# data[].attributes.headline
How to made a valid Cross-Ref (Reliable)

# data[].attributes.subject
How to made a valid Cross-Ref (Reliable)

# data[].attributes.body
Source A is reliable as it is supported by Source (?). Source A tells me that (Inf). Source A states (Evi). This means that (Exp). Similarly, Source (?) tells me that (Inf). Source (?) states (Evi). This means that (Exp). Since Source (?) Supports Source A, Source A is reliable.

# data[].attributes.headline
How to make a valid Cross-Ref (UNreliable)

# data[].attributes.subject
How to make a valid Cross-Ref (UNreliable)

# data[].attributes.body
Source A is unreliable as it is rejected by Source (?). Source A tells me that (Inf). Source A states (Evi). This means that (Exp). However, Source (?) tells me that (Inf). Source (?) states (Evi). This means that (Exp). Since Source (?) rejects Source A, Source A is unreliable.

# data[].attributes.body
Source A is reliable as it is supported by source F. Source A tells me that Singaporeans are impatient. Source A states that Singaporeans are impatient to board the train despite the crowd. This means that Singaporeans are ungracious. Similarly, Source F also claims that Singaporeans displays negative behaviour. Source F states that " no one offered her a seat on the MRT, people pretended to sleep or not notice". This means that Singaporeans won't offer their seat even when there is someone who needs it more than they do and are hence ungracious. Since source F supports source A, Source A is reliable.

# data[].attributes.headline
soonkeong , xavier , zixuan , eddie , jaron

# data[].attributes.subject
soonkeong , xavier , zixuan , eddie , jaron

# data[].attributes.body
Source A is reliable in telling me that Singaporeans are ungracious . Source A is reliable as it is supported by Source C . Source A tells me that Singaporeans are impatient and ungracious , Source A shows a cartoon strip of a man being stuck at the MRT door as people are trying to enter the train . This means that Singaporeans are impatient as they cannot wait to enter the train without letting the passengers out first . Similarly , Source C tells me that Singaporeans are ungracious . Source C states that Singaporeans did not give up their seats to a pregnant lady and nobody asked whether she was alright . This means that Singaporeans are ungracious as nobody cared about the Pregnant lady and not a single one gave up their seats for her . Since Source C supports Source A , Source A is reliable .

# data[].attributes.body
Source A is reliable as it is supported by Source C. Source A tells me that Singaporeans are very inconsiderate to others. Source A shows me that Singaporeans were very impatient and couldnt give way to other people. This means that Singaporeans are very inconsiderate as shown in the comics, they wouldnt give way to each other and all rushed inside the mrt. Similarly, Source C tells me that Singaporeans are very self centred and only care about themselves. Source C states that no one bothered to help the journalist when she was feeling very unwell and no one checked on her or offered their seats. This means that Singaporeans only care about themselves as they did not bother to help the unwell british journalist when she was feeling unwell. Since Source C supports Source A, Source A is reliable

# data[].attributes.body
Source A is unreliable as it is rejected by Source B. Source A tells me that  Singaporeans at the MRT were ungracious as the comic strip shows that a guy was at his stop wanting to go out from the MRT. When the MRT opens, people were impatient as they just went in the MRT instead of giving time to people who need to go out from the MRT. This means that Singaporeans were ungracious. However, Source B tells me that Singaporeans are willing to offer a helping hand to people in need. This means that Singaporeans are gracious towards the people. Since Source B rejects Source A, Source A is unreliable.

# data[].attributes.body
Source A is unreliable as it is rejected by Source B.Source A tells me that singaporeans are impatient, ignoring other people when boarding the trains.Source A states that during rush hours singaporeans tend to ignore other peoples needs when boarding the train since they put themselves first and ignore other people leaving the train and not giving them space to leave and causing a jam at the train doors .This means that singaporeans are impatient and selfish people . However ,Source B tells me that singapores are benevolent and respectful .Source B states an old woman giving up her seat to an injured person and another young man giving up his seat to the old woman so that she is able to seat and the slogan says"make it right for a better ride".This means that singaporeans are very caring as the old woman and the young man offered their seat instead of just letting them stand .Since Source B rejects Source A, Source A is unreliable.

# data[].attributes.headline
zixuan , soonkeong , eddie , xavier , jaron

# data[].attributes.subject
zixuan , soonkeong , eddie , xavier , jaron

# data[].attributes.body
Source A is unreliable as it is rejected by Source E . Source A tells me that Singaporeans are impatient . Source A shows a Man being stuck in between the MRT doors as people rushed inside . This means that Singaporeans are impatient and ungracious as people did not let the passengers out first but instead rushed onto the train . However , Source E tells me that Singaporeans are Gracious . Source E states that 8 out of 10 Singaporeans gave up their seats for a pregnant lady . This means that Singaporeans are gracious as they were willing to give up their seats for a pregnant lady . Since Source E rejects Source A , Source A is unreliable .

# data[].attributes.body
singapore is not a gracious because they are vv rushing and not patient when they take public transport.....as in source a the cartoon shows the singaporeans not giving way for the ppl that are alighting but js rushing in.source c also tells me that singaporeans are ungracious because there was once a pregnant lady taking the mrt and no one offered her the sit but js ignored her.....

# data[].attributes.body
Source A is unreliable as it is rejected by Source B.Source A tells me that Singaporeans are impatient and therefore ungracious.Source A states that while a guy was trying to go out of the train,a group of people was pushing their way in the train.However,Source B tells me that Singaporeans are being considerate as they are giving up their seats for people who are in need.Source B states that "Give up your seat to those who need it.Make them matter,make it better."This means that Source B shows that Singaporeans are gracious as they give up their seat for those who are in need.Since Source B rejects Source A,Source A is unreliable.

# data[].attributes.body
Source A is unreliable as it is rejected by Source B. Source A tells me that  Singaporeans at the MRT were inconsiderate as it shows that a guy was at his stop wanting to exit out from the MRT. When the MRT opens, people were impatient as they just squeezed as if their competing entering the MRT instead of letting people exit before them entering from the MRT. This means that Singaporeans were inconsiderate. However, Source B tells me that Singaporeans are willing to help people in need. This means that Singaporeans are considerate towards the people. Since Source B rejects Source A, Source A is unreliable.

# data[].attributes.body
source A is reliable as it is supported by source c . source A tells us that s,poreans are really self centred as in the picture in source A shows us that people are not giving way to the people who are alighting the mrt , instead , they are cramming the doorway and rushing into the mrt . this means that source c is the same as source a as source C also tells us that s,poreans are so self centred because when there was a pregnant lady on the mrt , she was not feeling well and she was crouching on the floor with her hands on her head for 15 minutes but no one went to help or ask she was alright . this means that source C supports source A . since source C supports source A , source A is reliable .

# data[].attributes.body
source A is unreliable as it is rejected by source D . Source A tells me that Singaporeans are impatient to board the train and that leads to Singaporeans being ungracious.Source A shows that a man trying to get out of the train but there were many people rushing into the it. This means that Singaporeans are ungracious  by not giving way to people that want to go out which is shown in Source A.However, Source D tells me that,Singaporeans has been stepping up efforts, including reaching out young Singaporeans in school and in community. This shows that Singaporeans are positive and make small acts of kindness

# data[].attributes.headline
Constantine, Kenneth & Jayden Lua (RELIABLE)

# data[].attributes.subject
Constantine, Kenneth & Jayden Lua (RELIABLE)

# data[].attributes.body
Source B is reliable as it is supported by source E. Source B tells me that Singaporeans are willing to help one another and give up their seat to the needy as Source B depicts an elderly lady giving up her seat for a man with a broken leg and another man gave up his seat for the elderly woman. This means that Singaporeans can and will be gracious at times. Similarly, Source E tells me that Singaporeans will help those in need and are gracious. Source E states that eight out of ten times, Singaporeans will give up their seat for a pregnant woman within a few seconds. This means that Singaporeans are willing to help one another. Since source E supports Source B, source B is reliable.

# data[].attributes.body
Source A is reliable in telling me that Singaporeans are not gracious as  source A is reliable as it is supported by Source C. Source A tells me that Singaporeans are impatient and ungracious. The  cartoon shows the passengers alighting at that station being pushed around and getting stuck in the middle of the raging crowd as they are unable to alight without others pushing them away and rushing to board the train.This tells us that Singaporeans are impatient and ungracious as they are impatient  to enter the train without letting the passengers out alight. Source C also  tells me that Singaporeans are ungracious as Source C states that Singaporeans did not offer a seat to a pregnant lady in need and did not check up on her as she looked like she needed help . This means that Singaporeans are ungracious as no one cares about others and are selfish as they only think about themselves. Source A is reliable as Source C provides evidence on how singaporeans are impatient and ungracious

# data[].attributes.body
Singapore is not graceful as they are not willing to give up their seat when they see a pregnant lady and they are just acting that they are sleeping or didn't even notice them..