede immediately called the fire brigade, which logged the call at 00:54. Four fire engines were sent to the scene, the first arriving at 00:59.

The first fire crew entered the flat at 01:07 - an approximate timing taken from a thermal imaging camera. They initially searched the bedrooms and did not enter the kitchen until 01:14.

In the kitchen, firefighter Daniel Brown described seeing an "isolated curtain of flame from about 2-3 feet in the air to the ceiling".

Thermal images captured by the fire crew appear to show that "hot fire gases and flames had spread across the window space".

As the fire crew dealt with the fire in the fridge-freezer, their thermal images also appear to show falling embers outside the kitchen window.

Mobile phone images taken by Mr Kebede from outside Grenfell Tower approximately 11 minutes after his first 999 call show an orange glow of flames around the kitchen window, and later a fire burning more intensely in the area of the window filler panel and extractor fan.

Subsequent photos by Mr Kebede suggest that the "fire was continuing to develop and grow", Dr Nic Daéid reports, by 01:09 becoming "external to the building".

Although the timings provided are approximate, it appears that the fire had spread to the cladding before the firefighters had entered the kitchen.

Dr Nic Daéid's provisional report also identifies "unknown materials" stored between the freezer and wall which "may have become involved in the fire in the early stages of its development".

Among these materials was an item described as an "electric cooking device" or "large hot plate".

In another report, fire expert Professor Luke Bisby expressed his view that the likely reason for the fire spreading beyond the kitchen was that flame and hot gases penetrated the internal window frame.

From the fourth floor, the fire spread rapidly upwards and across the eastern side of the building. From there, it spread across the north face of the tower.

Mobile phone videos show the blaze reaching the top floor on the east side of Grenfell Tower by about 01:26, less than 30 minutes after firefighters had arrived.

In a report to the Grenfell Public Inquiry, fire safety engineer Dr Barbara Lane identified the fire spreading vertically up the tower columns, and "laterally along the cladding above and below the window lines (and) the panels between windows."

The fire had spread to the north side of the tower by 01:42, Dr Lane recorded.

At 01:52, the fire also began travelling across the eastern side towards the south in the other direction.

At 02:06, London Fire Brigade declared the fire a "major incident". At this point, some 40 fire engines were either at or en route to the scene.

Grenfell Tower had a 'stay put' fire policy - essentially, the building design would contain a fire in a single flat for as long as it took fire crews to bring it under control.

So on the night, many residents were told to remain in their flats by the emergency services, only to become trapped as the fire blazed out of control and thick poisonous smoke spread up the single narrow stairwell.

Dr Lane said that the stay put policy had "substantially failed" by 01:26 - less than 30 minutes after the first firefighters were at the scene.

Some people ignored the stay put advice and made it down the stairs to safety.

A total of 65 people were rescued from the building by firefighters.

But in desperation, other residents went upwards and sought refuge in flats of friends and neighbours on the upper floors. Twenty-four people died on the top floor of the tower block.

By 02:10, multiple internal fires could be seen burning inside the building.

At 02:22 fire had spread to the south side of the tower and by 02:30 it was reported that the eastern side of the building was "fully involved in fire".

The stay put advice was finally abandoned at 02:47, when the incident commander gave the order to "advise people to make efforts to leave the building."

Counsel to the Grenfell inquiry Richard Millet QC told the 4 June 2018 hearing that 144 people managed to evacuate before 01:38, but only 36 after the stay put guidance was abandoned.

By 02:51, the fire had reached the western side. At this point, some 63 flats were on fire and more than 100 people remained in the building.

At 04:30 the whole building was engulfed, with more than 100 flats on fire.

The blaze did not burn itself out until 01:14 BST on Thursday - 24 hours later.

The most significant part of the renovation of Grenfell Tower was the addition of external cladding. This consisted of aluminium sheets bonded to a central plastic (polyethylene) core.

In his report to the public inquiry, Professor Luke Bisby said evidence "strongly supports" the theory that the polyethylene material in the cladding was the primary cause of the fire's spread.

"The ACM (aluminium composite material) product on Grenfell Tower incorporates a highly combustible polyethylene polymer filler which melts, drips, and flows at elevated temperature. The polyethylene filler material is expected to release large amounts of energy during combustion".

His report also suggests that vertical cavities within the cladding structure played a role in the spread of the fire, as did the insulation, although evidence was inconclusive.

A number of other flammable materials, including a polyurethane polymer foam insulation board which pre-dated the refurbishment were also present and may have contributed, Prof. Bisby found.

In her report, fire expert Dr Barbara Lane identifies combustible materials used in the refurbishment of the tower's windows as another factor in allowing the fire to spread.

The Grenfell Inquiry has also heard that the building's smoke extraction system was not working, and that firefighters experienced problems with the water supply because there was no 'wet riser' - a water-filled pipe running up the building to be used in the event of fire.

Giving evidence to the inquiry, Dr Lane said exposed gas pipes installed in 2016 were another contributory factor, while none of the flat doors met current fire resistance standards.

Work done on the lifts in 2005 and 2012-16 left them unfit for evacuating vulnerable residents and aiding the emergency response, Dr Lane said.

They include six members of the Choucair Family and five members of the Hashim Family, who lived on the 22nd floor.

Five members of the El-Wahabi family died on the 21st floor.

The youngest victim was six-month old baby Leena Belkadi, who died in her mother's arms as she tried to escape.

Other young victims included Jeremiah Deen, 2, Isaac Paulos, 5, Hania Hassan, 5, and her sister Fethia, 3, and twelve-year olds Biruk Haftom and Jessica Urbano-Ramirez.

The oldest victim is believed to be 84-year-old Sheila from the 16th floor, who had lived in Grenfell Tower for 34 years.

Baby Logan Gomes, who was stillborn in hospital on 14 June the morning after the fire, is also included in the toll.

The final victim was Maria Del Pilar Burton, who suffered from serious long-term health issues, and died in hospital in January 2018.

Grenfell Tower was part of the Lancaster West Estate, a social housing complex of almost 1,000 homes.

The tower was built in the 1970s, but recently renovated.

An £8.6m refurbishment - part of a wider transformation of the estate - was completed by Rydon Construction in May 2016.

Work included new exterior cladding, replacement windows and a communal heating system.

The bottom four floors were also remodelled, creating seven additional homes and improvements to communal facilities.

There were 129 flats across 21 residential floors and three levels of mixed use.

The tower was managed by the Kensington and Chelsea Tenant Management Organisation (KCTMO) on behalf of the council.

After the fire a massive search and recovery operation led by the Met, City of London and British Transport Police began immediately.

Specially trained officers thoroughly searched every single flat, examining some 15.5 tonnes of debris on each floor, helped by forensic anthropologists, archaeologists and forensic dentists or odontologists.

The Met Police are looking into offences including manslaughter, corporate manslaughter, misconduct in public office and breaches of fire safety regulations in relation to the fire.

The force has already gathered 31 million documents and 2,500 physical exhibits. Some 1,144 witnesses have given statements and 383 companies are part of the investigation.

A public inquiry, ordered by former Prime Minister Theresa May, is under way.

Lawyers representing survivors and relatives of the victims began giving evidence in December 2017.

Phase one of the inquiry, which examined what happened on the night, was released in October 2019 and found 'systemic failures' in London Fire Brigade's response.

Phase two, which will look at the building's refurbishment and external cladding, is due to begin in January 2020.

Produced by the Visual Journalism team

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.description
Images, maps and graphics explaining how the devastating fire at Grenfell Tower may have started and how it spread.

# data[].attributes.body
"If she cared so much where was she for the last three years when Lynn was out of her mind and we didn't have two beans to rub together never mind the money to get Lynn the help she needed, where was this dagger when you got fired and I had to drop out of school".

This shows how Jude is still angry about how he had to stop going to school.

# data[].attributes.attachment_link.title
Issues in Northern Ireland Compilation | Ross Kemp Extreme World

# data[].attributes.body
“WORSE THAN ANIMALS-LIKE BLANKERS!”

Shows how her privilege and innocence makes her more ignorant about racist things she might say

# data[].attributes.body
Chapter 51 Page 201, “What to drink? Warm milk or cold orange juice? In the fridge door was a half-full bottle of Chardonnay.”

Links to Sephy’s privilege as she can choose an expensive wine to drink. She can drink her problems away unlike people without privilege.

Rhetorical Question
Listing

# data[].attributes.body
‘each move i made in callums direction just seemed to pave my way faster to hell’ pg 172 chapter 41. metaphor explaining that her and callums relationship is getting uncomfortable and causing them to feel horrible

# data[].attributes.body
"Sephy felt a pang of guilt when she saw the state of the noughts' compartment. She'd never known it was so bad because she'd never bothered to look before."

Page 146 chapter 30

She is starting to understand the privilege she gets.

# data[].attributes.body
I’d been ashamed of them. And myself. I’d felt ashamed of myself a lot recently, and, if I’m honest, part of me resented Callum for it. I didn’t want to feel guilty for just being, but that’s how he was beginning to make me feel. ---- page 110

In this quote, Sephy explains the internal conflict she feels as she learns more about the social dynamics between noughts and Crosses. She's ashamed of other Crosses' behavior, and of herself—but this shame also makes her angry at Callum, because she personally doesn't see how she's done anything wrong. At this point in the narrative, she feels she's "just being," and she blames Callum for how she feels as she learns about inequality. This blame is, of course, misplaced; as she learns more and becomes more active in pursuing social equality, Sephy will learn to direct the guilt she feels into action.

# data[].attributes.body
“My dads the Home Office Minister, Kamal Hadley. Callum is my friend,” page 104

# data[].attributes.body
‘mother. her drinking getting worse’ i said

‘shes just smoothing out the rough edges.’ minnie smiled wryly

pg 184 chapter 45

this is ironic because sephy being the person to point out her mum drinking then later on in the book doing the exact same thing following in her mums footsteps which is a metaphor

# data[].attributes.body
““Would you like to see my ID as well?”Sephy held out her pass. “That won’t be necessary, Miss Hadely”” - page 104 , chapter 24.

This is a interrogative sentence shows the privilege that Sephy is treated with compared to Callum due to after Sephy wants the police officers to take her I’d to the police officers treat her with respect and even call her miss Hadely.

# data[].attributes.body
“Naughts are people,just like us.”

Sephy defends the naughts even after Lola threatens her.this shows how she feels that naughts and crosses are equal and should be treated as such.

# data[].attributes.body
It makes it sound like ... you're in one place and I'm in another, with a huge, great wall between us. P25

suggest the fact that they cant be friends, because they have too many differences between them, and highlights how they will never be accepted in socienty.

# data[].attributes.body
“Everyone’s controlling my life except me” - Chapter 57, she understands that she needs to take initiative on her life and do what she wants.

techniques:

metaphor “everyone’s controlling my life”

hyperbole, exaggerates the control from others

“I just drink because . . . Well, because” - Chapter 53, without realizing, she starts to follow her mother’s footsteps, and can’t find a reason to why she is drinking. She has the privilege to drink away her problems.

# data[].attributes.body
“I lay on my stomach and punched the sand, my body bathed in sweat. And again, and again. Until I was pounding it with both fists. Until my knuckles were red raw and bleeding. And I wished more than anything else in the world that the sand beneath my fists was sethy’s face.” Will

# data[].attributes.body
"She knew she would be safe in her compartment, surrounded by other Crosses. No one would dare to harm her here."

Chapter 26

# data[].attributes.body
"I was beginning to realise just how much id taken for granted she had previously ignored due to her privilege

# data[].attributes.body
worse than animals, like blankers! P50

👺

# data[].attributes.body
“i’m not a moron.

No your worse. you’re a drunk. a lush. an alcy

i covered my ears. don’t say that. that’s enough.”

this shows that callum is hurting sephy and making her emotions worse than they already are instead of being empathetic towards her and help her

“your a drunk. a lush. an alcy.”

short sentence shows aggression and anger

tripartite list reflects how bad she is

# data[].attributes.body
Chapter 24 Page 104, “Persephone Hadley. My dad’ the Home Office Minister, Kamal Hadley. Callum is my friend.”
‘That won’t be necessary Miss Hadley.’ Moustaches almost bowed.”

When Callum is asked where he got the ticket then Sephy has to intervene to say that she bought the tickets, and had to tell the officer that her dad was Office Minister.

# data[].attributes.body
“You’re still my princess aren’t you?”asked dad hugging me. “I nodded trying to get past the lump in my throat trying not to spill the water”

Refers to how she doesn’t agree with her dad and is trying to hide it away when he calls her his princess when all he is doing to her mentally is crushing her so she has to hide her real feelings.

# data[].attributes.body
“Persephone Hadley, My dad’s the home office minister, kamal Hadley.”

Sephys power and privilege can be shown here when she uses her father, who’s has a powerful position, as a threat to an officer to gain special treatment

# data[].attributes.body
‘The first sip almost made me gag. It tasted like refined vinegar, what did mother see in this stuff?’

Links to sephys privilege of having alcohol in her house.

Page201

# data[].attributes.body
Chapter 47 Page 188 “ ‘ The ones we tried in Roberts & Miller,’ Mum replied. That was four shoe shops ago.

Depicts that she has privilege as she can go to many shoe shops and choose whichever one they want.

# data[].attributes.body
Page 110

“And there were so many differences, they swamped the similarities”

This is sephy trying to say that all people are the same but they are treated differently just because of their skin colour.

Not their personality or actions, but by the skin colour

There is a metaphor in this quote and there is juxtaposition

# data[].attributes.body
‘Blanker lover… you’ve had this coming for a long time’ she said softly. “And then she let me have it”

# data[].attributes.body
“It’s just a word,callum.”

Sephy uses the word blanker, a racial slur, to describe people who are worse than animals and is too naive to realize the severity of the word

# data[].attributes.body
They all belong to the liberation militia and all they do is cause trouble and commit crimes and stuff like that…’
I stared at them astounded.they can’t really be serious.’

# data[].attributes.body
“Away from them. Away from callus. Ran for my life. I could never hear them yelling behind me. Not the words. I didnt try to decipher the words”

# data[].attributes.body
“Be what you have to be, Callum, not what you are… I repeated that phrase over and over in my head”

# data[].attributes.body
Chapter 94

“Be what you have to be, Callum, not what you are.”

# data[].attributes.body
the cut was deep. too deep, even a scratch would be too deep

# data[].attributes.body
“I never realized how powerful words could be until they turned from sticks into knives and stabbed me in the heart.”

# data[].attributes.body
Be what you have to be, callum, not what you are

# data[].attributes.body
"dont hate me for wanting change the way things are"

# data[].attributes.body
“In that instant, I hated her. Truly hated her. And for the first time ever, I knew without a shadow of doubt that she hated me too.”

Chapter 92

# data[].attributes.body
“I can’t stop thinking about what might have been… I can’t stop imagining the two of us together. My body burns at the thought of it. Sephy and I might’ve been together for ever.”

# data[].attributes.body
“shut up! shut up… ignore her callum just ignore her

shows he is still loving and caring even after everything that happened

# data[].attributes.body
Chapter 94

“We had Sephy. NO! Not Sephy… Just a Cross girl.”

# data[].attributes.body
“Be what you have to be, Callum, not what you are” - nidhi

# data[].attributes.body
Page 359

“We had Sephy. No! Not Sephy… Just a cross girl”

# data[].attributes.body
“Just because I was a nought didn’t mean I had to accept my place in life without question. I wouldn’t .

# data[].attributes.body
‘The cut was deeper than I intended , a scratch would have been deeper than i have intended.’

# data[].attributes.body
We had sephy.No! Not sephy...just a cross girl

Shows how he still cares about sephy and how he doesn't want to harm her

# data[].attributes.body
now i know whose side ur on juse to callum